"Hobbit" Human Was Unique Species, Wrist Bones Suggest

John Roach
for National Geographic News
September 20, 2007
The proof is in the wrist: The "hobbit" human found on the Indonesian island of Flores is indeed a unique species, not a diseased modern human, a new bone analysis suggests.

Since the discovery of the hobbit's remains was announced in 2004, researchers have debated whether the find represent a new, small-bodied species called Homo floresiensis or a diseased modern human.

Much of the debate has centered on the hobbit's grapefruit-size skull.

Some researchers hold that the brain case is that of a modern human with a genetic disease that causes small brains.

Other researchers conclude it looks nothing like a diseased modern human but instead represents a new species.

The new study steps outside the brain box and finds resolution in the wrist.

"Their wrist bones don't look anything like wrist bones that modern humans and Neanderthals have," said Matthew Tocheri, a paleoanthropologist at the Smithsonian Institution in Washington, D.C.

The wrist bones are more primitive, he said, like those of gorillas, chimpanzees, and other early human ancestors. This suggests the hobbit represents a lineage that appeared before the modern wrist evolved.

"This is basically something that has descended from an ancestor that probably lived sometime between one and three million years ago," Tocheri said.

Knowing who that ancestor is must wait until wrist bones for other ancestors are found, he noted. Possibilities include Homo erectus and the more primitive australopithecines.

Wrist Bones

Tocheri is the lead author of the new study, which appears in tomorrow's issue of the journal Science. Co-authors include Australian, U.S., Canadian, and Indonesian researchers.

Before conducting his hobbit study, Tocheri had found that a particular wrist bone is wedge-shaped in great apes and early human ancestors but is squared-off in modern humans and Neandertals.

That wrist bone in the hobbit retains the wedge shape, he found.

"It was a no-brainer from my perspective," Tocheri said of his conclusion that the hobbit is its own species.

Chris Stringer is a research leader in the Human Origins program at the Natural History Museum in London. He said the study makes a convincing case that the wrist bones are primitive.

The research also supports previous studies that identified primitive shoulder joints and jawbones in the hobbit, as well as unpublished reports of primitive features in the foot.

"When you put all this together, you do end up, I think, strongly reinforcing the idea that this is indeed a very strange and very primitive kind of creature, not necessarily [in the genus Homo]," Stringer said.

"Obviously, one has to temper this with admitting that we still need more material."

More Bones to Pick?

Robert Martin is curator of biological anthropology at the Field Museum in Chicago and co-author of two papers arguing the hobbit is a diseased modern human. He said that possibility remains despite the new findings.

While the hobbit's wrist bones do appear primitive, Martin noted, the study fails to include a direct comparison of the hobbit's wrist to those of a modern human with microcephaly.

Microcephaly is the bone disorder that he believes afflicts the hobbit. The disorder also causes deformations elsewhere in the skeleton, potentially even the wrist bones.

"I stick to the suggestion that [the hobbit] is more likely to be a pathological modern human than any kind of new hominid species," he said.

Tocheri and colleagues write in their paper that no known genetic disease, including microcephaly, results in a wrist that looks like the hobbit's or those of other early human ancestors.

Nevertheless, the mystery of what exactly the hobbit is and how it wound up on the island of Flores remains unresolved.

(See a National Geographic magazine feature: "Flores Find: The People That Time Forgot.")

Researchers need as-yet unavailable wrist bones from Homo erectus to determine if the modern wrist morphology was present in modern human's closest direct ancestor.

Such information will help clarify whether the hobbit is a Homo erectus that shrunk to dwarf size on the isolated Indonesian island or is a new species.

"The fact that the [wrist bones] align themselves so clearly with ape morphology is pretty interesting," said Campbell Rolian, a graduate student of anthropology at Harvard University.

"And [it] is really just another feather in the cap of those who are willing to ascribe it to a new species."

Free Email News Updates
Sign up for our Inside National Geographic newsletter. Every two weeks we'll send you our top stories and pictures (see sample).


© 1996-2008 National Geographic Society. All rights reserved.