A child works in a factory in India. Apart from environmental devastation, climate change could have disastrous effects for poorer countries.
Photograph by Akshay Gupta, Pacific Press, Getty Images
Climate change has been linked to increased frequency and intensity of destructive weather events, such as floods and hurricanes. But the effects of a warming planet on crops may pose an even greater danger, especially for the world’s poor, according to the World Bank.
“Agriculture is one of the most important economic sectors in many poor countries,” says a report from the institution. “Unfortunately, it is also one of the most sensitive to climate change given its dependence on weather conditions, both directly and through climate-dependent stressors (pests, epidemics, and sea level rise).”
The report focuses on developing economies and doesn’t include North America, Australia, or a handful of other areas. It sets up two scenarios to project the effects of climate change. The “prosperity scenario” is optimistic: It predicts strong economic growth, fewer people living in poverty, and improvements in basic services. The “poverty scenario” isn’t as hopeful: It predicts the number of impoverished people will grow from the current 702 million to around 900 million by 2030 without factoring in climate change. When climate change is part of the equation, more than a billion people will be in poverty. Most of that additional 100 million, the report says, will become poor due to rising food prices.
Prosperity scenario*
142
Without climate change
158
With high-impact climate change
Poverty scenario*
900
Without climate change
1,026
With high-impact climate change
126 million more people will be affected with a high-impact climate change. These are the main causes
73
28
19
6
Agriculture
Food prices and production affected
Health factors
Malaria, diarrhea, undernutrition
Reduced labor productivity
Natural disasters
Prosperity scenario*
Without climate change
142
With high-impact climate change
158
Poverty scenario*
Without climate change
900
With high-impact climate change
1,026
With high-impact climate change, 126 million additional people will be affected. Main causes shown.
19
6
73
28
Reduced labor productivity
Agriculture
Food prices and production affected
Health factors
Malaria, diarrhea, undernutrition
Natural disasters
Higher food prices can be devastating for the poor. Think about your own budget: How much do you spend on groceries relative to your entire paycheck, your rent or mortgage, or your phone bill? If you’re poor, you spend a higher percentage of your total income on food. In some regions, the poorest residents use more than 60 percent of their income to buy food while for the wealthiest, it’s less than 10 percent.
Poorest
Poor
Middle
Wealthier
60%
50
40
30
20
10
0
South Asia
East Asia & Pacific
Latin America & Caribbean
Sub-Saharan Africa
Europe & Central Asia
Middle East & North Africa
Poorest
Poor
Middle
Wealthier
60%
50
40
30
20
10
0
Sub-
Saharan Africa
Europe
& Central Asia
South Asia
Middle East & North Africa
East Asia & Pacific
Latin America & Caribbean
Food prices would increase the most in these regions.
To remedy this, the World Bank recommends preparing for climate change by “developing early warning systems and flood protection, and introducing heat-resistant crops.”
2000
2030
2050
2080
Sub-Saharan Africa
+77%
60%
40
South Asia
+23%
20
World
+17%
Latin America & Caribbean
+12%
East Asia & Pacific
+9%
Europe & Central Asia
+3%
0
Middle East & North Africa
-11%
-20
2000
2030
2050
2080
Sub-Saharan
Africa
+77%
60%
40
+23%
South Asia
20
+17%
World
Latin America
& Caribbean
+12%
East Asia &
Pacific
+9%
Europe &
Central Asia
0
+3%
Middle East &
North Africa
-11%
-20
There are health risks beyond malnutrition. Disease rates are expected to rise. World leaders are now meeting in Paris to negotiate plans to curb CO2 emissions in an effort to limit the global temperature increase to 2 degrees Celsius. The World Bank report says a small rise in temperatures “could increase the number of people at risk for malaria by up to 5 percent, or more than 150 million more people affected. Diarrhea would be more prevalent, and increased water scarcity would have an effect on water quality and hygiene.”
Like rising food costs, these diseases would disproportionately affect people with lower incomes who pay more out of pocket for healthcare. Think of it this way: When you pay for medical treatment, how much do you pay in cash? Those in poorer countries pay more than half of their medical bills, while those in richer countries pay less than a quarter, with private insurance, government aid, and other forms of assistance paying for the rest.
These estimates are all based on the most pessimistic model for climate change. If action is taken immediately, some of the effects might be curbed, but the potential for climate change to cause financial ruin or push the world’s poor deeper into poverty remains. What’s more, the poorest countries are the least responsible for the carbon emissions that are warming the planet and putting their residents at risk.
In the chart below, the circles relate to overall emissions, the vertical axis represents pollution per capita, and the horizontal axis is gross domestic product.
The poorest countries not only emit the least CO2 per capita, they also contribute the least total emissions on a global scale. But that presents another problem as these countries try to lift their residents out of poverty, and it’s adding to the complexities of the Paris climate talks.
9,000
Amount of total carbon dioxide determines size of circle (metric megatons)
3,000
Carbon dioxide emissions per capita (metric tons)
600
30
Kuwait
25
United Arab Emirates
20
United States
15
Russia
10
Japan
Norway
Germany
China
5
Switzerland
Singapore
India
0
0
10,000
20,000
30,000
40,000
50,000
60,000
70,000
40 poorest countries, based on GDP per capita
GDP per capita**
9,000
Amount of total carbon dioxide determines size of circle (metric megatons)
3,000
600
Carbon dioxide emissions per capita (metric tons)
30
Kuwait
25
United Arab Emirates
20
United States
15
Russia
10
Japan
Germany
Norway
China
Switzerland
5
Singapore
India
0
0
15,000
30,000
45,000
60,000
75,000
GDP per capita**
40 poorest countries, based on GDP per capita
This report from the BBC outlines the issue using India as an example. India’s relatively low per capita pollution is partially the result of its widespread poverty. If poor residents are brought out of poverty, per capita emissions might increase, thereby raising India’s share of global emissions. So countries with sizeable poor populations need two things to come out of the Paris talks. First, they need support for environmentally-sustainable growth around the world. Second, they need wealthier countries to commit to larger cuts in emissions, so there can be room for growth elsewhere.
And that’s why the World Bank, in its report, argues that climate change and poverty reduction can’t be separated as issues, or treated locally. The world needs to resolve both.