Chimp "Stone Age" Finds Are Earliest Nonhuman Ape Tools, Study Says
for National Geographic News
|February 13, 2007|
Humans might not be as pioneering as we're cracked up to be.
That's one possible explanation for new evidence that West African chimpanzees learned to use stone tools on their own to crack nuts at least 4,300 years ago.
The research pushes back chimpanzee tool use thousands of years. It casts into doubt the long-standing theory that direct human ancestors were the only animals to independently develop tools—and that chimps learned to use stone tools by watching humans.
(Follow a time line of human evolution.)
Instead both humans and chimps could have inherited the ability to crack nuts with rocks from a common ancestor, Julio Mercader of the University of Calgary in Canada and co-authors report in today's issue of the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.
Or chimps may have developed the behavior on their own. In either case, it's no longer likely that chimps learned to use stones as tools only by imitating humans.
At 4,300 years old, the chimps' tools correspond to the late Stone Age of human history—before the advent of agriculture in West Africa.
"Until recently people used to say that among modern-day chimpanzees the behavior came from imitation of farmers," Mercader said. "That assumption is no longer valid. What we present predates the presence of farming."
Mercader and colleagues found subtly altered rocks in Côte d'Ivoire (Ivory Coast) in Africa at a research site that houses the only known prehistoric chimpanzee settlement.
(Related news: "Chimp Nut-Cracking Site Offers Clues to Early Tool Use" [May 23, 2002].)
The excavated stones resemble those used by ancient humans and modern chimpanzees to smash nuts—showing evidence of flakes, chips, and worn edges.
Also, several types of starch grains were found on the stones, which the researchers say is residue from cracking local nuts.
Some experts had believed that the chimps at Mercader's study site learned to crack nuts by watching people break apart the seeds of African palm oil trees and other tropical species.
Agustín Fuentes, an anthropologist at Indiana's University of Notre Dame, said he's not surprised by the new research, but he's happy about it.
"It puts the nail in the coffin on those who say chimp tool use is atypical," he said.
"Most people have already bought into that. But now you can say, Look, you've got a 4,000-year-old tradition."
The most primitive human stone-tool sites are in Olduvai Gorge in East Africa.
Tools there date back to 2.6 million years ago, when people were deliberately modifying stone tools by flaking rocks to create razorlike edges. Chimps today don't change the shapes of the stones they use as nutcrackers.
But the chimps' stones may be similar to stone tools used by humans before our ancestors began to chisel rocks for specific purposes.
Today in Côte d'Ivoire's Taï rain forest, mother chimpanzees still teach their infants the art of nut cracking.
It takes young chimps about seven years to master the technique. To split a nut without pulverizing it, the chimps must apply 2,200 pounds (1,000 kilograms) of force.
Fuentes said that Mercader and colleagues' work emphasizes that the difference between chimps and humans is not the ability to use tools, but the ability to modify the tools and share that information.
For Fuentes, the research "knocks humans off the pedestal of tool use," but it affirms our unique ability to communicate.
A chimp mother might teach her offspring to crack nuts, but chimps are not really communicating about how to use tools and where to get them, he said.
"Nothing," he said, "goes to the level of information-sharing and technology that [humans are capable of]."
Editor's note: Julio Mercader's investigation of the stone tool use of present and past chimpanzees in West Africa has been funded in part by the National Geographic Society's Committee for Research and Exploration.
Free Email News Updates
Best Online Newsletter, 2006 Codie Awards
Sign up for our Inside National Geographic newsletter. Every two weeks we'll send you our top stories and pictures (see sample).
|© 1996-2008 National Geographic Society. All rights reserved.|