Photograph by Isvett Verde, Demotix
Published August 8, 2013
Something smelled fishy early Wednesday when a wet, dead shark was found under the seats of a subway car in New York City.
Metropolitan Transit Authority officials did not identify the shark's species nor where it came from, MTA spokesperson Kevin Ortiz told CNN.
When the train arrived at Ditmars Boulevard in Queens, an MTA supervisor reported that the small shark was dead and cleared it from the car. Conservation group Shark Advocates International has identified the animal as a smooth dogfish, a heavily fished Atlantic species with weak finning rules in the U.S.
Rumors about the shark's origin are circulating around the Internet, and someone even created the Twitter handle @NYCSubwayShark with over 560 followers. Ortiz joked from the MTA spokesperson Twitter account @MTA_NYCT_Vocero of "unconfirmed reports that the shark was headed home after a night of partying in Coney Island." The MTA said it will not investigate the incident.
But this mysterious shark isn't the only creature making an appearance on public transportation. From birds on a train to goats on a bus—adaptable animals are learning how to get around our expanding cities.
In many cases, animal "commuters" are motivated more by food and security than anything else, said Suzanne MacDonald, a psychologist and biologist at York University in Toronto, Canada, who studies urban wildlife.
"If they're sitting there thinking, 'I gotta catch that 3 o'clock bus in order to make it to the movies,' then we're in deep doo-doo," quipped MacDonald, who receives funding from the National Geographic Expeditions Council.
Instead, animals that end up on buses or trains usually realize "if they get on this thing and get off this thing, in between they [can be] treated pretty well and rewarded for it."
Indeed, urban-wildlife ecologist Seth Magle noted that many animals drawn to public transportation are likely getting fed by people, which should be avoided.
"It seems cute, but it's an opportunity where people can come into conflict with animals," said Magle, who directs the Lincoln Park Zoo's Urban Wildlife Institute.
Magle's program works to tell urbanites that they're part of a living ecosystem, and that wildlife are still figuring out how to co-exist with them. (Read why cities are environmental solutions.)
"Our cities are not sterile—we built them for humans, but other species are going to find use of them," he said.
Here are five animals that travel human-style.
Birds on a train? Believe it. Pigeons have been known to take the A Line on the New York City subway. According to a 2002 New York Times article, when trains lay over at Far Rockaway Station at the end of the line, pigeons walk onto the trains in search of crumbs.
"But being pigeons, they do not listen for the announcement that the train is leaving, and the doors close on them. They ride generally for one stop, exiting as soon as the doors open again," the Times reported.
But they're not total bird brains: The article reported that a train conductor would see them promptly fly back to the Far Rockaway terminal for more free food. (See National Geographic's bird pictures.)
Talk about getting your goat—an owner in Multnomah County, Oregon, was asked to retrieve her pet goat after it escaped and hitched a ride on a Portland schoolbus in 2008.
The goat was "taken into custody by transit police for lack of proper fare," Portland news station WCSH reported, citing a Multnomah County Animal Control official.
Also in 2008, in Mahoning County, Ohio, news station WFMJ reported on a pet goat that would follow its owner onto a schoolbus—giving new meaning to the term "new kid on the block."
Wily as ever, the coyote has taken to city life, increasingly popping up in urban areas from Chicago to New York.
The predators are versatile—eating everything from shoe leather to fruit—and adaptable, shifting their normally daytime schedules to night to adapt to city life, experts say. (See city pictures.)
In 2002, a coyote hopped on the light rail at the airport in Portland, Oregon, and got comfortable on a seat—but wildlife specialists removed and released it before the train took off.
Even so, the sneaky interloper is forever immortalized in a song: Sleater-Kinney's "Light-Rail Coyote."
Take Macavity, the kitty who would get on a busy bus at the same stop in Walsall every morning, and then jump off at the next stop not far down the road—which just happens to be near a fish-and-chip shop, the Daily Mail reported in 2007.
"I suppose he is the perfect passenger really—he sits quietly, minds his own business, and then gets off," passenger Paul Brennan told the paper.
Then there's Casper the commuter cat, which BBC News reported in 2009 was a regular on a bus near its home in St. Budeaux, England. Sadly, Casper died in 2010 after being hit by a car while crossing the road to board the bus, according to the Daily Mail.
A commuting feline named Dodger liked to sit in laps as he rode the bus around Dorset, England, the Daily Mail reported in 2011. His owner suspects the cat was attracted to the warmth of the bus and recently vacated seats.
MacDonald noted that domestic animals like cats are likely more comfortable hopping on buses because they're used to people—but that it's still "amazing" they're not stressed by the riding experience.
Delhi has a monkey on its back—well, make that several thousand. The Indian city's rhesus monkey population is exploding, bolstered by people who feed the critters, which are considered living representatives of the Hindu god Hanuman, according to a 2012 article in the New York Times.
The emboldened animals have also overrun parts of the city. According to the Times, the animals "treat the Indian Parliament building as a playground, have invaded the prime minister's office and Defense Ministry, sometimes ride buses and subway trains, and chase diplomats from their well-tended gardens."
This monkey videotaped on the Delhi metro looks like a regular commuter, responsibly holding onto the banister and settling into a seat.
Tell us: Have you seen an animal getting around in an unusual way?
—Jaclyn Skurie contributed reporting
Soooo.... the shark decided to catch the subway for beneficial reasons. Okay, so how in the world did he get on the train. It's a shark. last I checked they couldn't just walk among us on dry land, or sneak in on accident through our swimsuits, (without us noticing of course).
I saw an article a while back about 'wild' dogs regularly taking the metro from the outskirts to the centre of Moscow, and back, daily! Lx
none of em hold a candle next to the strays on the Moscow subway system
last July 31,2013 we had this news in the Philippines that a stray cat travels 11,000 km from our country going to Los Angles California ... good thing the US Customs did not require the cat for US Visa... http://www.abs-cbnnews.com/video/lifestyle/classified-odd/07/31/13/stray-cat-philippines-ends-us
A few months ago I was on vacation with my family in London(UK), when we got on the Tube, and saw four or five pigeons actually sitting on the seats of the Tube, so some people had to stand and wait for the pigeons to get off at their stop.
Just saw your post after I'd posted mine. Exactly - none of these hold a candle to those canines in Russia. Lx
How to Feed Our Growing Planet
National Geographic explores how we can feed the growing population without overwhelming the planet in our food series.
The Innovators Project
Meet some of science's most important movers and shakers—from past and present.
Latest News Video
Mazes are a powerful tool for neuroscientists trying to figure out the brain and help us learn to grapple with the unexpected.