Photograph from Robert Harding Picture Library, Alamy
Published November 23, 2010
Five hundred years before Columbus sailed the ocean blue, a Native American woman may have voyaged to Europe with Vikings, according to a provocative new DNA study.
Analyzing a type of DNA passed only from mother to child, scientists found more than 80 living Icelanders with a genetic variation similar to one found mostly in Native Americans. (Get the basics on genetics.)
This signature probably entered Icelandic bloodlines around A.D. 1000, when the first Viking-American Indian child was born, the study authors theorize. (Related: "Vikings' Barbaric Bad Rap Beginning to Fade.")
Historical accounts and archaeological evidence show that Icelandic Vikings reached Greenland just before 1000 and quickly pushed on to what is now Canada. Icelanders even established a village in Newfoundland, though it lasted only a decade or so (regional map).
The idea that a Native American woman sailed from North America to Iceland during that period of settlement and exploration provides the best explanation for the Icelanders' variant, the research team says.
"We know that Vikings sailed to the Americas," said Agnar Helgason of deCODE Genetics and the University of Iceland, who co-wrote the study with his student Sigrídur Ebenesersdóttir and colleagues. "So all you have to do is assume … that they met some people and ended up taking at least one female back with them.
"Although it's maybe interesting and surprising, it's not all that incredible," Helgason added. "The alternative explanations to me are less likely"—for example the idea that the genetic trait might exist independently, undiscovered, in a few Europeans.
The study authors themselves admit the case is far from closed. But University of Illinois geneticist Ripan Malhi—an expert in ethnic DNA differences who wasn't part of the project—agreed that the report holds "strong genetic evidence for pre-Columbian contact of people in Iceland with Native Americans."
Dating the DNA Signature
Through genealogical research, the study team concluded that the Icelanders who carry the Native American variation are all from four specific lineages, descended from four women born in the early 1700s.
Those four lineages, in turn, likely descended from a single woman with Native American DNA who must have been born no later than 1700, according to study co-author Ebenesersdóttir.
The genealogical records for the four lineages are incomplete before about 1700, but history and genetics suggest the Native American DNA arrived on the European island centuries before then, study co-author Helgason said.
He pointed out that Iceland was very isolated from the outside world in the centuries leading up to 1700, so it's unlikely that a Native American got to the island during that period.
As further evidence, he noted that—though the Icelanders share a distinct version of the variation—at least one lineage's variation has mutated in a way that would likely have taken centuries to occur, the researchers say.
This unique signature suggests that, in Helgason's words, the Native American DNA arrived in Iceland at least "several hundred years" before 1700.
DNA Evidence Fragmented
Despite the evidence, for now it's nearly impossible to prove a direct, thousand-year-old genetic link between Native Americans and Icelanders.
For starters, no living Native American group carries the exact genetic variation found in the Icelandic families.
But of the many known scattered versions that are related to the Icelandic variant, 95 percent are found in Native Americans. Some East Asians, whose ancestors are thought to have been the first Americans, carry a similar genetic pattern, though.
The Inuit, often called Eskimos, carry no version of the variant—a crucial detail, given that Greenland has a native Inuit population.
Helgason speculates that the precise Icelandic variation may have come from a Native American people that died out after the arrival of Europeans.
It's possible, he added, that the DNA variation actually came from mainland Europe, which had infrequent contact with Iceland in the centuries preceding 1700. But this would depend on a European, past or present, carrying the variation, which so far has never been found.
(See pictures of Native American lands in National Geographic magazine.)
History Not Much Help?
Complicating matters, the historical record contains no evidence that Icelandic Vikings might have taken a Native American woman back home to their European island, scholars say.
"It makes no sense to me," said archaeologist and historian Hans Gulløv of the Greenland Research Centre in Copenhagen.
For one thing, experts say, nothing in excavations or the Icelandic sagas—thought to be rooted in fact but not entirely reliable—suggests a personal alliance of the kind reported in the new study, published online November 10 in the American Journal of Physical Anthropology.
The Saga of Erik the Red does tell of four Skraeling boys—the Norse term for the American Indians—who were captured by an Icelandic expedition and taken back to Greenland, said Birgitta Wallace, an emeritus archaeologist for Parks Canada who has written extensively about the Norse.
But Icelanders spent little time in North America, and their relations with the people they found living there seem to have been mostly hostile, she said. The stories "talk in not very flattering terms about [Native Americans'] looks," Wallace said.
One saga, she added, tells of explorers "who found some sleeping natives—and they just killed them."
Time to Rewrite Viking History?
"What we have is a big mystery," study co-author Helgason admitted.
It won't be solved, he said, until the DNA pattern's origins are nailed down, perhaps through the study of ancient DNA—for example, if an ancient Native American bone is found with DNA closely matching the Icelandic variant.
But at least one skeptic suggests it's a mystery worth pursuing.
"I have no historical sources telling me" that Vikings took Native Americans home, said Gulløv, the historian. But often when new data is uncovered, he added, "we have to write history anew."
Lots of Native Americans were in Europe before 1700, with many descendants today in England, France, and beyond. Easier for me to guess is that one of these somehow made it to Iceland on a trade ship.
These dots are large and not far apart. The Indians transported to Greeland as recorded in the Norse sagas made it in any number of manner, enslavement, agreement, escape, what have you, to Iceland. The North Asian DNA which is a variant of the North American DNA found in Iceland preceded the North American, which is a variant of it. And on to Greenland its Viking transportation went.
Nobel Prize, please.
No mention of the possibility that native americans were the first inhabitants of iceland, and this mitochondrial dna is the last genetic link to that past.
Perhaps one of the native boys grew up to marry a Scandinavian woman and their daughter went to Iceland.
History is full of things that make no sense originally, but upon further investigation, prove to make perfect sense. I see no reason why the DNA results don't make sense just because someone at one point didn't mention it a Native woman making the voyage to Iceland. Perhaps it just wasn't considered to be important enough to note - I can't see why that's not perfectly plausible.
My guess is that we are dealing with the Beothuk here and that may be very difficult to prove. A staring point may be DNA from folks in Newfoundland, however, from families of long standing and in areas last known to be inhabited by the Beothuk.
Some of the conclusions made by the Icelandic historians make no sense. Of course the date of this article may matter, but there is confirmed evidence of a viking settlement, possibly seasonal, on Baffin Island where they would have had regular contact with the now-extinct Dorset people (who lived there before the Inuit). I would suggest that each of these experts should consider a true interdisciplinary investigation before ruling anything out based on their own specific discipline. For starters, why would the sagas talk about an everyday trade outpost--where would the glory be in that?
There is a strong possibility that the Beothucks are not extinct in Newfoundland. There is substantial anecdotal evidence that a Beothuck female was espoused by an European fisherman in Hants Harbour just before the middle of the 18th century. The descendants of that union today have anatomical characteristics of North American Indians. The Icelandic researchers could perhaps find a closer DNA match among these people.
@Earl Berg Easily disproven by the fact they've narrowed the dates when this Indian DNA appeared there.
@Prithvi Jagannath The kind of DNA found follows only the maternal line! As male I got my mtDNA from my mother, but my daughter got hers exclusivly from her mother.
A computer simulation of America's worst day of tornadoes in decades finds a link to land-clearing fires in Central America.
"People find it instructive and helpful, but also kind of fun—in a macabre kind of way," says the American Alpine Club's executive editor.
A photographer caught the 130-pound monster on camera in November off the southern California coast.
The Future of Food
How do we feed nine billion people by 2050, and how do we do so sustainably?
We've made our magazine's best stories about the future of food available in a free iPad app.