I don't think I entirely agree with him saying they act just the same. Another study shows how cats don't "meow" to us the same way they do to other cats. They adopt a distinctive sound that they will use with their human ("owner") to get their attention.
PHOTOGRAPH BY FSTOP, ALAMY
Published January 27, 2014
Since cats first got their adorable claws into us about 9,500 years ago, humans have had a love affair with felines.
Today more than 80 million cats reside in U.S. homes, with an estimated three cats for every dog on the planet. (Watch a video about the secret lives of cats.) Yet there's still a lot we don't know about our feline friends—including what they think of their owners.
John Bradshaw is a cat-behavior expert at the University of Bristol and the author of the new book Cat Sense. After observing pet cats for several years, he's come to an intriguing conclusion: They don't really understand us the way dogs do.
Bradshaw recently shared some of his insights with National Geographic.
How did you get into cat behavior?
For the first 20 years of my career I studied olfactory [smell] behavior in invertebrates. I've always been fascinated by this other world that animals live in—primarily of odor, which is dogs' primary sense. So in the early 1980s I started working on dog behavior. [Later] I very quickly became fascinated with cats, and what their idea of the world is compared to the one we have.
What do you do in your research?
A lot of observation—watching groups of cats to see how they interact with one another and deducing their social structure. [I watch] cats in colonies that are free-ranging, and in animal shelters where quite a number will be housed together—you get interesting dynamics [when new cats are introduced].
I've also done slightly more manipulative things, such as studying the way cats play with toys, or testing cat [behaviors] at different times of the day. [I also observe] relationships with owners, interviewing them and giving them questionnaires to find out how they perceive their cats.
Why did you conclude that cats don't "get us" the way dogs do?
There's been a lot of research with dogs and how dogs interact with people. [It's] become very clear that dogs perceive us as being different than themselves: As soon as they see a human, they change their behavior. The way a dog plays with a human is completely different from [the way it plays] with a dog.
We've yet to discover anything about cat behavior that suggests they have a separate box they put us in when they're socializing with us. They obviously know we're bigger than them, but they don't seem to have adapted their social behavior much. Putting their tails up in the air, rubbing around our legs, and sitting beside us and grooming us are exactly what cats do to each other. (Also see "How Cats and People Grew to Love Each Other.")
I've read articles where you've said cats think of us as big, stupid cats. Is that accurate?
No. In the book [I say] that cats behave toward us in a way that's indistinguishable from [how] they would act toward other cats. They do think we're clumsy: Not many cats trip over people, but we trip over cats.
But I don't think they think of us as being dumb and stupid, since cats don't rub on another cat that's inferior to them. (See "Cats Use 'Irresistible' Purr-Whine to Get Their Way.")
Can we discover what cats really think about us?
More research needs to be done. [It's] not an area that's received sufficient attention. [Cats are] not wild animals, so ecologists [might think], 'Well they're not really animals at all.'
What has been most surprising to you in your research?
How stressed a lot of pet cats can be without their owners realizing it, and how much it affects the quality of their mental lives and their health. Cats don't [always] get on with other cats, [and people don't realize] how much that can stress them out. Other than routine visits, the most common reason cats are taken to vets is because of a wound sustained in a fight with another cat.
[More cats are mysteriously getting] dermatitis and cystitis [inflammation of the bladder] and it's becoming abundantly clear that these medical problems are made worse by psychological stress. [For instance], inflammation of the bladder wall is linked to stress hormones in the blood.
One solution is to examine the cat's social lifestyle, instead of pumping it full of drugs. [For example, that could mean making sure] two cats that [don't get along] live at opposite ends of the house. Quite often the whole problem goes away.
I have a few questions from cat owners on Facebook. First, why might a cat yowl when it's by itself in a room?
Cats learn specifically how their owners react when they make particular noises. So if the cat thinks, 'I want to get my owner from the other room,' it works to vocalize. They use straightforward learning. (Learn about National Geographic's Little Kitties for Big Cats initiative.)
Why do some cats treat one human member of the household differently?
They're much smarter than we give them credit for: They learn what works with what person. They know if [one member of the family] is prone to get up at 4 a.m. and give them some treats.
Why do cats knead us?
They are using behavior that they would use toward their mother—all the behavior they show toward us is derived in some way from the mother-kitten relationship. The kitten learns to raise its tail, rub on its mother, and knead and purr. Grooming is what mothers do back to kittens.
So they're using bits of behavior already in their repertoire to communicate with us. There aren't very many behaviors—maybe half a dozen. (See National Geographic readers' pictures of cats.)
Can you train cats?
Yes. Cats can learn what they're not supposed to do. If your cat has developed a habit [of jumping up on the kitchen table], there are limited ways to prevent it.
You could use a spring-loaded toy, so when a cat jumps up on something, the toy goes bang and up in the air—the cat doesn't like that and jumps down. Another reasonably benign [strategy] is to use a child's water pistol. But make sure the cat doesn't realize you've got it. Cats don't forgive, and once they realize a person is causing them anxiety or hurt, they keep away.
What do you want owners to know about their cats?
Acknowledge that cats are sociable animals to a point, but not sociable to the extent that dogs are. A lot of people who have one cat decide they would like to have another cat, thinking two cats are twice as much fun. But the cats may not see it that way.
The simple message I would like to get across is if you do want to have more than one cat, go about it in a careful way—and be prepared to give up on it if it doesn't work.
This interview has been edited and condensed.
No one has stated WHY they think this article is "bull". I find it pretty obvious actually. What she says is true and not very "innovative" in terms of cat research. I could have told anyone these things.
It's really weird how so many of us think this arcticle is total crap.
I have essentially lived at home the last 27 months with two cats the first year. Then 4 more as the female had kittens. We gave two of them away(the boys) and kept the two girl kittens and had the father fixed and his claws removed.
There is way way way way way more to cats then this guy describes. Given my experiences with the four of them as well as the 3 other family members who live here and are home far less then I am. Most of what he says is bulls***.
I've lived with cats for my entire five and a half decades. During that time I've studied them intensively, inspired by the work of Paul Leyhausen - a researcher who REALLY observed cats. Much of this article is pure crap. It sounds like it was written by someone who started with an agenda & then tailored his observations to fit. Until this researcher spends two or three cat lifespans observing them, and I mean their entire lifespan, from kitten through to old age and eventual death, he doesn't have a clue about how cats really interact with their human families and/or other cats.
Then my cat is very forgiving because when ever someone steps on his tail or something he runs away, but if you pet him we are back to being friends. Actually he only does it with me.
This is a load of garbage. Look at the feral/stray cats. They are incredibly intelligent and have sophisticated social structures. They will survive and multiply just about anywhere. Thats something dogs can not do.
I have three Burmese, 2 girls, 10yo & 11yo, and a little boy 18months old; One of the girls dislikes him because (I thought) he was trying to play with her. I thought that if she didn't run away he wouldn't chase her! Don't know if I'm right.
I wish i knew what my cat was up to! She'll be all cuddly for a while and we'll have a petting fest. Then all of a sudden she hisses and tries to bite or scratch. She likes to draw blood! I don't know if she thinks she's playing or not. She's calmed down since we got the dogs, though she doesn't have much to do with them
Total crap where certain issues are concerned . Written by someone who has purported to have studied cats for years and yet hasn't actually supplied cat owners with anything remotely new to chew on - on any meaningful level .
My pedigree Burmese cats do "dog" tricks , all four sleep in a heap, are as loyal as dogs - they interact socially and are completely different ages .
"Later, I studied cats (sic) " how much later ?About a year ago ? I have lived with them for 30 years , nothing here that makes me change my mind. They like living in prides, they are highly social, look after each others kittens, they can count ( they know how many kittens they should have and steal from another's litter to make up the shortfall ) . They completely "get" us in a different but better way than dogs do - they understand and manipulate me ( especially me) to get up in the night and feed them when others ignore them . They do forgive - they do love . My old Cream Burmese boy just lived for us , hung on for days when he was dying , just wanted our hugs and love and died at the vets but in my husband's arms . They know about love and devotion and in a much more equal way than dogs - we are not superior to them, we just "are" just like they just "are".
Always found that cats have more of an extra ordinary sensing skills. Quite impressive post. Iron Man Tony Stark Jacket
I don't "believe" in everything this article says. I've some experience with cats and i don't think this way :)
Eh..."Cats don't forgive." Not true. My husband and I have lived with a menagerie of cats (we currently have 7) for 15+ years. They are VERY forgiving; and not just about the water squirter. All of our cats came to us at various times, all rescued either from shelters or taken personally off the streets. There have been some social issues, but overall, even the 2 that hate each other the most have reached some form of detente that makes living in the same house more than just tolerable. Sometimes I do feel like they think I'm a "big, stupid cat." Other times, I think they treat me like "Mommy." Yet other times I seem to be nothing more than a walking food dispenser. They all have different personalities and even moods.
Bottom line: They are extremely complex and are more intelligent than you would believe, unless you've lived with multiple cats for extended periods and can testify to it (as many of you can, I see).
I think the researcher needs to live a little bit longer with cats. You can't make a point only by observing them for 1 or 3 years. You need to have the ability to connect with cats sincerely, and you may have that gift or not. Cats are for patient people who admit and respect others behaviour and timings. I had the honor to share my life with 2 cats for 18 years (my dad gave them to me when I was 10), they passed away and had a happy life. Later in life I adopted 2 orphans, both were a month old, now both are 9 and I can't explain how deep and neat and good this friendship is. My cats know when we need them the most and make me, my husband and my kids smile and cheer up in a second. My kids already know how to connect with cats' behaviour and I am so proud we accomplished it because I am sure they will keep that for life and will share it with others.
As a cat owner, I find this interesting and possibly helpful. But I'm not quite on board with the thought/observation that "We've yet to discover anything about cat behavior that suggests they have a separate box they put us in when they're socializing with us." When cats are raised in a household with other animals, such as dogs, rabbits, pigs, and "treat" these other animals as "friends" (for lack of a better word) rather than food or competition, it appears they act similarly with those animals as they do with other cats as far as cuddling, playing, or ignoring as they choose, don't they? Don't cats put everything into a "separate box"? Even other cats? Acting more or less self-centered/self-reliant? They let us know when they want attention and they let us know when they don't.
That's horse hockey about cats "not forgiving" if you spray them with a water bottle, etc. I've had scores of cats over a period of 40 years and not one of them has ever held a grudge because I've used this form of discipline. In fact, sometimes I only have to hold my hand as if I'm about to spray something and the cat not only reacts by quitting whatever naughtiness she's about to do, but five minutes later is all up in my bidness with the snuggles. I'm just saying. If you're consistent (and calm!) with the disciplining tool (water bottle, can of pennies, spring toy, saying "No!", etc.) and don't randomly frighten the cat w/said tool for no reason, the cat will understand and absorb the lesson. Without hating you. Oh and p.s. that advice about being "ready to give up" when trying to assimilate cats? That is also what I would refer to as "kaka." Yes, be careful, but just as important is "be relaxed." Assume the cats will get along eventually, make sure they've got enough space (and litter) to work around each other for a week or three, and just basically leave them alone until everything smooths out. Nothing wrecks new cat relationships more quickly than humans freaking out ahead of time -- "what if they kill each other???" A trick: Pay more attention to the cat(s) you already had, and ignore the new one almost completely for the first few days, at least. "Old" cat will appreciate the affirmation of its veteran status and will feel less inclined to be aggressive about territory. "New" cat will totally get this -- don't worry about hurting feelings.
The rest of the article is not bad. :)
An interesting take on cat behavior. Not sure if all domestic cat behavior can be explained this way. For instance, I'm not sure why being the "big cat" in the family makes me the can opener or door opener. That might be a little simplistic in explaining some behaviors, but still interesting.
"...-and be prepared to give up on it if it doesn't work."
There are several ways to guide cats behavior in order to get along with other cats, is a matter of patience and lots of dedication, I'm fairly sure any cat can get along with other cats with the right guidance and training, so, I think there is a very negative message at the end of this article.
Not surprised, our parakeets also treat us like we're birds, including sometimes trying to feed us a seed.
I have a blind male cat and a female one, both are rescue cats and i loved the explanations that were given on the interview.
I see them as they see me (except the blind one, he feels) as equals and i always tried to socialize with them the same manner they do with me but showing some predominance over them and it works, they are happy, follow me everywhere but knowing they're boundaries (not always...a cat, is a cat).
I just think some people (that have cats) didn't understand what was said in the interview nor cats.
"...-and be prepared to give up on it if it doesn't work." When tons of pets are left to their on devices every day because of plain human selfishness and cruelty, I have to say, NOT a very responsible message to end with, Mr. Bradshaw. Maybe the next step for you is to study human behavior. You will see they are less smarter than we give them credit for, and they will use "be prepared to give it up", as an excuse for the rest of their lives. Oh, and they will say "I read on National Geographic. It's okay."
I don't think all cats behave in the same manners, I lived with cats since my childhood, since I was 3 years and before that, when didn't remember a thing or understand anything.
there are lot of kind of cats, ignoring their colors and furs, they are different in their way of thinking, their altitude toward humans and toward each other. I have 4 cats now, after losing two of them in this month. The dad of our cats clone (died after 6 years with a normal illness) and the son which disappear without letting a trace behind him! Of course, his name is Zoro. these two cats are unbelievable in their altitude with us humans, they saw as like their owners and nothing like you say " a big cat", they know the best time to play with us, the best time to bed and the funniest thing, they know where to pit, theses two are smart but like our best cat (a female) ever, her name is "Cristy", this is the best cat anyone dreams to have one like her, she is a human wearing a cat's uniform, she is a wise cat, a thinker, I didn't see any cat like her. The first day she comes to our home, and her method to make us loved her, she is a clever one, even my mother loved her so much and all the family cried when she died, she is a unique one, we didn't take any picture of her, but we have many of them in our brains, she a mother of cats, she remind me of "maditow" in the national geographic's documentary "The Last Lion", she grew her babies like a human, she took care of them longer than any cats in this world and even after she begun to punch them with her hands, she still supervise them. The best part in this cat, when we miss treat her child, she got angry and the person who made these treatment will never walk in peace in our house, even if he tried to kick her, she is the best worrier ever, she punch, kick and give you lot of wounds every time she saw you, and will not forgive you until you apologize to her child by make them asleep, feeding them and any activity. The second thing, how she treated her husband "Bashoto" (the six years old one), and the other wife, she didn't let any cat above 1 years old to eat until all the child under this ages fill their stomach, and after that she open the doors to the older even her husband and after all of them, she eats, she is unbelievable, and after she died our cats respect these roles and organize themselves in groups, the younger first and the older last.
cats do have a laungre and comunicate with us as under them selfs.
am living with cats for 40 years now . and now alot of words thy use to tel things.
what is weird is that nomadder where the cat come from ,country /village, part of the world .thy use thy same words to name things , like a fly for example. our what kind of thing thy want. beside this thy do use aswel a body laungre . tail, body,feets and head.
after 40 years am pretty good at it to have a basic conversation with cats.
the strangest thing i found out about cats that thy all speak the same laungre all over the world.
so far i now something about +- 100 cat words , but thy do have alot more then this.
My cats do not follow EACH OTHER around meowing urgently and pathetically as if to say, "You gave me that flavour of cat food yesterday! Give me the chicken off your plate!" They do not think of me as another cat. They think of me as a food dispenser and a door opener, and the way to get me to do my job is to purr and be affectionate.
@Chris Biscan Why would you take away your cats claws (and part of his foot)? I don't understand how that would help with not having kittens again, if, as it sounds like, that is why you got him fixed.
Fixing your pet is essential to stop the overpopulation of neglected animals, declawing is cruel and absolutely completely unnecessary!
PLEASE do not do this to any other cats you may own in the future.
@Chris Biscan Yeah, I'm with Alex. It is truly terrible to torture a cat by removing its claws. You don't seem to know much about cats either, as you have not given any evidence as to how this article is false.
@Kadir Olav Really? So there aren't packs of wolves, wild dogs, and feral dogs doing that all over the planet?
@Megan Morris You can pet cats until they get over-stimulated. Once they reach that point, all bets are off. That is you need to learn how much your cat can take at once time and on a certain part of their body.
@Karry Gardner That sounds exactly like a dog to me. I've known a lot of cats over the years and they're all selfish douchebags. "They completely "get" us in a different but better way than dogs do". Ofc you say that, you're obvously a cat-person. Just like I'm a dog-person, but unlike you, I understand that we percieve our pets differently based on our likings. Sprry for my bad English, it's my second language.
@Karry Gardner We have a tall skinny indoor-outdoor cat, he eats whenever and how much he wants and never puts on weight. We are probably his third owners or more, who knows. The vet says he is about 7-10 years old. We had seen him around for four or five years. Then he seems to have sort of adopted the neighbors. He'd stay there for a few days at a time and then disappear again. About two years ago he decided to stay with us. He had shown up one night at the sliding door, he had pus running down his face. He let me pick him up (he would never let me near him before) and squeeze out all the puss. I used peroxide and Neosporin to treat the wound. Within a week of treatment it was almost completely healed.
He is an old fighter. He has battle scars here and there and notches in his ears. He has only two fangs left. One was gone when we got him the other broke off and had to be pulled. He is very territorial, he'll beat up any cat that wanders on his territory, so I don't know about them liking to live in groups, Lyons maybe but most of the cats big and small are solidary hunters.
@Diana Prince I agree since seeing the video of the Family Cat seeing off a Viscious dog who was mauling a little 5 year old child..and then Tabby went back to see if the child was okay..amazed by this. He was injured and had to have sutures after the dog left a nasty dog bit in his calf. Could have been a lot worse. I think the dog has been since put down looked like a Staff Bull type.
@Julie Martin Usually when they grow up together they are very happy with each other!
@Theodore Elperro if a cat really got to know you than it can definitely forgive you.
@Theodore Elperro I have looked at my Cat social network in my neighborhood, and there is a clear male leader, a female leader, their followers, and an omega or lowest of the low. it is a strange concept to grasp, but cats have social lives.
Agreed. Although, I barely believe that the researcher was even trying to see what the cats did.
Not true that any cat will eventually get along with any other. There are cats who simply do not like particular individual cats, while they DO like different individuals. This is true regardless of what behavioral modifications, guidance, training, pheromones, drugs, etc. are tried. Sometimes an individual cat just must be re-homed.
Not true that any cat can get along with any other. Cats can be persnickety, and they know who they like and who they don't. I've known many to get along with some other cats but never with some different ones.
@M. Essaid cats do life and behave in the same madder. i had like a gang of 40 cats and thy just behave like the lions you see on your tv. so it is not ongly house cats but al the cats that behave the same . even with the same words . and thy have always a leader who will learn them al thy most now to survive. all the rest will follow her becourse the leader is always a female cat. and rare a male .
@Robyn Alexiadis That's because one cat does not provide food or door-opening to the other. They treat you that way because they see you as their mother, or a mother-type figure, and treat you that way. That's what the article was trying to get across.
@Dawn Richardson Yes the dog was put down sadly. I hope the child develops a love for all animals despite having a bad experience as a child.
"One solution is to examine the cat's social lifestyle, instead of pumping it full of drugs. [For example, that could mean making sure] two cats that [don't get along] live at opposite ends of the house. Quite often the whole problem goes away."
I live with 3 cats, each with their own special personality and level of understanding, and though they originally started out flat-out hating each other they, at the very least, get along. I think the most ironic part is that though they'd swat and hiss at each other, even at the beginning they cared for each other when things got serious. Once, I accidentally stepped on a cat's tail, and the yelp that ensued brought the other cats to where the incident had taken place, as if to say, "Alright, we heard the scream, who do we have to slice to bits? Who's hurting who?". On a serious level I've seen comradery among cats, that they'll protect each other, even if when they're playing their little games of who-owns-what, they're enemies. They're like humans with fur and claws and cute meows. Enough said.
The United States has deported tens of thousands of Mexicans who crossed the border as children, and many now struggle on the streets of Tijuana in a country they hardly know.
Latest From Nat Geo
It's all hands (and paws) on deck when it comes to the poaching crisis in Africa.
For Sebastián García Iglesias, the ghosts of his ancestors are stitched to the tapestry of the land they pioneered.
In this new series, writers and photographers from around the world reflect on places that hold special meaning for them.
The Future of Food Series
Food. It's driven nearly everything we've ever done as a species, and yet it's one of the most overlooked aspects of human history.
We've made our magazine's best stories about the future of food available in a free iPad app.