Bear-Viewing in North America Stirs Concerns About Safety

<< Back to Page 1   Page 2 of 2

More tourists means more tourist dollars.

Tourists pay up to U.S. $2,103 each to visit Churchill, Manitoba, the most popular destination for viewing polar bears in North America.

Day's tours have become so popular that two years ago she bought her own Dehavilland Otter floatplane. "Now it seems everybody who has an airplane, and in some cases, a boat, is offering bear-viewing," she said.

Growing Risks

As more and more people have close encounters with bears, there's a growing risk of danger. Major injuries have not been a problem so far at popular bear-viewing spots in Alaska and British Columbia, but several incidents in recent years have raised concern.

In Alaska, a ranger at Katmai National Park was bitten on the hand by a charging grizzly. Bears have been reported trying to climb into boats full of viewers.

In 2000, Knight Inlet visitors watched in fear as a man who had paid to be flown to the site, which is on public land, sat down near feeding grizzlies, who sniffed him curiously. He was eventually persuaded to leave without incident.

Wildlife managers and concerned officials say one problem is the films and videos that attract people to bear-watching in the first place. Some show people dangerously close to bears or acting inappropriately around the animals.

As a result, said wildlife biologist George Matz, viewers may let their guard down. "At Katmai, people are almost applauding when bears catch fish," he said. "Sometimes it looks like a sporting event."

Day said the increased publicity and public interest is a mixed blessing. "It's great and it's not so great," she said. "We don't want it to be a Disneyland experience. We want people to go away understanding the bears."

Unfortunately, when encounters between people and bears do become unfriendly, it often results in the death of bears. In Alaska and British Columbia, it's legal to shoot a grizzly in defense of life and property. Even when no one gets hurt, experts say, bear populations can be seriously disturbed by unregulated interactions with people.

"Grizzly bears are highly intelligent animals, sensitive to their surroundings and experiences with people," said Gilbert. "And as the slowest reproducing land mammals in North America, they are particularly vulnerable to anything that interferes with their feeding or reproduction."

Studies show that bears behave differently in the presence of people. They spend less time fishing and more time watching their surroundings—a change in feeding habits that may affect their ability to survive the winter. They appear in the open most often at dawn and dusk, when people generally aren't around.

Small Groups and Self-Policing

Gilbert advocates the adoption of viewing guidelines to protect bears from "over-viewing" and ensure public safety. He suggests some specific practices that research by him and others has shown to reduce the effects that human presence can have on bears.

"Bears should be viewed from established locations, such as raised platforms, and at particular times, so you don't surprise them," said Gilbert, adding: "Small groups of viewers are key."

"And," he said, "it's crucial not to teach bears that people mean food." This means cleaning up campsites and making it impossible for bears to get into garbage. Bears that learn to connect people with food often become dangerously bold, and have to be relocated or killed.

Not all bears grow accustomed to the presence of people, Gilbert pointed out. "It's important to give these ones in particular regular 'windows' with no people around," he said.

Day said a licensing system should be required to keep out inexperienced guides who do not know how to act in the best interests of both their clients and the bears.

"The industry needs to self-police," she said. After agreeing to a set of recommendations, or "best practices," guides could work together to ensure that safe practices are being heeded, she said.

Such a system is already in effect among boat tour operators who take visitors to see pods of killer whales near Vancouver, B.C. The voluntary guidelines were adopted after scientists warned that the whale populations were at risk from being disturbed by too many boats approaching too closely.

Matz agreed that a voluntary system is a good start, and said that state and federal agencies have been working to come up with official guidelines. "Passing laws takes time," he said, "but things need to be done now."

Whether the guidelines are official or not, said Day, "I think we have a people problem, not a bear problem. Dealing with people is the hardest part of our job—the bears are a piece of cake!"

"In 14 years, I have never elicited an aggressive response from a bear," said Day. "The day we start impacting the bears badly, I won't do this anymore."

But, she added, "that's not true for everyone."

<< Back to Page 1   Page 2 of 2




NEWS FEEDS     After installing a news reader, click on this icon to download National Geographic News's XML/RSS feed.   After installing a news reader, click on this icon to download National Geographic News's XML/RSS feed.

Get our news delivered directly to your desktop—free.
How to Use XML or RSS

National Geographic Daily News To-Go

Listen to your favorite National Geographic news daily, anytime, anywhere from your mobile phone. No wires or syncing. Download Stitcher free today.
Click here to get 12 months of National Geographic Magazine for $15.