Don't Rebuild on China Quake Faults, Experts Warn

<< Back to Page 1   Page 2 of 2

(Related story: "China Quake Delivered Seismic One-Two Punch" [May 15, 2008].)

Higher building standards and a buffer zone along the faults "could help cut the number of deaths during an earthquake by one or two orders of magnitude," Densmore said. "Instead of tens of thousands of people dying, maybe thousands or hundreds will die."

Recalling travels in Sichuan in recent years, Densmore said, "The rate of building in the area was astonishing.

"Development in the region has progressed farther and farther back into the mountains, toward the epicenter [of the May 12 quake]."

Five million people have become refugees since their homes were leveled, and the Chinese leadership and foreign aid groups are now scrambling to assemble temporary "tent cities" (see photo).

But the real challenge is to construct cottages, schools, hospitals, and communities reinforced to withstand any future temblor, experts say.

"With the exception of [quake-triggered] tsunamis, earthquakes do not kill people. Buildings kill people," said Guido Cervone of the Center for Earth Observing and Space Research at George Mason University in Virginia.

Architecture for Quake-Prone Areas

Scientists and building designers have made steady advances in creating seismically sound architecture, Cervone said.

The new China Central Television (CCTV) complex being built in Beijing by the Dutch architecture firm OMA, for instance, has been designed, reinforced, and tested to survive powerful earthquakes, said OMA architect Ole Scheeren.

The building's frame has already withstood hundreds of "extreme events" in intense experiments conducted by China's leading engineers, he said.

Improving the earthquake resistance of rural Chinese housing doesn't require such advanced technology, though.

Svetlana Brzev co-founded a Web project called the World Housing Encyclopedia (WHE), which shares information on how to create quake-resistant structures.

"A confined brick masonry earthquake-resistant house," said one WHE pamphlet, "is designed and constructed so that its walls are able to resist earthquakes. Its plan view must be simple and symmetrical. Its bearing walls must be well constructed and must always be confined by reinforced concrete columns and beams."

"Adobe and other forms of unreinforced masonry construction are proven 'serial killers' in many earthquakes worldwide," said Brzev, also an engineer at the British Columbia Institute of Technology in Canada.

"Unreinforced masonry seems to be a culprit in the earthquake-affected area in China," Brzev added.

Sudhir Jain, a professor at the Indian Institute of Technology in Kanpur, said WHE's simple manuals on reinforcing a building's beams and columns with steel designed to bend during a seismic shock could be popularized across China.

Inside China

Architects inside China have begun calling for a system of checks and balances to prevent local officials, government-appointed builders, and inspectors from siphoning funds out of public construction projects, especially schools and hospitals.

Jiang Jun, founder of the architecture magazine Urban China, said, "China's Ministry of Construction is now carrying out a massive investigation into the public buildings that collapsed during the Sichuan earthquake and is drafting measures to prevent any more disasters in the future."

The government is expected to pass stricter laws on earthquake-resistant construction, approve a corps of independent engineers to inspect buildings nationwide, and begin retrofitting unsafe schools across China, he said.

As the superproject to rebuild Sichuan is launched, Jiang added, "China is likely to welcome the globe's leading earthquake engineers to help."

During a rare roundtable discussion on the earthquake and its destruction of haphazardly built schools, architect Liang Jingyu said the public and the media could help in the effort.

"The press needs complete freedom to investigate this earthquake and all public building projects in the future."

Even before that, earthquake experts and builders across China and worldwide could start meeting in cyberspace to create a safer future for Sichuan, Liang said.

His studio is helping set up a wiki platform that Chinese architects and international earthquake engineers can use to bounce ideas, blueprints, and technologies around the planet.

Worth the Cost

The extra expense of designing buildings to absorb seismic shocks seems cost-effective, experts say. For instance, adding counter-quake protections makes the cost of building a school only slightly higher.

Brian Tucker is the president and founder of GeoHazards International, an organization that works with locals around the world to devise or improve building codes.

"In polls conducted across the world, people say they are willing to spend more to make sure schools are safe for kids during earthquakes," Tucker said.

One of the group's main goals is to help international earthquake experts and architects transfer newer technologies to the rest of the world.

The group might join a China-based reconstruction project now being considered by the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development, which promotes democracy and market-based economies.

One aim, Tucker said, would be "helping China to design and build structures that absolutely must remain standing after an earthquake, like hospitals and schools."

<< Back to Page 1   Page 2 of 2




NEWS FEEDS     After installing a news reader, click on this icon to download National Geographic News's XML/RSS feed.   After installing a news reader, click on this icon to download National Geographic News's XML/RSS feed.

Get our news delivered directly to your desktop—free.
How to Use XML or RSS

National Geographic Daily News To-Go

Listen to your favorite National Geographic news daily, anytime, anywhere from your mobile phone. No wires or syncing. Download Stitcher free today.
Click here to get 12 months of National Geographic Magazine for $15.