Weird & Wild

One More Reason Dogs Are More Like Us Than We Thought

Man's best friend can understand both the words we say and the tone in which we say them, new brain scans reveal.

View Images

New brain scans of 13 pet dogs reveal that the canines understand both our words and in the tone in which we say them.


It's likely no surprise to dog owners, but growing research suggests that man's best friend often acts more human than canine.

Dogs can read facial expressions, communicate jealousy, display empathy, and even watch TV, studies have shown. They've picked up these people-like traits during their evolution from wolves to domesticated pets, which occurred between 11,000 and 16,000 years ago, experts say.

Now there's even more evidence that dogs understand us. New brain scans of dogs reveal that our pets hear both the words we say and how we say them. For people, both the word and intonation are important, but no one knew—until now—whether that was also the case for dogs.

WATCH: Animal behavior researchers in Hungary have found evidence that dogs can understand both the content and the tone of human speech.

In a study published August 29 in Science, scientists found the canine brain also processes the information in a similar way as humans: The left hemisphere of the dogs’ brains responded to the word itself, and their right hemisphere responded to intonation. (See "5 Amazing Stories of Devoted Dogs.")

"It’s really exciting to see such close correspondence between brain activity in humans and dogs," said Chris Petkov, a neuropsychologist at the U.K.'s University of Newcastle who was not involved in the study.

Here are a few more recent studies showing the human side of our canine companions.

Eavesdropping Dogs

Social eavesdropping—or people-watching—is central to human social interactions, since it allows us to figure out who's nice and who's not, among other things.

In a new study, scientists tested 54 dogs that each watched their owner struggle to retrieve a roll of tape from a container. The dogs were divided into three groups: helper, non-helper, and control.

Dogs of All Sizes For thousands of years, the size of dogs evolved to match their environments. Canines now come in more sizes than any other mammal on land.

In the helper group, the owner requested help from another person, who held the container. In the non-helper group, the owner asked for help from a person, who then turned their back without helping. In the control group, the additional person turned his or her back without being asked for help. In all experiments, a third "neutral" person sat in the room.

After the first round of experiments, the neutral person and the helper or non-helper both offered treats to the dog.

In the non-helper group, canines most frequently favored the neutral person's treat, shunning the nonhelper. However, in the helper group, the dogs did not favor either the helper or the neutral person over the other. Scientists have previously observed similar results in human infants and tufted capuchin monkeys. (See "Can Dogs Feel Our Emotions? Yawn Study Suggests Yes.")

So are dogs taking sides by ignoring the people who are mean to their owners? Only future research will tell.

Made You Look

Gaze following is instinctual for many animals—including humans, chimps, goats, dolphins, and even the red-footed tortoise—because it alerts animals to everything from immediate threats to "a particularly tasty berry bush," says Lisa Wallis, a doctoral student at the Messerli Research Institute in Vienna, Austria.

Dogs were previously thought to follow human gazes only when food or toys were involved. Now, a new study suggests dogs also follow human gazes into blank space—but only if they're untrained.

View Images

It took months to train pet dogs to lie still enough to enter the fMRI machine.


"We know they should be able to do it," says Wallis, leader of the research published in the journal Animal Behaviour, but training was the "missing piece of the puzzle."

In recent experiments, Wallis and her colleagues recruited 145 pet border collies with a range of training levels and ages. The researchers wanted to see if age, habituation, or training influenced the dog's tendency to follow a human's gaze.

Wallis then observed the dogs' reactions as she gazed toward a door. Surprisingly, only the untrained border collies followed her gaze—the trained animals ignored it. That may be because trained dogs learn to focus on a person's face, and not where the person is looking.

When Wallis and colleagues spent just five minutes teaching the untrained dogs to look at her face, they began ignoring the instinct to follow her gaze.

Even more surprising is that the untrained dogs often glanced back and forth between her and the door, baffled at what she was looking at. The behavior, only seen before in humans and chimps, is called "check backs" or "double looking," she said. (Read about war dogs in National Geographic magazine.)

"It's a lesson for us all that we should always examine whether training has an effect in these types of studies," says Wallis.

Next Steps in Dog Research

In humans, aging hastens declines in short-term memory and logical reasoning skills, making it more difficult to learn new tasks. Previous research has found similar declines in dogs, but long-term memory is a little known aspect of dog biology. (See "Many Animals—Including Your Dog—May Have Horrible Short-Term Memories.")

That's why Wallis and colleagues are studying how dogs both young and old memorize tasks, and whether the animals can remember them months later.

The results are still in the works, but Wallis expects to discover that it's tough—but not impossible—to teach old dogs new tricks.

Follow Maya Wei-Haas on Twitter. Carrie Arnold contributed reporting.

Comment on This Story