National Geographic News

Julia Harte in Turkey

for National Geographic

Published February 21, 2014

From the Neolithic caves riddling its cliffs to the honey-colored, 15th-century minarets looming over its streets, Hasankeyf, Turkey, is a living museum of epic proportion.

Rare birds soar around the crumbling towers of its Artuqid bridge. Shepherds' songs have echoed through its canyons for centuries, even as the area transformed from a Byzantine bishopric to an Arab fortress to an outpost in the Ottoman Empire. Almost every major Mesopotamian civilization has occupied this 12,000-year-old settlement site on the banks of the Tigris River in southeastern Turkey, not far from the border with Syria.

Map of Turkey and Iraq showing where the Ilisu dam site is located along the Tigris river, in relation to the town of Hasankeyf upstream, and the Mesopotamian marshes in Iraq downstream.
NG STAFF

But today's reigning power, the Turkish Republic, has a unique plan for Hasankeyf: submerging the ancient town beneath 200 feet (60 meters) of water.

That will be the result of a hydroelectric dam now under construction in Ilısu village, 60 miles (97 kilometers) downstream from Hasankeyf. In February 2013, Turkey's highest administrative court ordered construction to halt until an environmental impact assessment had been carried out.

"Then the Turkish government just changed the regulation so that the Ilısu Dam doesn't need an environmental impact assessment," says Dicle Tuba Kılıç, the Hasankeyf campaign coordinator for Turkey's Nature Foundation.

The last major dam to be built under a regional development plan known as the Southeastern Anatolia Project, the Ilısu Dam will generate nearly 2 percent of Turkey's electricity supply, and create an 11-billion-cubic-meter reservoir. Turkish officials say it will open later this year.

The dam joins a list of massive river-blockers that have submerged historic homes and cultural sites worldwide in the last century. During the 1950s, construction of Egypt's Aswan Dam to control the flooding of the Nile led to resettlements and the removal of monuments such as a massive statue of Ramses the Great. China's Three Gorges Dam on the Yangtze, completed in 2012,  caused the relocation of 1.2 million people and the flooding of hundreds of archaeological sites. Brazil's Belo Monte Dam, now under construction, has triggered protests from indigenous people over its planned flooding of 250 square miles (650 square kilometers) of rain forest.

The Ilısu Dam is also expected to reduce the flow of the Tigris into Syria and Iraq, possibly exacerbating a six-year drought that has crippled agriculture in southern Iraq, said Kılıç. Upstream, the reservoir will inundate 300 historical sites and displace more than 25,000 people in Turkish towns along the Tigris, she added.

Aerial image of the Kurdish town of Hasankeyf.
Photograph by John Wreford, Demotix/Corbis
The Tigris River winds through Hasankeyf; the town and its archaeological treasures will be flooded when a new dam is built.

The Nexus of Energy and Culture

Hasankeyf townsfolk understand their country's need for energy.

"We aren't against the dam. But we want a dam that will leave Hasankeyf above the water," says Süleyman Ağalday, a local butcher. Like most of the town's residents, Ağalday is himself a memento of the area's diverse history: He's fluent in Kurdish, Turkish, and an Arabic dialect related to the Bedouin tongue spoken by his forebears.

Only one-fifth of the archeological sites around Hasankeyf have been unearthed so far, and local archeologists predict that 85 percent of the remainder will be flooded before they can finish excavating.

An Arab nomad girl hides behind her mother as she bakes bread for the family.
PHOTOGRAPH BY JULIA HARTE, NATIONAL GEOGRAPHIC GRANTEE
An Arab nomad girl and her mother bake bread in Iraqi Kurdistan. The nomads haul river water in tankers for themselves and their animals.

In 2010, a team from Turkey's Middle East Technical University proposed an alternative plan to Ilısu: five smaller hydroelectric dams along the Tigris that would leave Hasankeyf completely above water. Government officials did not respond specifically to the proposal, but declared that all efforts would be made to preserve Hasankeyf's culture and history.

The Ilısu Dam as planned is crucial to Turkey's future energy security, according to Ahmet Saatçi, director of Turkey's State Water Works, the government authority in charge of constructing the dam.

"Turkey is suffering for energy sources," he says. "We currently have to buy our energy from Russia and other countries, so we're trying to use our renewable energy to its fullest extent."

Doubts and Concerns

So the government has built new houses for the villagers on a nearby hillside, and has promised that Hasankeyf's biggest monuments will be moved.

"In the underwater area, we'll preserve some artifacts that can't be moved, and we'll create a center for tourism that can host diving activities and water sports," says Hasankeyf District Governor Ceyhun Dilşad Taşkın. "Hasankeyf will be transformed into a very modern city in the new settlement site."

"New Hasankeyf" is located on arid, rocky soil that is a stark contrast to the fruit trees and fertile gardens that now fill the backyards of Hasankeyf homes.

A three-bedroom house in the new site will cost 170,000 TL ($85,000), according to signs posted around the town, while residents' current homes have been valuated at one-eighth of that.

The local government arranged a motorcycle show on the banks of the Tigris River in Hasankeyf.
PHOTOGRAPH BY JULIA HARTE, NATIONAL GEOGRAPHIC GRANTEE
A motorcycle show in Hasankeyf was promoted as a nonhistorical attraction for tourists.

Some residents, many of whom already rely on government subsidies, say they don't want to take the government loans they would need to afford the new houses. They say economic opportunities are scarce in this depressed region of Turkey, the site of a three-decade-long civil war between the Kurdistan Workers' Party (PKK) guerilla army and the Turkish state.

So desperate are locals for jobs that even Hasankeyf villagers who oppose the dam have helped build it. Murat Sevinç worked at the site from 2010 to 2012.

"If there weren't so few job opportunities [here], nobody would want to work on something that was going to submerge his home under water," he says. "I don't want my city, my village, to be lost for a project that will last 50 years."

Sevinç said he has doubts about the stability of the concrete casing around the dam, and suggested that too much water was mixed into it.

The Ilısu Dam's project manager, Mahmut Dundar, refused repeated requests for interviews, saying he could not get permission from his superiors at Turkey's State Water Works to comment on the construction.

Regional Water Politics Heat Up

Downstream countries have their own concerns about Ilısu and Turkey's other planned dams.

In Iraq, "there are thousands of water refugees every year," says Bakhtiar Amin, former human rights minister of Iraq. "Many villages are depopulated because of this."

Turkey claims to release 500 cubic meters of river water downstream each second from its dams, but Amin says the actual amount is closer to 200 cubic meters per second.

Local children stand on a wall overlooking the Sultan Suleyman mosque.
PHOTOGRAPH BY JULIA HARTE, NATIONAL GEOGRAPHIC GRANTEE
Children overlook the Sultan Suleyman mosque in Hasankeyf; some argue that tourism could be boosted if the town's historical sites were promoted.

Iraq and Syria have built their own big dams on the Tigris and Euphrates Rivers. But Turkey's dams dominate the rivers, especially the Euphrates. When the 27-billion-cubic-meter-capacity Atatürk Dam opened on that river in 1990, it reduced the mighty waterway to a trickle for one month.

In the Mesopotamian marshes of southern Iraq, which once covered one-fifth of modern Iraq's landmass and which have hosted human civilization since ancient Sumer, the flow of the Euphrates is now sometimes as low as 18 cubic meters per second, compared with the 90 cubic meters per second required to sustain the local population of Marsh Arabs, according to Jassim Al-Asadi, a local director for the non-governmental organization Nature Iraq.

"There won't be any more marsh in Iraq" if Ilısu and the other remaining dams in Turkey's Southeastern Anatolia Project are built, says Al-Asadi. Iraqi officials estimate that the project will dehydrate 670,000 hectares of arable land in the country.

Al-Asadi was born amidst the reeds of the majestic marshlands. As a child, he would paddle in a traditional wooden boat to school, where birds, fish, and snakes wandered through his reed-hut classroom during the flood season.

But the Tigris and Euphrates Rivers are now so low that salty water from the Persian Gulf has rushed in. This has raised river salinity to levels that are unhealthy for marsh wildlife, not to mention the Marsh Arabs, who now buy tanks of potable water in nearby towns and ferry them back to their homes in the marsh.

Agriculture around Iraq's marshes is also suffering from the lower river levels, causing mass urban migration and dozens of conflicts each year. One sheikh estimated that water scarcity caused 20 murders in his province in 2012.

Near Nasiriyah Province, where a 52-year-old farmer recently shot himself in the head after his farm's stream dried up completely, Salim Mihsin Saeed has a small fruit and vegetable farm that doesn't get enough water despite Saeed's high-efficiency drip irrigation system.

"This land used to be a marsh, but the water constructions in Turkey affected our whole country's water quality and quantity," he said last May, gesturing at his tiny tomato plants poking out of the parched earth. He isn't sure whether his farm will survive the next big Turkish dam.

On a larger scale, no one can predict exactly how much social upheaval the Ilısu Dam will cause. But as its construction draws to a close, people across modern Mesopotamia are anxiously waiting to see.

Julia Harte's trip was supported by a Young Explorer grant from the National Geographic Expeditions Council and a Dick Goldensohn Fund grant from the Center for Investigative Reporting.

13 comments
Joyce Stam
Joyce Stam

Such a beautiful and fascinating place when I saw it a few years ago! a shame to flood it all!

aziz alim
aziz alim

Last week in Hasankeyf, saw a heavenly village of centuries-people, location, food, the old majestically beautiful old bridge and monuments can surely and must be preserved with alternatives to the current plan of the dam. 


Yes to dam - various environmental groups have viable suggestions.

No to disappearing Hasankeyf .



Lisa Stallings
Lisa Stallings

The point this report leaves out is the importance of the marshes for the fishery in the Gulf- If the marshes are killed the fish and shrimp won't have a spawning ground, and many more people will (Not to mention lots of other species) will suffer serious consequences.

Ruth Young
Ruth Young

All this for TWO PERCENT of the country's energy?!?!?!

Benoit Azagoh-Kouadio
Benoit Azagoh-Kouadio

We need to learn to use less energy period, that is the essential project of our adaptation if we are to live harmoniously even more so than the rush toward exploiting "renewable" energy. There is no energy deficit in the world for our lives to be full with its wonder but rather a surplus of energy-desire constructed around privileges we are conditioned to believe that we need. There is no question that people in so called "developing countries" should not be excluded from the benefits of electrics, phones, lights, plumbing, the things we in the so called "West" largely take for granted, but the sad reality is that its more than likely the power centers in Istanbul and Ankara that are in the minds of government planners and not the people whose lives and ancestral history are to be submerged and forgotten. How many of these people will even be able to afford "diving activities and water sports"?

Barbara Johnson - Harvey
Barbara Johnson - Harvey

Why are we human beings so destructive? We are destroying the planet and virtually eradicating our heritage and history, it's amazing that our historic ancestors made anything to last all the thousands and hundreds of years, real treasures to help people understand where we have come from and how people lived there lives, and even died, scientists physicists etc can learn from this to supposedly improve our lives, what will we leave behind to find in the future? Probably a baron raped land with a poisonous atmosphere from all our rubbish and destruction of trees and forests, animals are becoming more extinct as we destroy there habitats and environments, inevitably man will destroy himself by destroying the gift of nature around him designed specifically for his own survival through greed, greed of food, minerals, water, and pure luxuries completely unnecessary. I'm sure the reason girl extreme weather conditions and changes all around the world is born from ourselves in trying to change to much and mess around with our environment to much Mother Nature is fighting back and trying her damnedest to redress the balance, the question is who is listening? And what are we doing about it? To many selfish people who don't care as it won't effect their life time without a care of what we leave behind or who it will have an impact on, maybe all the electronic games people play these days desensitises people so killing and destruction becomes the norm as they do it all the time when playing their games?? Especially now the graphics are being improve how life like can it get?

Nixar Osman
Nixar Osman

I appreciate the difficulty and hardship this Ilusu dam would create in Hasankeyf, its historical ruins and also the people in surrounding areas. These are all valid points. However, it would have been a more balanced presentation had the author also consider the positive impact the damn will have both locally and nationally. This article had been written with just damages in mind but not benefits, which should have been given an equal space. This would have enabled us to judge the net impact of constructing such a damn.

Andrew Booth
Andrew Booth

We can't keep destroying our culture and heritage in this manner. 

I know governments only consider the financial aspects today but such gains will be forgotten in even 100 years' time but these sites would have gone forever. Historic sites such as this should be protected so that they are still extant in 2000 years' time.

Caio Fabricius
Caio Fabricius

In the future, the human beings will look at this and regret. It is very sad to live now, in this time, and not having powers to change situations like the construction of these turkey dams.

Lisa Stallings
Lisa Stallings

@Ruth Young and dams have such short life spans- 30-40 years max... and the consequences go on forever.

David M
David M

@Barbara Johnson - Harvey  

So, violent video games are the leading cause of environmental destruction now too?  What won't they cause? : P  I wouldn't have thought the government leaders in charge of constructing these hydroelectric facilities and otherwise maintaining the environment and culture of their nations spend much time playing violent video games, but apparently they do, since they don't seem to care enough about these things.


Really, why bring up video games in your argument at all?  People have been misusing the environment and others to gain money and power for hundreds of years, and I really don't think that had much to do with video games.  Your argument is a good example of people not caring enough to look for the actual causes of problems and how they can be amended, and instead just passing the blame off to any popular scapegoat that they themselves are not directly associated with.  Clearly those 'other' people must be the root of the problem, and your own lifestyle couldn't possibly have any harmful influence over such things.


In any case, those in charge of this construction project likely don't care much about what random people in other countries think about what they're doing.  If they don't care about how the people of their own and neighboring countries are affected, they're probably not going to be influenced much by the opinions of those in nations thousands of miles away.

d. p.
d. p.

@Nixar Osman  Because, Nixar, sometimes there are not two positions with equal moral validity, and to pretend otherwise (under some false pretense of providing "balance") would only confer undeserved legitimacy upon those who wish to steamroll their own citizens and cultural heritage.

Share

The World's Water

The world's increasing population and development of agricultural land are putting pressure on the Earth's limited freshwater supplies. Find out what's at stake and how you can help.

Learn More About Freshwater »

Water Currents, by Sandra Postel and Others

More Posts »

The Future of Food

See more food news, photos, and videos »

Stories From Experts in the Field

Read More Stories »