Bluegill Fish Monitor Water Supplies for Terrorist Atta

Maryann Mott
for National Geographic News
September 28, 2006
The common bluegill fish is being used to protect public drinking water for millions in the United States from terrorists and accidental contamination.

An automated machine developed by the U.S. Army uses bluegills—a hardy species about the size of a human hand—to continuously monitor water quality in New York City; San Francisco, California; and Washington, D.C.

Unlike current humanmade sensors, bluegills can respond to a wide range of chemicals and provide rapid detection of developing toxic water conditions.

The Army system, for example, can quickly detect toxic materials such as cyanide, organic solvents, and pesticides.

(Related: "Loons Sound Alarm on Mercury Contamination" [May 2003].)

"It's definitely gone well beyond the 'canary in the coal mine' aspect," said Tom Shedd, a biologist with the U.S. Army Center for Environmental Health Research in Fort Detrick, Maryland, who co-invented the system. Miners once used the health of canaries to monitor for the presence of deadly methane gas.

"It's a high-tech technology that has been brought to this new millennium because of advanced hardware and software capabilities."

Since the terrorist attacks of September 11, 2001, federal law has required nearly all communities to assess the vulnerability of their water systems to terrorism or other intentional acts that would disrupt delivery of safe and reliable drinking water.

Tank Monitors

The Army started development of its early-warning system—now sold under the commercial name 1090 Intelligent Aquatic BioMonitoring System—about six years ago, Shedd says.

The system works by monitoring the behavior of eight bluegills that swim freely in tanks where dechlorinated water flows at reservoirs or treatment plants.

Electrodes mounted in the aquarium monitor the fishes' respiratory behavior.

Complex software then analyzes the fishes' actions in reference to tank conditions such as temperature, acidity, and dissolved oxygen levels.

When an abnormality is detected in at least six of the fish, the computer calls or emails the technician on duty.

"It gets a human involved right away," said Bill Lawler of Intelligent Automation Corporation (IAC) in Poway, California.

The private company developed the system's software and sells the unit at a starting price of $45,000 (U.S.).

IAC says there's no humanmade sensor available that can measure toxicity harmful to humans in the same manner as bluegills.

The fish were chosen because of their commercial availability and an established database on their response to toxins.

To keep the fish from being stressed or sick, they "work" for two weeks. Then the bluegills get a break and are fed brine shrimp to keep them "happy."

Sensitive Species

Lawler says bluegills are highly attuned to water quality changes.

During routine cleanings in the New York City and San Francisco reservoirs, the fish caused an alert after divers kicked up sediment about 40 miles (64 kilometers) away, he says.

And in New York City bluegills detected a diesel leak before it got out of control.

"There's a lot of emphasis on their ability to deter terrorism, but they are also doing a lot in terms of potential watershed monitoring and accidental chemical spills in source water," Lawler said.

Under a pilot project with the U.S. Army, bluegills have monitored New York City's drinking water since 2002.

The biomonitoring unit is currently on loan from the government, but plans are underway to purchase and expand the system, says Ian Michaels, a spokesperson for the New York City Department of Environmental Protection, which supplies water to nine million people.

"We considered it to be worth investigating as an additional layer of security," Michaels said, adding that other tests—literally tens of thousands every year—are also performed to ensure safe drinking water.

Just One More Tool

The push for aquatic biomonitoring first took place in Europe about 20 years ago after a major chemical spill in Switzerland, according to Shedd, the Army biologist.

In addition to fish, other aquatic creatures such as clams and daphnia are used as indicators of chemical changes (see fish photos, profiles, and more).

"It's just recent that the U.S. has become interested in this capability," Shedd said.

"It's one tool in an arsenal of tools to monitor for water quality and to protect surface waters," he added.

"It's not a stand-alone technology. It's a complement to the current technology we already have out there."

Free Email News Updates
Best Online Newsletter, 2006 Codie Awards

Sign up for our Inside National Geographic newsletter. Every two weeks we'll send you our top stories and pictures (see sample).


© 1996-2008 National Geographic Society. All rights reserved.