New Study Weighs Promises, Pitfalls of Hydrogen Cars

<< Back to Page 1   Page 2 of 2

"Hydrogen Highway" Possible?

Debates continue about whether hydrogen, given the existing production methods, could produce an economically feasible fuel.

The Stanford study estimates that hydrogen produced from wind, the most environmentally friendly method, would cost between $1.12 and $3.20 per gallon at the pump.

Such costs don't include the massive expense of converting the nation's energy infrastructure from petroleum to hydrogen. But those numbers are free of the "hidden" per-gallon costs of gasoline that come in the form of health care expenses.

Jacobson believes that converting the existing oil-based infrastructure to a hydrogen-based one is a reasonable, though expensive, long-term goal.

"The technology to change the infrastructure is already there for the most part," he said. "You can produce hydrogen by natural gas or by wind, and hydrogen fuel-cell vehicles exist—every car company has them. Technical improvements will be necessary, but it's more a matter of getting [such a change] going—nobody wants to put in fuel stations until they know that someone wants them."

Daniel Sperling, director of the Institute of Transportation Studies at University of California, Davis—and the owner of two prototype hydrogen vehicles—noted that automakers, too, realize the potential of hydrogen.

"Car companies have a huge motive and a huge interest in developing and commercializing fuel-cell technology," he said. The industry sees it as the future, Sperling observed—they just don't know when that future will become a reality.

Kazuo Okamoto, incoming head of Toyota's research and development group, said in a public statement last week that the automaker hopes to reduce the cost of an HFCV from today's typical $1 million per vehicle to $50,000 by the year 2015.

General Motors has also said it hopes to sell hydrogen vehicles in the United States by 2010.

Many Roadblocks Ahead

But some experts warn of major roadblocks that could keep hydrogen from becoming the fuel of choice in the U.S.

Joseph Romm helped oversee fuel-cell research for the U.S. Department of Energy during the Clinton administration and is the author of The Hype About Hydrogen.

"I think that the challenges to building a practical vehicle are enormous, and I suspect we are decades away from that," Romm said.

Even if vehicles can be affordably produced, Romm predicts difficulty in building a network of fueling, storage, and transfer facilities.

"Fuel providers know how to make money investing in gasoline," he said. "What would possess them to gamble tens of billions of dollars in a fuel when they don't know that people will want it? The government would have to intervene to get fueling stations into the marketplace."

Automakers will also be tasked, at least initially, to make such vehicles desirable—particulary in light of increasingly available, and environmentally friendly, gas/electric hybrids.

"The fuel is going to cost more, and the opportunities for fueling are more limited," Romm said. "These vehicles will have to be clearly superior in some category [in order to sell], and I think that is not on the horizon yet."

While Romm doesn't entirely dismiss HFCV research, he terms the technology "wildly premature" and favors a more immediate focus on hybrid vehicles and improved fuel-efficiency standards.

"We don't have vehicles that anyone would want to buy, and we don't have a fuel that's either inexpensive or environmentally benign," he said. "Could that be different in two decades? It could be, but it might not be. It's certainly not going to be any different in five years."

UC Davis's Sperling is more bullish on hydrogen's prospects.

The reality is, there's a whole range of strategies and options, some for the near term and some for the long term, he said. "Hydrogen has to be considered a leading option. It's clearly not [a technology] for tomorrow. But just as clearly, there is a need to get started soon to make it a plausible option for the future."

Don't Miss a Discovery
Sign up for our free newsletter. Every two weeks we'll send you our top news by e-mail (see sample).

<< Back to Page 1   Page 2 of 2




NEWS FEEDS     After installing a news reader, click on this icon to download National Geographic News's XML/RSS feed.   After installing a news reader, click on this icon to download National Geographic News's XML/RSS feed.

Get our news delivered directly to your desktop—free.
How to Use XML or RSS

National Geographic Daily News To-Go

Listen to your favorite National Geographic news daily, anytime, anywhere from your mobile phone. No wires or syncing. Download Stitcher free today.
Click here to get 12 months of National Geographic Magazine for $15.