National Geographic Daily News
A reconstitution of the falcatid shark, one of the three cladodontomorph shark species discovered, in the depths of an ocean that covered what is now southern France 135 million years ago.

The factoid shark, which had a hook-like protuberance over its head, was one of a group of small sharks that survived into the era of dinosaurs.

Image courtesy Alain Beneteau 2013

Dan Vergano

National Geographic

Published October 29, 2013

A family of small sharks—some of which had spiky heads—cruised the ancient seas for far longer than scientists had suspected, surviving to about 120 million years ago. Their surprising survival suggests that deep oceans sheltered predators during past mass extinctions.

Some 252 million years ago, roughly 90 percent of the planet's marine species perished in the Permian-Triassic mass extinction event.

Tied to everything from volcanic eruptions to ocean oxygen depletion to severe climate change, the Great Dying represents the most severe challenge to life's survival seen in the fossil record. (See "The Permian Extinction—When Life Nearly Came to an End.")

Among the victims were thought to be a wide variety of early cladodont sharks. These sharks—which brandished long, sharp, T-shaped teeth—are today seen as vanished, unsuccessful cousins of modern broad-toothed sharks.

However, an international team led by Switzerland's Guillaume Guinot of the Natural History Museum in Geneva, reports in the journal Nature Communications that the sharks survived the Great Dying, lasting at least another 170 million years—well into the age of dinosaurs.

"Something we didn't ever expect—[it's] so amazing to find these ancient sharks," Guinot says. "We were looking for modern sharks, to be honest."

Ancient Sharks Survived

The team reports that teeth from three new species of cladodont sharks—one of which is unlike any kind seen before—turned up in limestone fossil beds in southern France.

The 170-million-year survival of the sharks was a revelation to researchers not involved in the new study.

"It would be the equivalent to finding a living population of the descendants of T. rex [today]," says ancient shark expert and independent researcher John-Paul Hodnett.

Nevertheless, Hodnett says, "I have to agree with their conclusions. They have genuine cladodont shark teeth."

"If they had just survived the mass extinction and then died out, that would have been no great surprise," paleontologist Mike Benton, of the University of Bristol, U.K., said by email.

"However, survival by a 100 [million years] into the Mesozoic is interesting—even if they were presumably quite rare during that long span of time."

A Toothsome Tale

The sharks were small ones—likely only about 8 inches (20 centimeters) long—and their teeth were tiny, about a millimeter across.

Even so, they were true predators, likely dining on the ancestors of today's squids and small fish in ancient oceans, Guinot says.

One of the shark species discovered by the team sported teeth similar to a more ancient shark called the falcatus shark, whose males sported a flat, sword-shaped fin above their heads, thought to have been used for sexual displays.

A second species belonged to a family of sharks with two fins on their backs, similar to modern Port Jackson sharks found today off Australia's coasts.

And the third sported teeth with neat cutting edges never before seen on this kind of ancient shark, but often seen on modern ones. (See pictures of today's sharks.)

Finally, the teeth also possessed an enamel structure similar to the teeth of modern sharks as well—another surprise, Hodnett says.

The results "strongly suggest that this trait evolved more than once" in sharks, he says, pointing to how evolution sometimes finds different avenues to the same toothy ends.

Ancient Escape Act

The limestone beds where the shark teeth turned up were deep ocean floors some 120 million years ago, study author Guinot says.

That suggests that although ocean oxygen depletion was at least one likely cause of the extinctions seen during the Great Dying, some isolated seas served as refuges for the sharks and their prey.

The small cladodont sharks probably were flexible enough in their diet to survive in the deep ocean or on the coasts.

"These were not top, top predators—they would have eaten lots of things," Guinot says.

"They probably ate other sharks as well."

Follow Dan Vergano on Twitter.

12 comments
Paula Newbury
Paula Newbury

We have to save the sharks, stop the mass slaughtering for fin soup. The government has to get together with other governments and stop the fins from coming into the country. Sharks are the top of the food chain and if they are extinct then the ocean balance will be off and we will all suffer for it. So please help with saving the sharks. They are a beautiful species and need to be around for our children to treasure.

Emily Lerch
Emily Lerch

WOW!  I would like to say thank you for sharing this amazing find and information with the world.  This is spectacular!  This article and find has taken my breath away. So little is known about our oceans and all the creatures large and small, shallow and deep waters. 

I hate the damage that we as humans, greedy and selfish, cause to our great oceans, be it our from over-fishing, far too many vessels/ships in our oceans causing damage to our wale population due to lack of ability to find mates because of our steel ships blocking mating calls....the list is never ending. 

But to see that these creatures having not only endured thru all these millions of years,but to continue to evolve give this 'Lehman' great hope for the future of our oceans.  

Again, THANK YOU for sharing this incredible find!

Our planet is more amazing and inspirational then many people truly take time to realize.

Sophie H.
Sophie H.

This is quite inspiring I believe, I wonder what else hides deep in our oceans?

Ltm Lim
Ltm Lim

Short but interesting ! Very nice and exciting while reading it .

El Gabilon
El Gabilon

The ocean is vast, humans are puny and have hardly begun to explore it. Who knows what lies within its boundries and how many species we think have become extinct are still living within it.  The truth is out there and perhaps someday we will know what that truth is. Sill the earth is not static. Continents collide and in doing so churn much of the earth into lava destroying what may have proven interesting to science.  We have no idea of how much of the earths surface has been turned over thus eliminating evidence of what was.

M. Beck
M. Beck

Evolution is amazing!

Wesley Lam
Wesley Lam

@Paula Newbury In fact, many people do not know the the shark fins in sharks' fin soup does not do anything useful. It serves mainly only to decorate the soup. For many, the only reason why they like sharks' fin soup is because of the soup, not the fins.

Killing of sharks for their fins is unnecessary and a huge waste. Imagine if we swapped places with sharks.

I am not saying that we should stop consuming sharks' fin soup - which we should, actually - by tomorrow. We just have to find ways to ensure we get what we want WITHOUT harming sharks.

Take for instance, the new laboratory-generated meat. Has anybody thought of using it for other purposes? With enough advances in science, we should be able to use that technology for meat and fish coming from endangered species or species that are declining severely in numbers.

With this kind of thinking, we can save species such as tuna, cod, sharks, et cetera by mass-producing their laboratory-made equivalents.

Trending News

Celebrating 125 Years

Latest News Video

See more videos »