"Great White" Sighting Puts U.K. on Shark Alert

James Owen in England
for National Geographic News
August 12, 2003
Usually it's only jellyfish and skin-pinching crabs that swimmers worry about along the beaches of southwest England. But this summer they have something else on their minds—the ocean's awesome predator, the great white shark.

The perceived threat, however slim, follows reports of a large, unidentified shark feeding 20 yards (18 meters) off the west coast of Devon.

Experts disagree on whether it was a great white, which can easily be confused with another species of shark commonly found in these waters.

However, the publicity given to the sighting has raised a number of interesting questions. Why, for example, do great white sharks not ordinarily venture into this part of the ocean?

And if it was a great white spotted off Devon, could this be the first of many following their traditional food source? For some years now, many species that are also the great white shark's prey have been observed migrating farther north—possibly because the sea around the U.K. is getting warmer. Is it not inevitable that the great whites will follow in their wake?

The shark thought to be a great white was recently spotted by Chaynee Hodgetts while on vacation.

The teenager, who wants to become a marine biologist, watched the shark from cliffs for ten minutes as it attacked a shoal of fish. Using binoculars, she judged its length at 12 feet (3.66 meters) by comparing it with common dolphins chasing the same shoal.

Having seen detailed notes taken by the 15-year-old, experts say her description closely matches that of a great white (Carcharodon carcharias)—a species never before recorded in U.K. waters.

She reported her sighting to Rolf Williams, a shark expert at the National Marine Aquarium in Plymouth, England.

"It's tantalizing and we're taking it seriously," he said: "We scrutinized Chaynee very thoroughly to get the best information we could. We'll never know for certain, but some of her observations strongly suggest a great white."

Williams says there are just two other sharks found off southwest England that could be mistaken for this super-predator.

The basking shark, which can grow to 36 feet (11 meters) in length, is certainly big enough, but Williams rules it out as the species is a plankton-eater that wouldn't attack shoals of fish.

He added: "The most likely animal to confuse a great white with is a porbeagle shark. Chaynee wasn't able to confirm whether the shark she saw had a white spot on its dorsal fin—if it did it may have been a porbeagle. Then again, you don't get porbeagles measuring 12 feet."

"Spyhopping" Behavior

Williams pointed to another observation which, if accurate, would almost certainly signify a great white. Chaynee reported that the shark was "spyhopping." This behavior, where the shark raises its head above water to see what's happening on the surface, is unique to great whites.

Others are more skeptical.

Ali Hood, conservation officer for the Shark Trust, a conservation charity also based in Plymouth, said: "Although the girl's notes were remarkably detailed for a 15-year-old, these are incredibly rare animals, so to see them in our waters would be remarkable."

However, for other shark researchers the key question isn't whether there are great whites swimming off the U.K., but why they have not been seen before.

"This is the big question mark hanging over marine biologists' heads," said Williams. "When they look at sea temperatures and the food out there, they can't see a reason why they're not here."

The United Nations Food and Agriculture Organization has recently backed this view, having changed its distribution map for the species. This suggests its range could extend as far north as Scotland.

Shark biologist Ian Fergusson, who says just a single specimen has been caught in the eastern North Atlantic in the past century, added: "The enigma is all the greater, given that a center of abundance and reproduction for white sharks is located in the adjoining Mediterranean Sea."

Williams suggests one possible reason why great whites are not reported in U.K. waters is that few people know what to look for. He says even anglers who fish specifically for sharks often confuse porbeagles with mako sharks and other species.

Another possibility is that dwindling great white populations in the Mediterranean and off northwest Africa mean there are few individuals left to explore waters further north.

Tuna Stocks

Marine biologists blame these declines on reduced numbers of favored prey species. For instance, Mediterranean tuna stocks have been cut dramatically due to over-fishing.

But if great whites are now prowling the English coastline, they follow in the wake of many other species that have headed north.

Seen by many as harbingers of climate change, octopus, sea bream, sunfish, turtles, and other marine creatures associated with warmer waters are turning up with increasing regularity. In 2001 one angler even caught a barracuda—a razor-toothed predator usually found in tropical seas.

Although great whites often inhabit relatively cool waters, their presence around the U.K. could also be a response to climate change if their food is luring them to the North Atlantic.

And if they do start to turn up in numbers, the U.K.'s burgeoning seal population should give them good reason to stay. Already there have been reports of seals being attacked by large sharks, including one from a Cornish fisherman who claims to have seen a seal being bitten in half.

Despite such reports, Fergusson says he has yet to see any compelling evidence that great whites have arrived. But he added: "The possibility of these wide-ranging, globally distributed sharks sporadically roaming to U.K. shores as vagrants cannot be discounted, and we anticipate such records might well occur in the future."

While this may not be enough to stop nervous, seawards glances on England's beaches this month, it's worth remembering the great white's man-eating reputation rests largely with the bloodcurdling creature depicted in the Spielberg movie Jaws.

The reality is that people are at low risk of being eaten by a shark. Humans are thought to be rather too bony for a great white's taste.

More Shark Resources on

News Stories
Sharks Help Scientists Study Pacific Nuclear Test Site
Nurse Sharks: Key to Anthrax Diagnosis, Treatment
Underwater Photographer On Swimming With Sharksincludes two photo galleries
Shark Season: Hazard or Hype?
Asian Shark-Fin Trade May Be Larger Than Expected
North Atlantic Sharks on Sharp Decline, Experts Say
Satellite Tags Keep Track of Great White Sharks
Shark Gives "Virgin Birth" in Detroit
Shark-Soup Boom Spurs Conservationist DNA Study
Shark "Photo of the Year" is E-Mail Hoax
Great Whites May Be Taking the Rap for Bull Shark Attacks
Crittercams Provide Insights into Nurse Shark Behaviorincludes photo gallery
Researchers Tag Sharks to Study Breeding Habitsincludes photo gallery
Scientists Study Nurse Shark Mating Habitsincludes photo gallery
Jaws Author Peter Benchley Talks Sharkshear him read from his new book
Do Hammerheads Follow Magnetic Highways in Migration?
Shark Nursery Yields Secrets of Breedingincludes photo gallery
South Africa Rethinks Use of Shark Nets
Sharks Falling Prey to Humans' Appetites
Satellites Clear Up White Shark Mysteries
Are People Eating Sharks Out of Existence?

Featured Sites
Field Tales: Filming Great White Sharks
Oceans of Plenty: South Africa's Teeming Seas from National Geographic Magazine
The Crittercam Chronicles: Sharks

For Kids
Creature Feature: Great White Sharks
Ten Cool Things That You Didn't Know About Great White Sharks
Print 'N' Go Coloring Book: Great White Sharks
Shark Surfari: Online Quiz

© 1996-2008 National Geographic Society. All rights reserved.