The Science of Superheroes: Beyond "The Incredibles"

<< Back to Page 1   Page 2 of 2

Sacrificing Science

While Hollywood filmmakers today are striving to make their movies as scientifically realistic as possible, Weinberg believes the comic books from the so-called Silver Age of comics (the late 1950s and the 1960s) were more grounded in science than most of what is being published today.

"Most of the people who wrote comics back then were originally science fiction writers who knew their science and technology," he said. "Many of today's comic book writers seem to have learned their science from reading comic books and not from studying modern technology."

Some comic book writers have suggested that good science means sacrificing an entertaining story. Weinberg disagrees.

"Years ago critics said science fiction novels couldn't feature accurate science and intelligent characters, [yet] hundreds of best-selling science fiction books since then have proven [them] wrong," Weinberg said. "The same people claim that comic books can't feature accurate science and intelligent characters, that you cannot have both in the same story. Sound familiar?"

Unknown Universe

Weinberg and Gresh are not alone in studying superhero science. One Web site, "Insultingly Stupid Movie Physics," reviews movies based on scientific merit. Films receive anything from a GP rating (for "good physics in general") to an XP ("obviously physics from an unknown universe").

At the University of Minnesota in Minneapolis, James Kakalios, a physics professor, uses superheroes to teach science in a class nicknamed Everything I Know of Science, I Learnt From Reading Comic Books.

"It's a very sneaky course," Kakalios said. "I'm getting the students to eat their spinach by hiding it in a superhero ice-cream sundae."

Kakalios first brought comic books into his classroom in 1993. On an introductory physics exam he posed a question about the death of Spider-Man's onetime girlfriend Gwen Stacey.

Hurled from the top of a New York City bridge by the evil Green Goblin, Stacey died in Spider-Man's web as the hero tried to save her. The writers later attributed her death to the "shock of the fall," an explanation that left many readers mystified.

"Her fall is basically a standard problem that we would ask on an exam: If you fall 90 meters [295 feet] with an initial velocity of zero, how fast are you going at the bottom?" Kakalios said.

The answer removed any doubt about the cause of Stacey's death. She was falling at roughly 95 miles an hour (153 kilometers) when she hit the web. The impact on her body would have been 10 to 20 times the force of gravity. That proved the cause of death to be a neck snap when Spider-Man caught Stacey in his webbing.


While comic book fans have long argued over who the most powerful superhero is, Weinberg says there's no doubt about who is the most formidable villain.

"Without question, Magneto—the mutant who controls the power of magnetism [in the X-Men series]—is the most powerful villain in comics," Weinberg said. "Electromagnetism is the most powerful of the four basic forces of the universe."

But Magneto rarely uses his superpowers to cause maximum damage. Theoretically, everything on Earth that involves electricity falls under his influence. Instead, Magneto generally uses his powers to do things like manipulating the iron content of blood to establish mind control over others.

Similarly, Weinberg said, the powers of many superheroes are not put to optimum use or even used logically.

"Imagine you were driving in your car one day, and a meteor crashed in a nearby field, and inside that rocket was a child with superhuman powers," he said.

"What would you do? Announce to the world that life existed on another planet and that space travel was possible? Or would you take the child home, keep his origin a secret, and raise him to be some sort of flying policeman with a big s on his shirt?"

Don't Miss a Discovery
Sign up for the free Inside National Geographic newsletter. Every two weeks we'll send you our top news stories by e-mail.

For more superhero and related science stories, scroll to bottom.

<< Back to Page 1   Page 2 of 2




NEWS FEEDS     After installing a news reader, click on this icon to download National Geographic News's XML/RSS feed.   After installing a news reader, click on this icon to download National Geographic News's XML/RSS feed.

Get our news delivered directly to your desktop—free.
How to Use XML or RSS

National Geographic Daily News To-Go

Listen to your favorite National Geographic news daily, anytime, anywhere from your mobile phone. No wires or syncing. Download Stitcher free today.
Click here to get 12 months of National Geographic Magazine for $15.