National Geographic News
A photo of Wilma, a reconstruction of a nude Neanderthal female.

Neanderthals, like the one in this reconstruction, were long seen as strict carnivores.

PHOTOGRAPH BY JOE MCNALLY, NATIONAL GEOGRAPHIC

Dan Vergano

National Geographic

Published June 25, 2014

Want the real poop on the Paleolithic Diet? Discovery of the oldest human fecal fossils, some 50,000 years old, suggests that Neanderthals balanced their meat-heavy diet with plenty of veggies.

Ancient human cousins of our own species, Neanderthals disappeared from Europe some 30,000 years ago, around the time that modern humans arrived there. Long seen as strict carnivores, they hunted mammoth and reindeer, as evidenced by bones left at their campsites. (Related: "Last of the Neanderthals.")

However, Neanderthal fecal samples reported in the journal PLOS ONE on Wednesday suggest that they also ate plenty of berries, nuts, and other vegetables.

The oldest poop samples turned up at the site of El Salt, a collection of ancient hearths in southern Spain. The researchers were originally investigating the fire pits for chemical traces of fats from cooked meats. Amid the search, they unexpectedly found some fossil feces, or coprolites, in a top hearth layer dated to 50,000 years ago.

"I was quite surprised we found these samples in a place where they would eat," says MIT geoarchaeologist Ainara Sistiaga, who led the study. "We think they were deposited after they stopped using the fire pit."

The previous record holder for oldest human coprolites unearthed by archaeologists came from Oregon's Paisley Caves and are dated to perhaps 12,300 years ago. Far older fecal samples from dinosaurs and ancient sharks have also been uncovered by researchers.

A photo of the sediment where the oldest human feces was discovered.
This fire pit holding fecal fossils was uncovered in southern Spain.
PHOTOGRAPH BY BERTILA GALVÁN

Dietary Surprise

For clues to the Neanderthal diet, lab samples of the feces were pulverized and examined for spectroscopic identification of their chemistry. In particular, the researchers looked for compounds created when bacteria aid digestion of meat and vegetables. (Related: "Hot Stew in the Ice Age?")

The results identified four fats associated with meat. But two cholesterol-related compounds that are an unambiguous fingerprint of plants also turned up.

"They were eating a lot of meat," Sistiaga says. "But we believe they were omnivorous."

Although the chemistry analysis cannot specify which plant foods Neanderthals were eating, pollen analysis suggests that berries, nuts, and tubers grew in the region when the archaic humans lived in Spain. (Related: "Bonanza of Skulls in 'Pit of Bones' Changes View of Neanderthals.")

Mammoth, reindeer, and red deer bones widely found at Neanderthal sites had led paleontologists to see them as dedicated meat eaters. But more recent studies that uncovered plant remains at Neanderthal sites, on their tools, and even in their dental plaque had hinted that they were not strict carnivores.

The present study is the first to provide direct chemical analysis that Neanderthals ate vegetables—the most interesting part of the study, says paleontologist Erik Trinkaus of Washington University in St. Louis, who was not part of the research.

"Their results are confirming an idea that is still somewhat new in the field," says paleobiologist Amanda Henry of Germany's Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology in Leipzig. But she cautions that more evidence showing that the fecal samples undoubtedly came from Neanderthals, and not from another omnivorous animal such as bears, would be reassuring.

Sisiaga's team argues that the digestive compounds found in their analysis are present in ratios found only in humans. But Henry says by email that their argument would be bolstered with a deeper analysis: "I think the paper would have been stronger if they had used an independent means of identifying the coprolite, perhaps looking for human DNA or proteins."

The compounds tested for in the El Salt study are "very stable," Sistiaga says. "We are going to try a two-million-year-old sample from another site next."

Neanderthal Extinction

Some researchers have suggested that the Neanderthals' meat-centric diet may have left them open to extinction when they were forced to compete for resources after other omnivorous early modern humans entered their territory, bringing more complex tools with them.

That story looks a little too simple now, even if Neanderthals did have a "meat-dominated" diet, according to the study.

Sistiaga suggests that Neanderthal digestion worked with the help of bacteria similar to the ones at work in our own guts.

The coprolites also revealed that the Neanderthals apparently had parasites, such as hookworms and pinworms, similar to the ones afflicting modern and other ancient people. (Related: "Dangerous Parasites.")

"We were told that people with [as] many parasites as we saw [in the samples] would be very sick," Sistiaga says.

Follow Dan Vergano on Twitter.

8 comments
Peter Kraus
Peter Kraus

Congratulations! Now we know what gave neanderthals diarrhea.


So here's my theory:

Neanderthal eats nuts --> neanderthal gets sick --> neanderthal gets diarrhea


I highly doubt Neanderthals were capable of digesting Sorbitol or even Fructose.

Craig Nordmark
Craig Nordmark

The high numbers of parasites may also provide a reason why there was poop around the firepit. Could be that they were too sick to head out to the latrine (or the neanderthal equivalent). One of the first requirements for humanoids to settle down to semi-permanent camps would be to learn not to go where you eat.

Anyone know if wild chimps just go where they are or head to more private areas away from the group?

KENNETH LANE
KENNETH LANE

Mr. Obvious states "No surprise there".  Of coarse early man ate whatever they could find including vegetable matter.   We are opportunists which is part of why we survived.  Great study, especially the parasites remains reminds us of how well we have evolved.  The fecal remains near fire pits is odd to us but for ancient man perhaps not so much.  Could explain the high concentrations of parasites.

Paul Scutts
Paul Scutts

Must have been a teenager, they just love to leave their crap lying around.

R G
R G

Somehow I couldn't have been less surprised if the discovery was simply that, "Neanderthals Pooped Poop".

Did anybody ever really believe "carnivore only"?



Carlos Decourcy Lascoutx
Carlos Decourcy Lascoutx

...the Neander wordstring in Nauatl begins: ma/oma(N)=hunt land/sea with net,=

mati(N)=know,=s/ma(r)ti=smarty,=mati mati ca(N)=mathematics(E)=mimati(N)=

mime(E)=imati(N)=be prudent/perispicaz; to be better/in convalescence, and the tletl/atleti/atletia fire-drill Promethean wordstring in the language they gave us: atle(N)=no, atli(N)=drink water/atl(N), tle?(N)=what? tleco(N)=elect(E), tlei(N)=something, tlein in(N)=what's this?, tleyo(N)=célebre/ilustre/renowned, tlemolli(N)=meals,=molli(ground sauce)=moler(sp)=mill(E). 

Dwayne LaGrou
Dwayne LaGrou

WOW, Leave it to National Geographic to make finding an old turd so interesting and informative!!! I just love it!

Share

How to Feed Our Growing Planet

  • Feed the World

    Feed the World

    National Geographic explores how we can feed the growing population without overwhelming the planet in our food series.

See blogs, stories, photos, and news »

The Innovators Project

See more innovators »

Latest Photos Galleries

See more photos »

Shop Our Space Collection

  • Be the First to Own <i>Cosmos: A Spacetime Odyssey</i>

    Be the First to Own Cosmos: A Spacetime Odyssey

    The updated companion book to Carl Sagan's Cosmos, featuring a new forward by Neil deGrasse Tyson is now available. Proceeds support our mission programs, which protect species, habitats, and cultures.

Shop Now »