PHOTOGRAPH BY PAUL NICKLEN, NATIONAL GEOGRAPHIC CREATIVE
Published June 10, 2014
An extinct species of "very carnivorous" fox with supersharp teeth once roamed the frigid Tibetan Plateau, a new study says.
The fossils of the newly identified Vulpes qiuzhudingi, which lived 3.60 to 5.08 million years ago, in the Pliocene period, are the oldest arctic fox remains ever found. That could make them the earliest known ancestor of today's arctic fox (Alopex lagopus), which ranges throughout the northern poles. (Also see "Arctic Foxes Put Eggs in 'Cold Storage' for Lean Times.")
The discovery also supports the "out of Tibet" theory, which argues that the plateau acted as a "third Pole" where cold-adapted predators lived until they migrated to new lands at the beginning of the Ice Age.
Between 2006 and 2012, scientists unearthed three jaw fossils of the ancient predator while digging in Tibet's Zanda Basin and Kunlun Mountains.
In 2010, the team found an exemplar fossil of a jaw still studded with teeth. "I first uncovered part of the lower molar, and immediately I knew it was some kind of a dog," said study co-author Zhijie Jack Tseng, a paleobiologist at the American Museum of Natural History in New York City.
What Does the Ancient Fox Say?
The fossils were set aside until a few years later, when Tseng and colleagues examined them and discovered the teeth bore a "striking resemblance" to those of the arctic fox, according to the study, published June 10 in the journal Proceedings of the Royal Society B.
For one, the fossils' lower molars lack cusps and are sharper than those of other fox species. This adaptation—which allowed the prehistoric predators to slice into prey—is a clear sign of what's called a "hypercarnivore," or a carnivore that eats mostly meat. Omnivorous foxes have bumpier, duller molars better suited for chewing plants, insects, and small vertebrates, he said.
The extinct fox would've had plenty of meat to choose from: Other fossils found near the remains in Tibet include potential prey species, such as shrews, pikas, voles, and squirrels—all small mammals that today's arctic fox would eat. (See video: "Arctic Fox Raids Polar Bear Kill.")
Eating mostly meat makes sense for polar animals, in part because of the taxing demands of living in such icy cold environments and the scarcity of other food sources, Tseng said. That's likely why, in addition to the arctic fox, other northern carnivores, such as polar bears and gray wolves, are highly predatory.
Polar animals in general also tend to be bigger, possibly because beefier animals lose precious heat more slowly than smaller animals do.
That's also the case with the newfound fox, which was likely 20 percent bigger than the modern-day arctic fox. It was about the size of a male red fox (Vulpes vulpes), the biggest known fox species.
Link Olson, a mammal biologist at the University of Alaska Fairbanks, called it an "interesting hypothesis," but he's "not convinced of the close relationship with the arctic fox."
"As the authors briefly note, this could well be yet another example of convergence"—when two species evolve similar adaptations, Olson said by email.
Olson noted that canines' skulls are "notoriously plastic, even among living species; consider how much variation we see in the heads of domestic dog breeds versus cat breeds."
He added that a rigorous analysis, including a closer look at the fox family tree, "would make for a more compelling case."
Out of Tibet?
To Tseng, the discovery of the ancient fox is more proof for the out of Tibet theory. It goes like this: At the end of the Pliocene, about 2.6 million years ago, it was considerably warmer in the Arctic and colder in Tibet, where a host of animals evolved to cope with the elements. (See a prehistoric time line.)
When global temperatures dropped at the start of the Ice Age, these cold-loving Tibetan animals may have chosen to "step down from the plateau and spread northward toward the vast expanse of Russia, Siberia, and northern Canada, where they became characteristic Ice Age mega-mammals," Tseng said. (See "Pictures: 'Remarkable' Ice Age Fossil Cache Found.")
Indeed, Tseng and his colleagues have discovered that other species, such as the extinct woolly rhinoceros, the hyena, the snow leopard, and now the arctic fox, share roots in the Tibetan Plateau.
University of South Carolina carnivore paleontologist Adam Hartstone-Rose agrees that the "Out of Tibet" theory is a plausible one, noting that modern-day Tibetan animals—such as the yak—resemble Arctic animals.
"This fox fits in that scheme. Obviously it's a little less sexy than the big carnivores, but it's a neat little thing," said Hartstone-Rose, who has studied extinct foxes but wasn't involved in the new study.
"It's exciting to see as [Tseng's group] fleshes out this theory species by species."
Just wondering why this is considered an extinct species when it may be the same species that has just migrated and evolved somewhat over the many years? Unless you mean extinct to Tibet.
"When global temperatures dropped at the start of the Ice Age"
Could the article include the time frame of this event? Which Ice Age?
It seems to me that during an Ice Age it is equally likely that polar species moved south and may have reached a point at which going up into Tibet made as much sense as following the ice back as the earth warmed.
Don't forget the surprising finding of polar bear DNA in supposed "yeti" fur from the Himalayas....
My partner is leading an expedition in the Kunlun as this article went to print. I've just texted him of this news. We both work regularly in Tibet and we've always talked about it as the third pole. It looks like evidence is mounting that Tibet truly is that. Amazing find!
The Himalayas were much smaller millions of years ago so were not at the elevations they are now with all that snow not there yet. Those mountains are still growing as the Indian plate keeps pushing up against an Asian plate.
I wonder what new surprises await as more scientist explore Tibet what new discoveries they find in animal and human origins.
It is truly exciting to read about what is being discovered by careful research and attention to detail on and in the the skin of this beautiful Earth.
It's all hands (and paws) on deck when it comes to the poaching crisis in Africa.
In this new series, writers and photographers from around the world reflect on places that hold special meaning for them.
For Sebastián García Iglesias, the ghosts of his ancestors are stitched to the tapestry of the land they pioneered.
The Future of Food
Food. It's driven nearly everything we've ever done as a species, and yet it's one of the most overlooked aspects of human history.
We've made our magazine's best stories about the future of food available in a free iPad app.