Photograph by J. Telling
Published May 17, 2013
Pockets of water trapped in rocks from a Canadian mine are over a billion years old, and the water could contain life forms that can survive independently from the sun, scientists said this week.
The ancient water was collected from boreholes at Timmins Mine beneath Ontario, Canada, at a depth of about 1.5 miles (2.4 kilometers).
"When these rocks formed, this part of Canada was the ocean floor," said study co-author Barbara Sherwood Lollar, an Earth scientist at Canada's University of Toronto.
"When we go down [into the mine] with students, we like to say imagine you're walking on the seafloor 2.6 billion years ago."
Working with U.K. colleagues Chris Ballentine and Greg Holland, Sherwood Lollar and her team found that the water was rich in dissolved gases such as hydrogen and methane, which could provide energy for microbes like those found around hydrothermal vents in the deep ocean.
In addition, the water contained different rare gases that include the elements helium, neon, argon, and xenon, which were created through interactions with the surrounding radioactive rock. By measuring the concentrations of isotopes of these "noble gases"—so called because they rarely interact with other elements—the team could estimate how long the water had been trapped underground and whether it had been isolated.
Depending on the noble gas analyzed, the age estimates for the water varied between 1.1 billion years old and 2.6 billion years old—or as old as the rocks in the mine itself.
"It shows us that there's been very little mixing between this water and the surface water," Sherwood Lollar said. "What we want to do with further work is see if we can narrow that [age range] down."
Teeming With Life?
Geologists have long known that a lot of water can be present in continental crust, locked away in microscopic voids in minerals, pore spaces between minerals, and veins and fractures in the rock. But what's been unclear is the age of such water, said geochemist Steven Shirey, a senior scientist at the Carnegie Institution for Science.
"The question is how old is it? Is it water that's part of current circulation with surface water? Or is it water that retains old chemistry and potential biota?" said Shirey, who was not involved in the study.
The new findings, detailed in this week's issue of the journal Nature, is evidence that ancient pockets of water can remain isolated in the Earth's crust for billions of years.
"That's the really exciting part about this study," Shirey said.
Sherwood Lollar and her team are testing the mine water to see if they can find evidence of living microbes. If life does exist in the water, she said, it could be similar to microbes previously found in far younger water flowing from a mine located 1.74 miles (2.8 kilometers) beneath South Africa.
Those microbes could survive without light from the sun, subsisting instead on chemicals created through the interactions between water and rock.
Such "buried" microbial communities are rare, and fascinating for scientists because they are often not interconnected.
"Each one of them may have a different age and a different history," Sherwood Lollar said. "It will be fascinating for us to look at the microbiology in each of them ... It'll tell us something about the evolution of life and the colonization of the subsurface."
The Timmins Mine water could also help scientists understand how much of the subsurface of the Earth is actually inhabited by life. The answer to that question has implications for life on other planets, such as Mars, scientists say.
"It opens up your horizons for what's possible," Shirey said. "If you think that you can have microbial life throughout the entire crust of the Earth, then all of a sudden it becomes very possible that life could live on other planets under the right condition."
That raises questions about potential life in relatively warm rock located beneath the cold surface of Mars, where liquid water could still exist.
"We're looking at billion-year-old rock here and we can still find flowing water that's full of the kind of energy that can support life," Sherwood Lollar said.
"If we find Martian rocks of the same age and in places of similar geology and mineralogy to our site, then there's every reason to think that we might be able to find the same thing in the deep subsurface of Mars."
There seems to be a debate over weather this is true or not. That's not a bad topic for the debate club at my school. I for one think this is not only possible, but likely. Yes, rocks are porous, and it depends upon the type of rock, but think of how much time it would take for water to seep through them.
I understand the claim but to say that the pocket of water is a billion of years old is impossible. The water is gathered in rock and rock is very porous and any water gathered there even with extreme isolation would have seeped through and or evaporated many times over.
I am excited about the containment of the elements of microbes and other sustained life to found there, even though those I suspect are now tainted by the opening of the pocket.
they don't know it was trapped there for billions of years. It's all a wild guess. A wrong wild guess.
@John Cotter since you and others are contradicting it
@John Cotter where do you derive your expertise? not trying to be snarky i really want to know if you're in the field or something
@j. winchell You don't know it wasn't trapped there for billions of years. You've just made a wild guess. A wrong wild guess.
@j. winchell We can know by analyzing the water and measuring the depth in the earth's crust.
@Simon Willett @j. winchell While there may be proof that it is billions of years old, humans should probably remember that it takes a very long time before we actually know anything for certain. Who knows if it has actually been there for billions of years or not. Its just a guess based not on wild assumptions, but on what scientists have discovered so far. There are very few things we can be 100% certain about, but we can do our best to make sense of the world around us. In other words, claiming that either one of you is wrong is a wild guess in and of itself.
How to Feed Our Growing Planet
National Geographic explores how we can feed the growing population without overwhelming the planet in our food series.
The Innovators Project
Meet some of science's most important movers and shakers—from past and present.
Latest News Video
Mazes are a powerful tool for neuroscientists trying to figure out the brain and help us learn to grapple with the unexpected.