National Geographic News
Exotic animal picture: Animals killed in Zanesville, Ohio

A tractor carries an animal carcass for burial at the Muskingum County Animal Farm in Zanesville, Ohio.

Photograph by Tony Dejak, AP

Ker Than

for National Geographic News

Published October 20, 2011

The recent shooting of dozens of exotic animals at a private farm in Zanesville, Ohio, is raising new questions about how to handle the growing number of exotics being kept as pets in the United States. (See pictures of the rescued exotic animals from Ohio.)

On Tuesday, Terry W. Thompson killed himself after releasing dozens of exotic animals from their cages at his Muskingum County Animal Farm near Zanesville (map).

As a result, 48 animals were shot and killed by law officers called to the scene. One witness described the aftermath as "Noah's Ark wrecking."

By Wednesday evening the animal death toll included 18 Bengal tigers, 17 lions, 6 black bears, 3 mountain lions, 2 grizzlies, a baboon, and a wolf.

Only six animals from the farm—three leopards, a grizzly bear, and two monkeys—were captured alive.

Muskingum County Sheriff Matt Lutz defended the shootings, telling reporters that his officers had only about an hour before sunset to control the situation, and they didn't have immediate access to tranquilizer darts.

Most experts agreed that the Ohio officers had little choice but to kill the animals.

Unlike in television and movie portrayals, real tranquilizers take time to take effect, and the impact of a dart can make an animal aggressive or cause it to run.

Sedation "doesn't happen immediately," said Leigh Henry, a senior policy officer with the World Wildlife Fund (WWF).

In fact, a vet from a local zoo shot one of the tigers with a tranquilizer dart. But the animal started to run off, forcing officers to shoot and kill it.

Henry said that she believes the Ohio police did what was necessary.

"I'm not going to say who was right or wrong," she said. "I certainly wouldn't judge them for taking the actions that they did, when their primary responsibility was the safety of their community."

(See pictures of exotic animals rescued at the L.A. airport.)

Exotic Animal Shootings Highlight Need for Better Regs

Luke Dollar, program officer for National Geographic's Big Cats conservation initiative, said the public discussion should focus not on whether the animals should have been shot but on an absence of relevant legislation, which allowed Thompson's exotic-animal farm to exist in the first place.

"I hope we don't use this as a misdirected excuse to vilify or 'armchair quarterback' the men and women of law enforcement who were responding to an uncertain and dynamic situation with little chance of any good outcomes," Dollar said.

"This became an incident waiting to happen as soon as Thompson was able to buy that first tiger, then a lion, and so on. With proper legislation or regulation, we can prevent this from happening again."

(See why some conservationists call privately held exotic animals "ticking time bombs.")

Ohio is one of at least eight U.S. states that don't regulate ownership of exotic animals. It's also one of the few states that don't require residents to be federally licensed to keep wild animals by the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA).

While what Thompson did may not have been technically illegal, by many accounts his treatment of the animals was unethical. Thompson had been reported for animal cruelty numerous times, and attempts had been made to confiscate the creatures on his farm.

More Tigers Captive Than Wild?

The Ohio animal shootings also cast a spotlight specifically on the increasing number of captive tigers in the United States.

According to a recent WWF report, there are an estimated 5,000 captive tigers in the U.S.—a number that far exceeds the approximately 3,200 individuals believed to exist in the wild.

Captive tigers in the U.S. are often given as gifts when they're cubs. Owners later realize they don't want to care for the big cats when they grow older and more dangerous.

(Find out how the exotic-animal trade is creating a "python nightmare" in Florida.)

"What you end up with is a situation ripe for exploitation," said WWF's Henry, who was a co-author on the tiger report.

"Under the current system, parts from these domestic tigers in the U.S. can easily enter the illegal medicine market, and our concern is that that will help perpetuate or increase the demand for tiger products.

"That in turn will increase the threat to wild tigers," since parts from wild animals are perceived as being more valuable.

(Video: Tiger Trade Slashes Big Cats' Numbers.)

How Can People and Exotic Animals Coexist?

Laly Lichtenfeld, a wildlife conservationist and the executive director of the African People & Wildlife Fund, also worries that the Ohio incident will send the wrong message about how people in the U.S. feel about wild animals.

"I work directly with local communities [in Africa] who live with large animals like lions and elephants on a daily basis," said Lichtenfeld, who is also a National Geographic Society grantee. (The Society owns National Geographic News.)

(Related: "Lions, Elephants Speared Near Kenya Wildlife Park.")

"We're working very hard to find a way for people to do that, which is both safe for those people and the wildlife. So when something like this happens, it really calls into question whether there's a double standard," she said.

"When there are large animals in our backyard, we don't want them, but we're hoping that the rest of the global community will tolerate them.

"We really need to take an inward look at that."

Larry Rouse
Larry Rouse

Tranquilizing a large wild animal is extremely dangerous, and nobody is going to try it in the dark, especially in an area where there are dozens of other dangerous animals and no one knows where they are. As noted in the article, they don't just flop over like a sack of wet cement like they do on TV. What they didn't show when Jim Fowler did it on Wild Kingdom was the guy off camera with the real gun who had the job of shooting the animal if it jumped at Jim. It’s a miracle that no one got killed ot injured in this.One officer stepped out of his car to be confronted by a full grown bear charging him.He managed to bring it down seven feet from him with his sidearm.Believe me, if you’re taking on a large bear, a .40 pistol is not your weapon of choice.There is also an error in the article. When the vet put a dart in the last remaining tiger, it did not run off, it lunged at her she got tangled in a thicket while trying to back away. That's when the officers shot it. If they hadn't she would be dead.

Don't blame the officers for doing their job to protect the public. The blame lies with selfish people who hoard these animals in appalling conditions because they are unable to care for them properly, all the while ranting at the top of their lungs how much they love their "pets" and about their "right" to do as they please on their own property.

alexander apelis
alexander apelis

They definitely should NOT have been shot!! How hard is it to tranquilize them and transport the animals to a secured location.  Outright horrific.  Why punish them?


Popular Stories

  • Fighting Over Herring

    Fighting Over Herring

    Pacific herring stocks are shadows of their former abundance. But the Canadian government wants to reopen fishing off British Columbia.

  • Smoke Is Feeding Stronger Tornadoes

    Smoke Is Feeding Stronger Tornadoes

    A computer simulation of America's worst day of tornadoes in decades finds a link to land-clearing fires in Central America.

  •  Why 'Mountaineer's Guide to Death' Matters

    Why 'Mountaineer's Guide to Death' Matters

    "People find it instructive and helpful, but also kind of fun—in a macabre kind of way," says the American Alpine Club's executive editor.

The Future of Food

  • Why Food Matters

    Why Food Matters

    How do we feed nine billion people by 2050, and how do we do so sustainably?

  • Download: Free iPad App

    Download: Free iPad App

    We've made our magazine's best stories about the future of food available in a free iPad app.

See more food news, photos, and videos »