What is really tragic is that Michael Moore's film, "Roger & Me" was released almost 30 years ago, and the destruction of the American worker that he so expertly portrayed has only accelerated since then.
Published August 22, 2014
DETROIT—Rochelle McCaskill was in her bathroom about to rinse the soap off her hands when the water stopped. Slowed by lupus and other ailments, she made her way to a bedroom window, peered out, and spotted a guy fiddling with her water valve.
"There must be a mistake," she yelled down.
McCaskill explained that she had just paid $80 on her $540.41 overdue bill, enough, she thought, to avoid a shutoff. The man wasn't interested in the details. He cranked off her water and marked the sidewalk by her valve with bright blue spray paint, a humiliation inflicted on delinquent customers that McCaskill likened to "a scarlet letter." Then he drove off in a truck with the red, white, and black logo dreaded citywide: "Detroit Water Collections Project."
Nearly 19,500 Detroiters have had their water service interrupted since March 1. The Water and Sewerage Department, under pressure to reduce more than $90 million in bad debt, ordered shutoffs for customers who owed at least $150 or had fallen at least two months behind on their bills. The decision to take such drastic measures, done with little warning, ignited a controversy that prompted protests and arrests, more bad publicity for the struggling city, global dismay, and a warning from the United Nations.
As unusual as it is for the U.N. to raise public health concerns in a country like the United States, these are unusual times in Detroit. The fortunes of this once-prosperous home of the auto industry have plummeted so far that last year it became the largest city ever to file for bankruptcy. The population has dropped from nearly 1.8 million a half century ago to fewer than 700,000 today. Democratic rule was suspended last year when Michigan's governor appointed an emergency manager to take control.
Now, although Detroit was founded on a river, draws its name from a French word for "strait," and lies between two of the Great Lakes, water has become scarce for some of its poorest residents. With more than 40 percent of Detroiters living in poverty, the highest big-city rate in the nation, scraping together the money for something as basic as water can be a struggle unfamiliar to most American households.
Despite her illnesses, McCaskill, 54, still speaks and moves with the good-natured resolve that must have served her well during the 23 years she worked as a patient care assistant for hospice patients. Now on disability, her $672 monthly check covers only her $600 rent and minimal groceries without help from her family. A native Detroiter, she knows her way around a city whose services have been mostly in decline during her lifetime. But living without running water?
Photographs by Danny Wilcox Frazier
"I started crying," she recalled. "I was frightened."
I first encountered McCaskill five days later, on a cloudy Saturday morning in early August. Some 400 Detroiters descended on the water department's east side customer service office, queued up to discuss payment plans to restore or preserve their water. When McCaskill and her daughter, L'Oréal, 25, stepped out of the building, they were surrounded by a chaotic scene: police officers patrolling on horseback, protesters shouting over loudspeakers, activists in reflective safety vests arguing with city workers.
But McCaskill had good news: The city had agreed to turn her water back on. The news prompted one of the activists, Justin Wedes of the Detroit Water Brigade, to give her a big hug.
It had been quite a week. Returning home, McCaskill apologized for the broken blinds as she ushered me into the compact living room where she spends much of her day, often in the company of energetic children whose playthings include the blinds. With her niece, Selena, ten, perched next to her on a small brown couch, McCaskill showed me a letter from her doctor stating that she needs a hot bath with bleach every day to treat a persistent staph infection.
With no water, she recalled, "I had no idea what I was going to do."
What happened next to McCaskill is a story that has been repeated across a city that's emerging as one of America's most intriguing, if still deeply troubled, urban centers. Municipal ineptitude and human misery are converging with generosity and innovation. Neighbors across the street and people across the nation—and even across the border in Canada—stepped in to help, in some cases creating organizations to assist residents who were not being helped by their own city.
Long-Ignored Water Bills Lead to City Crisis
Like a lot of people, I couldn't imagine what was going on when I first heard about thousands of Detroiters having their water shut off. I no longer live in Detroit, but I worked as a journalist there for more than 15 years and still come often to the city to work on a start-up news operation. I've learned enough about the water department to know that years of lax enforcement had rendered its monthly bills as little more than optional reminders in the budgets of many hard-pressed Detroiters.
When the department was pushed by the city's bankruptcy to remedy that, it skipped such common shutoff alerts as door hangers and failed to deploy enough representatives to help customers. City officials say that every dollar that goes unpaid by one Detroiter must be paid by others and insist that a revised enforcement plan will be fair to all and accommodating to Detroiters unable to pay.
The city is paying a private company $5.6 million to shut off water in homes, but it's unclear how much it is doing to target commercial customers, a dozen with past-due amounts exceeding $100,000 each. The water department shut off water to 157 businesses for nonpayment since March 1, but service has been restored to all of them. About 5,450 homes, an unknown number vacant, remain without water.
To gauge the chaos engulfing the city's collection efforts, take a look at the list of more than 28,000 bills the department describes as "undeliverable" on its website. Among the overdue commercial accounts, you'll find $11,218.36 for Ford Field, where the National Football League's Detroit Lions play their home games. In the bill-pay section of the site, the same address also is associated with J.L. Hudson, the department store that was demolished in 1998.
In July and August, I spoke with a wide range of Detroiters affected by the water crisis, some of them waterless, many recently so and still more in fear of becoming so. Thousands have spent time this summer in all three categories.
More than 80 percent of Detroiters are African-American, but the city's water troubles seep indiscriminately across color, age, and circumstance. I spoke with Arab-Americans, African-Americans, Mexican-Americans, and whites—young and old—struggling to keep water running in their homes.
Robin Wilson, 59, a retired narcotics officer already supporting the city's recovery efforts through taking an expected cut in her police pension, was livid when she emerged from the water department's customer service center downtown. After having her water turned off, then on, she found herself back on the shutoff list. Her latest trouble? Failing to pay the $100 turn-on fee.
In late July, the emergency manager returned control of the department to City Hall. After years of corruption and place-holding in the mayor's office, the new guy, Mike Duggan, has already made an impact. His latest Detroit Dashboard shows 723 streetlights installed, 768 tons of illegal dumping hauled away, and 296 blighted homes removed. "Had I been given charge of the water department when I asked for it, this never would have happened," he said. "It was very frustrating to watch what I thought was a preventable problem."
Under the system that wreaked so much havoc, Duggan said, residents "didn't know whether the shutoff would happen in a week or a year." He said residents behind on the bills now would find a clear, seven-day warning on their doorknobs before losing their water. Besides streamlining a process that has created so many "frustrated and angry customers," the mayor says the department will add 50 customer service workers. He also says that Detroiters unable to pay will find it easier to get help.
Duggan is especially critical of the bureaucratic obstacles erected by the water department: "We had people who got to the front of the line and said, 'I want to pay my mom's water bill,' and they were told, 'You'll have to prove that your mom lives in that house.'"
That's the sort of policy that's left 42-year-old Kenya Jones and her family without water for the past month. Her overdue bill of $866.40 was complicated because the account was in the name of her 20-year-old son, Adonnis. She hopes to get the water flowing again next week by putting the account in her name and making a payment of $112, money earned from her job packing tomatoes for $8 an hour.
In the meantime, the Jones family fills buckets and milk jugs with water each evening at a recently vacated house in the neighborhood that still has service, and hauls them home.
Built on Water, Detroit Struggles to Bring It to Citizens
Water has played a critical role in Detroit for more than three centuries.
Just last month, the home of the 313 telephone area code celebrated the 313th anniversary of the day French explorer Antoine de la Mothe Cadillac steered his canoe to the shore of the river he called Détroit du Lac Érié, for "Strait of Lake Erie." The three-acre fortress he founded would become the biggest city in the state known as the Great Lakes State, a big mitten surrounded by 84 percent of North America's surface freshwater.
As the city entered its second century in the early 1800s, the population of 2,000 was still getting its water in buckets and barrels hauled from the Detroit River by hand and two-wheeled carts. Horse-powered pumps and pipes made of hollowed-out logs took their place.
It wasn't too long after the city began delivering water to people's homes that it also started turning it off. This ad appeared in Detroit newspapers on April 10, 1845:
PAY YOUR WATER TAXES—Every man and woman who does not pay up by Monday … will be reported to the Council, and the water in every case shut off. I am not joking.
— Morgan Bates, City Collector
Then as now, it became clear that simply turning off the water was no way to run a city that was home to people of varying means. In 1854, the water department installed special hydrants at nine locations aimed at making clean water available to anyone who needed it. The move was hailed at the time as a smart way to "promote the health of the poorer classes."
A century and a half later, Detroit's shutoffs prompted U.N. human rights experts to declare that access to water is such a fundamental human right that it should be denied only to people who are able to pay for it but refuse to do so.
In Detroit, Across the Country, People Step Up to Help
The ability to pay is at the heart of countless debates these days in Detroit, as bankruptcy attorneys argue on behalf of retirees, debtors, and vendors owed money by the city. Amid the turmoil, many Detroiters are left to look out for one another.
Harriet Green, 45, lives in a modest brick bungalow across the street from McCaskill. As soon as she spotted the water truck, she knew what was up. Although she had never met McCaskill and didn't know her name until I told her, Green filled a couple of jugs with water and lugged them across the street. "I had my water turned off a couple of years ago," she told me. "I know what it's like."
Relieved to have some water in the house, McCaskill said she closed her eyes and prayed. "Then my friend's name popped into my head, and I knew who to call." As McCaskill tells it, Valerie Burris, her friend from Mumford High School, "has Facebook and knows all that stuff!"
She says, "Valerie told me, 'Don't worry, Rochelle. I got you!'"
Burris contacted the Detroit Water Brigade, which Wedes helped start in June. A Detroit-area native who helped launch Occupy Wall Street, the movement protesting economic inequality, Wedes returned home from Brooklyn when he heard about the shutoffs. Before McCaskill had used up the water delivered by her neighbor, the Water Brigade was on her porch with more.
"People are outraged at the idea of denying water to people who need it," Wedes said as he and Brigade colleague DeMeeko Williams unloaded water from a rental car.
The group enlists volunteers, raises donations (more than $31,000 so far), and tracks developments on its Facebook page and Twitter feed. Wedes knows how to exploit those platforms. He supports himself as a freelance Web designer and social media consultant, and still directs social media for the Occupy movement.
Social media and news reports about the crisis also have inspired volunteers with no ties to Detroit. In July, for example, a group of Canadians drove 750 gallons of water in a seven-vehicle caravan through the tunnel beneath the Detroit River to City Hall.
In Salt Lake City, 31-year-old Shannon Harton learned about the water crisis after clicking on a Facebook link to a Huffington Post article about Detroit. By the time she finished soliciting contributions via Facebook and email, Harton had raised about $500 and spent about $3,000 of her own money to buy and ship more than 9,000 bottles of water and to cover travel costs for herself and a friend, who helped distribute the water.
"This stirred something within me," Harton told me by phone. "I've been telling everybody I know about the situation, and a lot of people don't believe me at first, asking me, 'Are you sure? Is this really happening in Michigan?'"
Another conversation—this one on Twitter between two women on opposite sides of the country—led to an initiative called the Detroit Water Project.
"Is there a directory … where people in Detroit can go for water relief?" tweeted Tiffani Bell, a 29-year-old in Oakland, California, who works with Code for America, a nonprofit that seeks to use technology to solve community problems.
Kristy Tillman, 30, a digital designer working for a start-up in Boston, tweeted back: "@tiffani I have been asking this, too. I'd pay someone's water bill if I could pay directly."
@tiffani I have been asking this too. I’d pay someone’s water bill if I could pay directly.— Kristy Tillman (@KristyT) July 17, 2014
Three weeks later, the project they built had poured more than $84,000 into the water department on behalf of more than 700 customers. The founders and their team are struggling to keep up with more than 8,000 volunteers who have registered on their site. Offers have ranged from $1 to $2,500.
Beth Campbell, an attorney in Sacramento, California, offered to pay a bill up to $100 and was matched with a recipient whose bill was just over $95. "I have no personal or family connection to Detroit except that I used to date someone who was from there," Campbell wrote in an email. "I'm just horrified by what is happening to the people who can't pay their water bills."
Ross Howard, a 45-year-old single father of seven, described his reaction to learning that his overdue bill of $773.56 had been paid by the Detroit Water Project: "I cried like a baby."
When I asked him what kind of work he does, he answered: "I'm a social worker, believe it or not."
In pursuit of a 21st-century version of those special hydrants, Tillman said they're now exploring how the water department might connect customers in need with agencies offering help. "What started us down this road is a strong point of view of using tech for good," Tillman explained.
But like so much of what's unfolding these days in Detroit, optimism about emerging solutions is filtered through the reality of new and persistent problems. Just four days after Duggan announced plans to ease the shutoffs, the city was hit with the biggest rainfall and worst flooding in 89 years.
With a new round of enforcement set to begin Monday, the water department is introducing a new smartphone application aimed at enlisting citizen help with one of the great ironies of its water crisis: the wasted water spraying from broken pipes in many of the city's 78,000 abandoned buildings. Living up to the name that city leaders chose for the app won't be easy: Detroit Delivers.
Danny Wilcox Frazier collaborated with author Charlie LeDuff on a photo essay that appears in his book: Detroit: An American Autopsy.
What is really tragic is that Michael Moore's film, "Roger & Me" was released almost 30 years ago, and the destruction of the American worker that he so expertly portrayed has only accelerated since then.
I cannot believe what I'm seeing here in America. On the first picture it reminds me a lot of my childhood on the 50's when I was in Mexico but that was then! I thought I would never going to see was happening specially in Detroit what a shame. We send food an water to another countries for them to survive but we don't see our own suffering.
the only difference between the prosperous Detroit of yesterday and the poverty stricken Detroit of today is the absence of an abundance of decent paying jobs. end of story.
Update: Kristy Tillman of the Detroit Water Project reports that, as of Sunday, the group's volunteers have paid $100,000 in overdue water bills to the Detroit Water Department, clearing the way of hundreds of Detroiters to get their water back or keep it flowing.
The damage done to Detroit is unprecedented in that it stands alone in terms of widespread degree of severity within in American city . Sure, many cities face or have faced similar but smaller scale problems attributed in part to financial downfall that snowballed very quickly - but the visible dilapidation and unbridled chaos within that metro cannot match or be compared to any other in the nation.
Detroit is now dying in rapidly noticeable fashion because of an epic failure to proactively identify and address ingredients of implosion until it was too late...and even then, did those who COULD have made a difference care enough to even try?
Many of the movers and shakers of the motor city abandoned home town pride and unity to adopt a 'law of the jungle' state of mind...fight or flight...every man for himself, etc. But NOBODY chose to stay and fight unless financially forced to.
Without a cent to spend and without any sense of stability...many whom were already part of the growing legions of low-income, hard-knock demographic will become contagiously devilish.
Random and relentless crime waves will inevitably flood almost anyplace ...when potential perps know full well that police are no longer able to protect victims-to-be.
When things like water and square meals become luxury items, resentment and desperation seems to justify violence and lawlessness among capable criminals who may or may not have engaged in crime BEFORE simple survival became a serious and widespread concern .
This phenomenon is by no means acceptable but how it came to be IS understandable. As in every city in any country, the have-nots who also happen to be void of empathy or sanity WILL track and attack whomever has what they want or need. THEN, fear among decent people in declining neighborhoods breeds legitimate paranoia. Previously docile folks are now arming themselves in response ... ready to kill or be killed.
There will be no significant improvement for the people of Detroit who are living on the edge of losing what little they have left. Many stay hidden inside behind locked doors....unable to even take a daytime walk without worrying about the exploding population of orphaned/stray dogs roaming almost EVERY street and also desperately wanting to eat. The video footage of this is unnervingly similar to watching a sci-fi movie with a post apocalyptic plot. There are believed to be as many unchained dogs wandering in Detroit, as there are total number of people living in the city of nearby Flint.
On a positive note, there ARE also a number of small groups and individuals who are slowly making progress when it comes to stopping the proverbial bleeding in Detroit. However, there need to be more major players ready to join the massive mission to resurrect and restore. More HEROS are needed if hopes of a happy ending can be achieved!
Sad to see this thing happening in America. Rather than increasing pentagon budget by the govt, money would be well spent if basic necessities are provided to weaker class. The lawmakers need to take a page out of India and install free water taps every 50 mtrs for the poor to use. It helps poor people a lot. The state governments in India only charge people with dedicated water supply and that too for less than 5$/month for an average household. If such measures are installed in US, poor people will benefit a lot.
This is to Christine Blair, This is not the place for your own personal billboard! This is a respected magazine called National Geographic, A place that people. Like to read about what is important in. The World and even their own home town. Please take your comments some other place, We are only interested in comments regarding the Detroit Water Problems. If you have a comment about this article then I'm sure people will be happy to read it and comment back to you.
I think I can speak for the majority of the people that have taken the time to ad this story, And if they disagree with me I welcome their comments back.
Thank You, Dwayne LaGrou
Well, here in the UK (and throughout Europe) it's illegal for a water company to disconnect the water supply of a customer - even if they do owe money! Clean water is essential - not just to remain healthy and well - but it's essential to maintain life itself! That's especially so for children and the elderly. That's why a water customer in debt cannot have their water cut off.
If a water customer does owe money in the UK or Europe the water company must leave the water supply on but pursue the debt through the local civil or small-claims court. The outstanding amount is then recovered from any income or property the customer might have. If the debt proves to be unrecoverable then it's usually waived, especially for the elderly or those with children - still without the water being disconnected!
It's a disgrace that water companies in the US are permitted to disconnect water supplies to those who can't afford to pay. It's a brutal thing to do and it can only adversely affect peoples' health - which ultimately rebounds on society and the tax payer in social discontent and increased health costs.
Argentine model Jesica Cirio Topless Bikini’s Pictures.
They should publish the name of the company hired to shut off the water so we can track down these terrorists and let them know we won't tolerate their evil actions any longer.
If you are not part of the solution, you are the problem.
And this is America at its DEMOCRATIC finest. You had better look long and deep at these pictures because in just a few months this is what the majority of this country is going to look like. And when you take food and water away from enough people because of your failed international problems, those people are going to come looking for yours. People will do ANYTHING to eat and drink. Damn sure won't be any buffet lines to fall back on because you ain't got money. Thank you Obama, Pelosi, Reid, Clinton and the whole DAMNED bunch of DUMBOCRATS.
When I think of Detroit or see images from it - it is always about the crime rate and foreclosures. I never imagined that that city would turn on their residents by denying them water. Fascinating story and images. Thank you.
@Chris Jax Thanks for your comment, Chris. It can be difficult to sort fact from hyperbole in many stories about Detroit these days. Nancy Kaffer of the Detroit Free Press did a good job debunking the stray dog tale here: http://www.freep.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=2014301240027.
@Aaron M I agree with Aaron M
@Dwayne LaGrou Same thing for Steven Kate -
@Phillip Lake The people who created the problems in Detroit no longer live there.The Democrats were not the problem.The problem was the Republicans who let the corporations rob Detroit and other American cities blind and then sent the workers jobs overseas.Detroits missing jobs ore in Mumbai,and Ciudad Juarez,Guangzhou and many other cites where they do not have to pay the workers Medical plans or a living wage.The Democrats did not do this the Bushes and Romney's did this.Because no one stopped them.
The real problem was because the State was put in charge of it and they assigned an "Emergency Manager" that really prevented the Mayor from doing what he knew was right by the people. Mike Duggan was elected Mayor of Detroit with a write in ballot because the city would not let his name be listed on the ballot. And he won anyways. He is the best thing that has happened to Detroit in over 30 Years. He is a real people's Mayor and he has great ideas to bring the city back to the mighty city it used to be. But he keeps running into brick walls when it comes to implementing them because of system is so screwed up with so many obstacles. There are a bunch of Millionaires that are behind the rebuilding of Detroit that are running into the same problems. If they could just get it all going their plans would be the greatest that could possibly happen to the city.
I was born in Detroit and can remember when it was a strong and safe place to live and work in and I still live in a suburb of Detroit and would love to see all of the great plans come together. If they could just get past all of the blockades!!