Sky-watcher Beware: Mars Email a "Spectacular" Hoax

Andrew Fazekas
for National Geographic News
August 26, 2009

An email promising a "Mars spectacular" on August 27 has astronomers seeing red, as scientists try to counter a seemingly unending Mars hoax.

The anonymous message from an unknown part of the globe says that the red planet " … will look as large as the full moon" in the night sky, and that "no one alive today will ever see this again."

The claim has been bombarding people's inboxes worldwide every summer for five years. Today the Mars hoax has grown into a kind of cyber legend—one that astronomers are still struggling to debunk.

"The possibility of seeing Mars as large as the moon strikes the imagination," said Marc Jobin, staff astronomer at the Montréal Planetarium in Quebec.

"The sad reality is that a lot of people have little comprehension of astronomy and are unable to call the hoax."

(Get the facts behind claims that the Apollo 11 moon landing was a hoax.)

Thread of Truth

In fact, there is a thread of truth that inspired the prank several years ago.

Planets are not on perfectly circular orbits, and during their elliptical paths around the sun, planets can vary in their exact distances to each other over time.

For example, Mars's orbit means that its distance from Earth can range from 34.6 million miles (55.7 million kilometers) to almost 250 million miles (401.3 million kilometers).

On August 27, 2003, Mars made a historically tight approach to Earth, coming about 34.7 million miles (56 million kilometers) away.

Such a near pass hadn't happened in nearly 60,000 years, and it won't happen again until August 28, 2287.

In 2003 planetariums had sent out notices alerting stargazers of the real astronomical event.

"At the time, through the telescope [Mars] looked as large as the full moon would with the naked eye," explained Geza Gyuk, astronomer at the Adler Planetarium in Chicago, Illinois.

Through a backyard telescope with a high-power eyepiece, viewers could even make out many surface features on Mars's disk.

"An email was circulated with this information, but unfortunately the part about the telescope was dropped off and people only passed on the 'size of moon' part."

With the naked eye, Mars still appeared as nothing more than a brilliant orange-colored star in the sky. Still, an email hoax was born.

Earth Doomed?

Luckily for us, Mars won't really loom so large in our skies.

If the red planet actually did appear as huge as purported in the Mars hoax email, the planet would be just 466,000 miles (750,000 kilometers) from Earth, or about twice as far away as the moon.

At that distance, the Montréal Planetarium's Jobin said, life on Earth would likely be doomed.

Given the interplay of gravity between the planets and the sun, a much closer Mars "would have extreme consequences on the shape of the Earth's orbit, with our planet swinging much closer and much farther away from the sun," he said.

"In turn, this would make our planet's climate radically different from what we know, with extreme cold and hot weather, making for very complicated living conditions—not exactly hospitable for higher life forms."




NEWS FEEDS     After installing a news reader, click on this icon to download National Geographic News's XML/RSS feed.   After installing a news reader, click on this icon to download National Geographic News's XML/RSS feed.

Get our news delivered directly to your desktop—free.
How to Use XML or RSS

National Geographic Daily News To-Go

Listen to your favorite National Geographic news daily, anytime, anywhere from your mobile phone. No wires or syncing. Download Stitcher free today.
Click here to get 12 months of National Geographic Magazine for $15.