Why doesn't this article cover the increased crime and illegitimacy rates that correspond with the changing demographics? Oh, that would be responsible journalism.
Photograph by Jacquelyn Martin, AP
Published August 14, 2014
MANASSAS, Virginia—Rebecca Apple's Latino students at Osbourn High School call her "Miss Manzana," the Spanish word for "apple." A floating teacher last year, Apple would pile her nine English-Spanish dictionaries and other supplies into a cart and travel down halls thronged with students.
She's one of hundreds of public school teachers in Manassas, in Prince William County outside Washington, D.C., who've struggled to adjust to the arrival of scores of new Hispanic students; a fresh onslaught is expected when school opens in a few weeks' time. Last year, Apple's class size for her beginner English for Speakers of Other Languages course grew so quickly that she was receiving one or two new immigrant students every day for a month.
Matilde Rosa Jimenez taught as many as 37 kids in her eighth-grade English class at Metz Middle School, from gifted students to kids struggling with basic reading comprehension to immigrants who spoke little or no English. Some of her students had trouble reading in their native language. And in one county public elementary school, 60 different languages are spoken.
Educating immigrant children has tested the capacity of the county's schools in other ways as well. Hundreds of trailers have been turned into makeshift classrooms to handle the overflow.
With 50,000 unaccompanied children flooding into the United States this summer, many towns and cities are expecting apprehended minors to be moved to their communities, at least temporarily. The national reaction has run the gamut from cautious willingness to open hostility. In the middle-class suburbs of Washington, D.C., where waves of immigrants have long been a source of cultural tension, the potential for a new influx has sparked angry debate and calls for immediate deportations.
Manassas has a main street that is traditional Americana, with red brick buildings and hanging flower baskets. But Hispanic influence in the city is growing, and many services and businesses cater to Spanish speakers. According to predictions from the Weldon Cooper Center for Public Service, a think tank at the University of Virginia, the county's Hispanic population will rise nearly 50 percent, from 81,460 in 2010 to 118,748 in 2020. (At the start of 2013, its total population was estimated at 431,000.)
In Manassas, the Hispanic community has doubled within the last decade and now makes up a third of the population. The small city, with a population of around 28,000, has become a battleground just as surely as it was during the Civil War.
Coming to America
Between October 2011 and September 2012, some 13,000 minors trickled across the U.S. border illegally. By October 2014, that number is estimated to reach 90,000, and few agencies are ready for the flood.
To make it here, children as young as five hide in trains, paddle in boats, or come on foot. One girl lived on peppermint candy for eight days. Another carried her two-month-old baby over her head as she crossed the Rio Grande.
They come to find family in the U.S. and to be a part of the American Dream. They come with the belief that the Obama Administration's Deferred Action program, meant to help young undocumented immigrants who've lived in the U.S. since 2007, will also offer them a reprieve. They come to escape gangs, drug cartels, and persecution in their native countries. A recent UN High Commissioner for Refugees study found that 48 percent of these minors experienced violence or threats in their home countries, mostly Guatemala, Honduras, and El Salvador.
Along their secret journey, they may be trafficked, robbed, or raped.
"They would rather risk their lives in trying to get to a better situation than stay in their current situation," says immigration attorney Susannah Nichols of Livesay & Myers. She adds that child immigrants don't have the right to an attorney in the U.S. as a suspect in a criminal case would.
"What kind of country are we going to be at the end of the day?" she says. "If you had to look at the face of a child, and you knew that the kid would be killed or harmed, would you send him or her back?"
Waiting 484 Days
When the children, often malnourished and confused, are caught at the border, federal law requires that they go through a deportation process. But the deluge has overwhelmed the Office of Refugee Resettlement, which lacks the resources to place and process the children. In Virginia, the average wait time for a court hearing is 484 days.
The long wait is a source of panic and indignation. "All some people hear is, 'These are Latino children coming in, everyone should do whatever it takes to take care of them.' How many, at what cost, and what do we give up to do that? Is that a trade-off we're willing to make?" asks Help Save Manassas president Greg Letiecq. Given that the organization has attracted up to 2,500 members, it's clear that many people in the community share his position.
A Shelter for Children
A 13-minute drive from Osbourn High School, behind a manicured lawn in the town of Bristow, Youth for Tomorrow takes in undocumented children caught at the U.S. border, under a contract with the federal government. An American flag, a Virginia flag, and a YFT flag billow in the wind beside each other, and plastic water bottles clutter a table by a basketball court.
Many locals wonder what happens once the children walk through the facility's doors. They ask whether the children will receive inoculations so that they can't spread disease. They don't know where the children will be sent as they wait for their court hearings or how the relocations will affect their community. They fear that the children will try to run away. Some are even skeptical that the immigrants sent there are truly minors, because without documents, they can claim to be any age.
YFT, founded by former Redskins head coach Joe Gibbs, has not answered these public concerns, arguing that the organization must give its full attention to the children. That's made some locals call their behavior secretive and suspicious, adding further fuel to the heated debate. Says electrician Dennis Durham: "We don't know the health diseases coming across the border. There have been reports of MRSA, scabies, and now there are fears of Ebola."
Makeup artist JoAnn Abbott says she's already wary, since three years ago a drunk undocumented immigrant hit her car; within three months, she says, her husband and son were in their own car accidents with undocumented immigrants. Now she worries that YFT's kids will flee "and get into trouble in the local community. What is to stop the illegals, and probably gang members, from escaping once they are up here and setting up their illegal businesses? Why are my tax dollars going to help ship in and set up more gangs?"
Sources who asked not to be named say the community has little to worry about from a resource or health perspective. The YFT program for the undocumented children is funded strictly by federal dollars, and an additional program for troubled local youth operates with state and local dollars.
In addition, within 36 hours, YFT's new arrivals are inoculated and receive a medical exam. They stay about 40 days at the private institution and receive private schooling before transitioning to a sponsor home. None have run away.
Few Local Placements
What's more, less than 2 percent of YFT's children are placed locally, amounting so far to less than a dozen kids. The Migration Policy Institute estimates that 90 percent of the unaccompanied children are placed with parents, relatives, or family friends.
But city council member Andrew Harrover says the lack of information about the center has been harmful. "A lot more transparency and a lot less evasion would help people understand the problem. The federal government shouldn't round up kids, then in the dark of night ship them off to other states. The citizens need to know and understand."
Most juveniles also choose to attend their court hearing. About 60 percent show up on their scheduled day, 93 percent when the children have a lawyer—which means they're less likely to vanish into the surrounding community indefinitely.
The Lure of Construction Jobs
Immigrants were first drawn to Prince William County around 2000 by a booming construction industry and a cheap housing market. The Hispanic newcomers worked in drywall installation and painting, then in the sheet metal and electrical trades—and quickly got a leg up over existing service businesses by charging less per hour.
Residential overcrowding soon became a lightning rod issue. It was not uncommon for a two-bedroom town house to be filled with a dozen migrant workers—neighbors who were often unwelcome on streets lined with nuclear families. "Manassas was ground zero for a lot of the immigration problems, and I was elected shortly after all of the fun and games started," says Harrover, who came into office in 2006. "Nobody knew what the hell they were doing."
Meetings at city hall sometimes ran until 11 p.m., with fervid residents offering three-minute diatribes. Harrover stopped going to his regular restaurant, City Tavern Grille, for lunch, since voluble townspeople would turn a simple lunch break into a referendum on immigration.
Some locals expressed their opposition by forming a grassroots organization. "These border crashers have contributed to rising crime rates, increasing burdens on our schools, hospitals, and public services, and the very destruction of our American culture," Help Save Manassas wrote in a 2007 newsletter.
When Corey Stewart was elected chairman of the Prince William Board of County Supervisors that year, the board put into place a plan to purge the county of undocumented immigrants. The new law allowed local law enforcement to ask people their citizenship status, even if they were not suspected of wrongdoing. Prince William County was catapulted into national headlines.
A year later the county amended the law. A person would need to be arrested before state and local law enforcement officers could enforce federal immigration law. That meant deputized officers could pull people over for driving violations, interrogate and arrest them, and investigate their immigration status. Thousands of immigrants were turned over to customs officials by local authorities, and thousands more fled the possibility by choice.
Now the new battle cry in Manassas is to keep the undocumented children from settling in the county. "We should deport illegal immigrants who are in violation of our laws, because it is the law and because that discourages other potential illegal immigrants," says Letiecq. "There is a legal process for legitimate immigration, and it starts at an embassy or consulate, not with the Border Patrol tens or hundreds of miles inside the U.S."
"An Act of War Upon Our People"
Shane Long, vice chairman of the Maryland chapter of the League of the South, takes a more radical position. Child or adult, legal or illegal—it doesn't matter, he says. He asserts that "a large amount" of native Virginians and Marylanders share his belief that all of the above intrude on Southerners' right to exist as a distinct people. "Any act or nonaction by the federal government to bring about such large influxes of non-Southern peoples is genocide and is viewed as [that] by native Southerners," he says. "It is, in effect, an act of war upon our people."
"They Don't Want to See Brown-Skinned People Here"
Given the intensity of feeling, many Hispanics live in fear, says Prince William County resident Wendy Jimenez, a community organizer for Casa de Virginia. They hear the anger echo in government meetings and feel it around the corner on many streets. She says Hispanics are more likely to get into trouble than a white person for the same act; she cites a Latino friend who was recently ticketed for jaywalking when he rushed to catch his bus.
She claims locals don't differentiate between people who come here legally and those who don't—to them, all Hispanics look undocumented. "They don't want to see brown-skinned people here," she says. "That's the real problem."
But Letiecq says he does distinguish between legal and undocumented immigrants. He adds that he believes that the latter get what they can and then go back to their own countries without contributing to the community. "They aren't buying the American dream like an American would," he says. "They're renting it."
Still, Hispanics feel power in their growing numbers. Jimenez says more Hispanics from Prince William County and Manassas participate in the organization's rallies, demonstrations, and protests than Hispanics from the surrounding areas. "We're gonna fight, help keep the community together, share stories, and raise our voices," she says. "We are not going to stop."
The Schools Gear Up
Handling the influx of nonnative English students is not easy, but the public schools are managing even as budgets are slashed. Manassas teachers break big classes into groups, offer test-preparation sessions, and teach evening and Saturday classes. They also make themselves available to students as much as they can. Rebecca Apple recalls that one student read The Hunger Games aloud in English to another teacher even though he didn't yet understand the words.
"Everything we think of to better improve opportunities for ESOL students is benefiting other students," says Matilde Rosa Jimenez. The scores of both ESOL and mainstream students have risen.
Locals argue that if public school teachers can't handle the exploding student population, it will be reflected in test scores and will ultimately diminish the community's reputation as a desirable place to live. But the better test scores reflect a more hopeful scenario.
In Prince William County's public schools, SAT scores have improved, matching or surpassing the national average in two of three areas. Black students outperformed the state and national average, and Hispanic students made enough progress in critical reading to pass the national average. Now teachers like Apple and Rosa Jimenez just want more teachers and a better screening process to address the needs of ESOL kids.
Do they know the legal status of their students? "To me, that's not a priority," says Rosa Jimenez. "They need to be educated. They are children."
"I don't ask," says Apple. "I don't want to know."
There is a solution to "illegal immigration." Make it "legal." It is time to restore open borders.
The government should not be in the education business. If it does not want immigrants to attend schools, it should get out of the business.
I don't understand how there could be any argument or debate about this issue.
If something is illegal, it's illegal.
It doesn't matter who breaks the law or why.
IT IS AGAINST LAW. IT IS A CRIME.
I don't see why we should reward or coddle criminals in this country when we are unable to even care for our own.
Shane Long is right. Unrestricted mass immigration from the third world
is genocide via planned demographic replacement of the native white
Southern population descended from the original colonists. "We the People of the United States, in Order to form a more
perfect Union, establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility,
provide for the common defence, promote the general Welfare,
and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity..." Catch that last part? To ourselves and our Posterity (i.e. the descendants of the original population). We are being dispossessed in the country our forefathers established for us and that country is being handed over to an alien population with radically different culture and values.
My car was not struck by an "Undocumented Immigrant". It was hit by a drunk driving illegal alien. My husbands car was not struck by an undocumented immigrant. It was hit by an illegal alien. My sons car was not broadsided by an undocumented immigrant who then fled and was the subject of a two hour manhunt, it was struck by an ILLEGAL ALIEN. Please get your terminology correct. I have NO problem with immigrants who waited their turn and did everything they needed to in order to become American citizens. I have a LOT of problems with illegal aliens who are here to steal the benefits of the American Dream from those who have worked to earn them.
What we resent is not "brown-skinned people," as Ms. Jimenez asserts. It's the ruined public schools, the food stamps, and the uninsured drivers.
When many of our forefathers came through Ellis Island, they needed to be (1) married, (2) have a sponsoring family able to integrate them, or (3) have confirmed employment. My great grandfathers arrived as teenagers and worked in the coal mines of Northeastern Pennsylvania. It was important to learn and speak English, for that was all part of the transition from the bad to the good. With these children from Central America being encouraged to come to the US, it seems that one option of that system could work today. Since many are too young to work and are not married, then the option would be for a sponsoring family to integrate them into the American way of life.
I have not seen in the news or heard of a program for families to adopt these children. Long ago before adoption agencies, there were orphanages. While I do not see it the responsibility of the US, state or local government to establish new orphanages, it seems like under the faith based initiatives, that there could be an option to integrate these little ones into families or group homes that have a track record of success with the youth. Is that not an option?
Unless you're going to start calling drug dealers "unlicensed pharmacists" you need to start calling these people what they are: illegal.
These undocumented children are illegal aliens who need to be deported. Our Federal Government has Billions of dollars to take care of these children and yet they ignore the problems of our own American children in places like Detroit and South Chicago. This is wrong. Its time for the Federal Government to start doing their job and enforce the law. Deport all illegal aliens. Secure the border and fine any company that hires illegal aliens. The "Construction" work that is being discussed in the article is ALL illegal and needs to be stopped. Where is ICE? Why are they not cracking down on this?
"Diatribes" and "They don't want to see brown-skinned people here," she says. "That's the real problem."
Ah, the "good old college try for Obama" -- as one would expect from National Geographic, based as it is in Imperial D.C. (to wit: Headquarters,
National Geographic Society; 1145 17th Street N.W.; Washington, D.C. 20036-4688). Let's get as many "unsolicited comments" about racists to stuff into the article.
The bigger problem ... for Obama and the Democrat Party, not to mention for National Geographic (do Illegals donate to "the Society"?) ... is that Manassas (most of the U.S., probably) is not interested in annually handing over millions of dollars of tax moneys to support / feed / educate hundreds of thousands of Illegals, in return for the dubious benefit of being converted into Juarez. Even the soft-shoe, soft-pedal "We Heart Illegals" article above notes that Prince William County has roughly 100,000 mainly Illegal and mainly Mexicans, out of a total population of around 400,000; so roughly 25% of the county is now populated by Illegals (all having LOTS of babies too, to be sure).
If Virginians wanted to live in Juarez or Tijuana ... doubtless they'd take some Spanish classes and move down to one of those delightful dust-traps.
Manassas (the town itself) is at best "middle-middle-class". Probably "working class" would be closer to the mark (around 2 decades ago I owned a fairly large horse farm in neighboring Fauquier County and so know whereof I speak). Being "working class", Manassas is "cheap" in terms of cost-of-living (if anyplace within commuting distance of Imperial D.C. can be called "cheap").
And accordingly -- "cheap" -- Manassas must be a magnet for Mexicans who work in the D.C. area service sector (fast-food places, Denny's, retail stores, supermarkets) yet need someplace cheap to flop.
These (mainly) Mexicans must certainly be displacing working-class whites in the relatively rural Virginia counties within a 1.5 to 2.0 hour commute of D.C., and the influx of (mainly) Mexicans are surely displacing the working-class West Virginians (the commuter vans that make the daily run back & forth I-66 are well-known, famous, infamous, and notorious all at the same time).
It would be a surprise only to "mainstream" journalists that Illegals/Mexicans coming almost out of nowhere to suddenly comprise 25% of the population of a rural country ... would cause consternation. "But Whyyy...? It's a Beautiful Kumbaya Thiiiinggg...!"
Prediction: Influx of Mexicans sucking up all the service-sector jobs and draining other public resources (what, you think nobody notices at the local Kroger's when they pull out an EBT card or hand over WIC papers?) ... will not gain them much admiration from working-class whites who have run out of employment benefits.
Virginia may end up not as deep-blue an Obama-Loving Democrat stronghold, as the media insists it is. Obama better hurry up and do as much damage as he can before November 2014; he may find his options "surprisingly" curtailed by the time December 2014 comes around.
@DAVID SHELLENBERGER Make it legal the right way. Send them back and re-apply to enter US with the proper way and follow the rules and waiting time just every other immigrant
then we will have open border because it is safe for the country.
@DAVID SHELLENBERGER "Restore" open borders? We haven't had open borders since 1875. Even before this the founders understood the importance of limiting citizenship (the other side of the "restore open borders" coin its supporters never want to address). From the first immigration law in 1790, anyone could enter the country but only whites (Europeans) of good character could ever become citizens (and only white men could vote) and there was no welfare of any kind. This makes sense as this was always intended to be principally a British country. When you bring in people who come from a completely different legal, social, and cultural tradition AND let them vote then in the proportion they exist within your country it ceases to to be YOUR country and becomes THEIR country. Different people create different kinds of societies.
@Ginge Vitis From the looks of your picture, you'd be better off getting some exercise and fixing your diet than worrying about the legal status of a bunch of terrorized children.
@Ginge Vitis They aren't illegal people, they are illegal immigrants. I am opposed to illegal immigration for security and economic reasons, as well as because it disrespects the many people who immigrated here legally. But I think it is important not to demonize the people who illegally immigrate here. That can have tragic consequences.
@Charles Brown They are needed by the Left to,
eventually, vote Democratic.
No, you don't know of what you speak. Most of the Hispanics in PWC and Manassas are from El Salvador.
There are no Kroger stores in the area. You are full of it in your assessment.
Feed the World
How do we feed nine billion people by 2050, and how do we do so sustainably?
We've made our magazine's best stories about the future of food available in a free iPad app.
Latest From Nat Geo
These cooing Casanovas use showstopping plumage to court females and fend off rivals.
Meet a trapper who keeps Florida's streets, sewers, and Kennedy Space Center alligator free.