National Geographic News
Photo of a woman entering a taxi in New York.

New York City has more than 13,000 taxicabs, and riders could be sharing many of them to cut down on traffic and pollution, according to a new study.

Photograph by Frank Heuer, laif/Redux

Christina Nunez

National Geographic

Published September 2, 2014

Many of us have had the deflating experience of arriving in a city by train or plane only to encounter a line at the taxi stand that seems to last longer than the trip to get there. But how many people waiting in that queue at, say, New York City's Penn Station could be sharing cabs to the same destination?

Researchers at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) set out to answer that question, analyzing a year's worth of New York taxi trips. They concluded that the total amount of time that taxis spent traveling could have been reduced 32 percent by shared cabs, with passengers riding no more than an extra five minutes. That reduction in travel time would result in less pollution and traffic, the researchers said, though they did not specify how much. Their work was published Tuesday in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

Carlo Ratti, director of MIT's Senseable City Lab and one of the paper's authors, said the research is meant to quantify the benefits of taxi-sharing. "We were ourselves very surprised with the results, which are quite striking, of how much more efficiently we could use the mobility infrastructure in cities," he said.

The researchers also looked at whether such increased efficiency would be possible in other cities that have a lower density of taxis than New York. "You still find that there's a huge potential for sharing," Ratti said.

City Mobility Evolving

Ride services such as Uber and Lyft have given urban dwellers more options than ever to get around. Instead of hailing a cab, residents of cities around the world now can summon a ride via smartphone from a black SUV driven by a professional, or from a moonlighting civilian driver with a personal car out for hire. For longer trips, drivers can rent from a proliferating fleet of by-the-hour cars offered by services such as Zipcar and car2go, or from car owners who put their vehicles on sharing services. (See related: "U.S. Teenagers Are Driving Much Less: Four Theories About Why" and "Car Sharing Widens Lanes of Access for City Drivers.")

"We've seen with Airbnb that people are ready to share even intimate spaces, in their homes, now that we have systems online that allow you to know better who you're sharing with," Ratti said. Airbnb lets travelers book a stay in all or part of someone's home.

The researchers analyzed 172 million trips made by more than 13,000 taxis in New York City in 2011. On the Senseable City Lab's HubCab website, an interactive map plots all of those trips and helps illustrate the potential for sharing. Let's say you're heading from LaGuardia Airport to the corner of Park Avenue and 57th Street. Including all passenger drop-offs within a quarter-mile radius, according to the map, that same trip occurred about 6,000 times.

If even 2,000 of those trips were prevented as a result of sharing, at an average distance of nine miles from LaGuardia, and with the average vehicle emitting 368 grams of carbon per mile, nearly 7,000 kilograms of carbon emissions would be saved. That amount is roughly equivalent to the emissions from consuming 788 gallons of gas.

Will Riders Want to Share?

The researchers acknowledge, though, that there are "psychological limitations of taxi-sharing" that need to be assessed. Passengers need a clear and straightforward way to split costs, among other factors. As the researchers noted, the potential delay that sharing introduces is an important consideration. When National Geographic informally asked people on social networks whether they would share a cab with a stranger if it meant saving money, answers ranged from "Sure, why not?" to "Depends" to "Nope. I might even pay extra to not have to."

From the taxi driver's perspective, wouldn't a reduction in travel time add up to less income? The MIT researchers point to a 2013 paper from Microsoft Research and the University of Illinois that modeled a taxi-sharing scheme in Beijing. In their scenario, drivers' profit would actually increase by an average of 16 percent, while riders would save 42 percent. In that model, drivers would charge a higher fare per mile for multiple riders. Ratti also noted, "If prices go down, a new category of people might start taking taxis, hence increasing demand."

John Boit, spokesperson for the Taxicab, Limousine & Paratransit Association, noted that an experiment with cab-sharing about 20 years ago in Chicago failed because people didn't want to do it. But he said the industry isn't necessarily against the concept. "If the attitudes in America have changed and if people are more willing to do this," he said, "then obviously the industry would change with that shifting cultural idea."

Some start-ups are trying to promote that shift. Bandwagon, which makes an app that matches travelers headed in the same direction so that they can share livery cars or traditional taxis, has focused its service on high-volume hubs such as airports and conferences. It has also experimented with offering a sort of HOV lane at for taxi lines at the Consumer Electronics Show in Las Vegas, where sharers get priority access to cabs.

The customer reaction to taxi-sharing is "really context-specific," said David Mahfouda, Bandwagon's CEO. He said that when the company has run its service at a convention center for a conference, "people see the fact that they can share the ride with another passenger as a value-add. You're there for networking." At airports, too, Mahfouda said, sharing is an easier sell: "When you're traveling, you're already part of a community of travelers, and you've already spent an hour—or three hours—sharing a plane."

Uber has also embraced the idea of sharing with the trial launch this month of UberPool, which will match sharing-friendly users of the car service, potentially reducing prices for riders by 40 percent, the company said in a blog post. At the lower prices, "Uber really is cost-competitive with owning a car, which is a game-changer for consumers," it said, but warned, "there will undoubtedly be kinks and surprises to work through."

Ratti said his center's research, which is also evaluating the possible impact of self-driving cars, is focused on the question: "How are intelligent transportation systems changing the city?" The researchers plan to study the effects of taxi-sharing in other cities, including Singapore, Vienna, and Rio de Janeiro. Ratti ultimately seeks "a general law of shareability," he said, "that basically, given a city, will be able to tell you how well you could share in different neighborhoods."

In the meantime, companies such as Bandwagon and Uber are testing the concept on the ground. Bandwagon's service is primarily active in New York, Montreal, and at specific events for now, but Mahfouda said he is convinced that "dynamic social transit" will be a primary transportation mode in the future, particularly in cities.

"I think the MIT research is fantastic, but it's not a theory project," he said. "It's real. We're doing it."

The story is part of a special series that explores energy issues. For more, visit The Great Energy Challenge.

5 comments
Andrew Booth
Andrew Booth

I would - but it depended who I was sharing the cab with! There would be some individuals I wouldn't get into a car with nor would I want them getting into the car with me!  

Gordon Davis
Gordon Davis

We can also save energy by giving up electricity and using candles, or by not having kids. People are not going to wait around and pick up other fares, and wait while those other fares are delivered to their homes. Super Shuttle service already exists to most airports, and no one uses it because an hour trip to the airport becomes 2 hrs with the multiple fares. Due to the internet, time is precious and no one is looking for a longer way to perform a task such as commuting. People rich enough to take a taxi want speed, or else they would walk or take public transportation. Silliest article I have seen all year.

Ajay Saxena
Ajay Saxena

Simple solution like having a colored light on taxi-roof will let people know that taxi is up for sharing. First passenger may get preference of reaching destination. Second passenger may not be allowed if the destination is say 5 km from first destination. GPS can help greatly. Expenses may be shared through bargain or standards may be set. 

Carter Fox Jr.
Carter Fox Jr.

I ride a bike! No Gas, No emissions, and no insurance costs. Repairs are simple, and I get a good workout in the long run. That's the way to reduce carbon monoxide in the air. And it sure beats paying house payments just to ride.

Joy Saldanha
Joy Saldanha

Simply just reading the head lines of the article about taxi sharing,reminds me of years ago in Bombay,that this went on with people sharing taxi's from Bandra,to the city. A ride of about an hour,depending on traffic. I,myself did it more than once,cutting my expense in half,and helping with my drop in the ocean to reduce traffic! Many many people did this every day,to work and back.

Mind, I have only read the headline of the article.Will it work here,it depends on many factors.So I leave it to people to choose.

Recent Energy News

See More at The Great Energy Challenge »

The Big Energy Question

Share Your Opinion »

The Great Energy Challenge

The Great Energy Challenge is an important National Geographic initiative designed to help all of us better understand the breadth and depth of our current energy situation.

Energy News, Blog and Interactive Features »

Shop Our Space Collection

  • Be the First to Own <i>Cosmos: A Spacetime Odyssey</i>

    Be the First to Own Cosmos: A Spacetime Odyssey

    The updated companion book to Carl Sagan's Cosmos, featuring a new forward by Neil deGrasse Tyson is now available. Proceeds support our mission programs, which protect species, habitats, and cultures.

Shop Now »