National Geographic News: NATIONALGEOGRAPHIC.COM/NEWS
 

 

Mute Swans Spark Loud Debate in Chesapeake Bay

Kim A. O'Connell
for National Geographic News
June 5, 2003
 
Bathing mute swan eggs in vegetable oil may sound like an old Eastern
Shore recipe from Maryland's Chesapeake Bay region. Instead, it's a form
of egg addling, a method used by wildlife managers to prevent the non-
native birds from reproducing.


Although strikingly elegant, mute swans (Cygnus olor) are one of the bay's most harmful species, edging out native waterfowl and destroying aquatic vegetation. Egg addling has slowed the species' population growth, but not quickly enough to protect the bay's already fragile resources.

Seeking more drastic cuts in the bird's population, the Maryland Department of Natural Resources (DNR) unveiled a plan in April to shoot 1,500 mute swans. But one animal-rights group, the New York City-based Fund for Animals, denounced the plan and filed a lawsuit, prompting the DNR to suspend its plan pending further review.

Meanwhile, the birds continue to reproduce.

Explosive Growth

Mute swans, native to Europe and Asia, are found throughout the Chesapeake Bay and its major tributaries. The invasive species first took roost in the area when five birds escaped from captivity in 1962. Since then, the population has grown to 3,600 birds, having reached an all-time high of 4,000 birds in 1999.

"In 40 years this population has doubled more than nine times," said Jonathan McKnight, associate director of habitat conservation for DNR. "We've got a bunch of birds that are ready to start nesting this year or next, and it is clear that the population could reach 20,000 birds in 10 years."

While their name sounds serene, mute swans are ruthless competitors for food. Each year, the swans eat an estimated 10.5 million pounds (4,800 metric tons) of underwater aquatic vegetation, primarily grasses, according to DNR officials. Aquatic vegetation improves water quality and provides essential habitat for waterfowl, fish, and shellfish.

The birds are also aggressively territorial. Mutes have trampled nests of least terns (Sterna antillarum) and black skimmers (Rynchops niger) and driven off tundra swans (Cygnus columbianus), black ducks (Anas rubripes), and other birds from feeding and roosting areas.

Officials from the Commonwealth of Virginia, which shares a border with Maryland along the Chesapeake Bay, have also studied the swans and developed vegetation restoration programs. Unlike Maryland, Virginia allows hunting of the swans. But because the swans are protected under Maryland state law, this issue has mainly been Maryland's albatross.

Stemming the Baby Boom

DNR's mute swan management plan also called for non-lethal population control methods, such as egg addling and relocating birds from sensitive areas. The plan was endorsed by several environmental groups, including the local Chesapeake Bay Foundation in Annapolis, the National Audubon Society in New York, and the American Bird Conservancy in The Plains, Virginia.

But one animal-rights group has not been as receptive, arguing that pollution, not swans, is the primary threat to aquatic vegetation. On May 13, the New York-based Fund for Animals filed a lawsuit in federal court challenging a federal permit that enabled the Maryland DNR plan to proceed. The Fund for Animals' lawsuit contends that the permit violates the Migratory Bird Treaty Act and the International Convention for the Protection of Migratory Birds and sidesteps public review and comment.

"There are major threats to the Chesapeake Bay, including [the effects of] pollution and industries," said Michael Markarian, president of the Fund for Animals. "It's much easier for DNR to throw up its hands and say 'Let's shoot a few hundred swans,' than it is to deal with these other issues."

In response to the lawsuit, DNR agreed to suspend its mute swan management plan. While Markarian called this an "eleventh-hour reprieve" for the swans, McKnight, with the state DNR, is concerned that the suspension will do more harm to the Chesapeake Bay. All management activities, including egg addling, have stopped pending review of the plan.

"While I can appreciate [animal-rights advocates'] concern for these animals, I ask people to look at the three years we put into finding alternatives, and to look at the scientific literature we're using," McKnight said. "We're not doing this because we're bloodthirsty. Who wants to shoot these birds that we agree are beautiful and graceful and majestic? But we're still looking for an alternative that will achieve maximum protection for aquatic grass vegetation without killing these birds."

However, DNR argues that the relocation of mute swans into unoccupied habitats would increase the distribution of the species. The agency has also stated that the relocation of same-sex pairs does not prevent breeding if a bird of the opposite sex enters the relocation site.

For now, state officials, environmental and animal-rights groups, and bay enthusiasts must wait for a federal decision that could seal the swans' fate. Until then, mute swans—as beautiful as they are destructive—will continue their reign in the Chesapeake Bay.

More Bird Stories by National Geographic News:
Early Birds: Is Warming Changing U.K. Breeding Season?
Smell May Play Role in Bird Courtship, Study Finds
Bird Teams Flock to Iraq to Survey War's Impact
Mystery Disease Stalking Vultures in Asia
Humans Are Driving Birds to Extinction, Group Warns
Loons Sound Alarm on Mercury Contamination
Tall As a Deer, Huge U.K. Bird Staging a Comeback
Memory Aids Birds in Migration, Study Finds
Crows Better at Tool Building Than Chimps, Study Says
Extinction Near for Albatross, Experts Warn
51-Year-Old Albatross Breaks N. American Age Record
Are Flashy Male Birds Threats to Their Own Species?
Wild and Escaped Parakeets Captivating City Dwellers
Bright Beaks Signal Health to Female Birds, Study Says
Coot Birds Can Count, Study Says

National Geographic Bird Resources:
Bald Eagles: Come Back From the Brink
Experience the Sights and Sounds of Eagles
Snowy Owls—Muscle & Magic
Attwater's Prairie-Chickens—Down to a Handful

Recent "Birder's Journal" Stories from Robert Winkler:
Birder's Journal: Giving Thanks for Wild Turkey Sightings
Birder's Journal: Ghost Town's Curse Haunts New England Forest
Birder's Journal: Looking at a Handy New Guide
Birder's Journal: Learning to Let Birds Come to You
Birder's Journal: A Morning With Migrants
Birder's Journal: This Warbler Is a Master of Deception
Birder's Journal: Seduced by Dueling Thrushes
Birder's Journal: Attack of the Flying Goshawk

Nationalgeographic.com Bird-Watching Sites:
Boston Area
Chicago Area
Florida Keys Area
Maine's Acadia National Park
Mount Rainier
New Orleans Area
New York City Area
North Carolina's Outer Banks
Philadelphia Area
Portland Area
Rocky Mountain National Park
Salt Lake City Area
San Francisco Area
Santa Fe Area
South Dakota's Black Hills
Utah
Washington's Olympic National Park
Wyoming's Grand Teton National Park
Yellowstone National Park
Yosemite National Park

From the National Geographic Store:
Guide to North American Birds
Portable Birdsong Identifier
Birder's Journal
Songbirds Puzzle

Additional Information from Related Web Sites:
American Bird Center
American Bird Conservancy
Fish and Wildlife Service Bird Web Site
National Audubon Society
Environmental Protection Agency: Bird Conservation
 

© 1996-2008 National Geographic Society. All rights reserved.