National Geographic Daily News
A fossil and an illustration of an ancient, shark-like lizard.

The first mosasaur tail on record with a preserved soft tissue outline (top picture). In similarity with whales and ichthyosaurs, Mosasaurs gradually attained a shark-like appearance (bottom picture).

Photograph courtesy Johan Lindgren; illustration courtesy Stefan Sølberg

Jane J. Lee

National Geographic

Published September 10, 2013

Sea monsters lying in wait for unsuspecting prey sounds scary enough. But slap on a tail that let them run down their dinner—much like today's great white sharks—and mosasaurs could truly be considered one of the ancient world's nightmares.

And that's exactly what a new study published September 10 in Nature Communications has confirmed.

A 72-million-year-old fossil specimen of Prognathodon—a genus of mosasaur—found in a Jordanian quarry in 2008 revealed fin-like soft-tissue imprints along its tail. Those imprints demonstrate that this group of ancient sea monsters possessed powerful tails similar to ones seen on sharks today, rather than the puny ones on eels or sea snakes.

Mosasaurs were aquatic reptiles that prowled the seas and freshwater streams toward the end of the age of dinosaurs, about 98 to 66 million years ago. (Related: "Freshwater Mosasaur Stirs Marine Reptile Relationships.")

Although they are fairly well represented in the fossil record, finding soft-tissue evidence for shark-like tails on these lizard ancestors isn't something that study co-author Michael Polcyn, a vertebrate paleontologist at Southern Methodist University in Dallas, Texas, expected to come across in his lifetime.

This fossil is so well preserved that researchers can discern the direction of stiffening fibers in the tail, he added.

"You can [also] see the outlines of scales," said study co-author Johan Lindgren, a vertebrate paleontologist at Lund University in Sweden.

Questioning the Past

For over 200 years, scholars thought mosasaurs sported paddle-shaped tails much like sea snakes, said Lindgren. Since mosasaurs are true lizards, scholars formerly thought that the ancient reptile's tail should look like those on their living lizard relatives.

But this limited mosasaurs—some of which could grow to over 33 feet (10 meters) long—to short bursts of speed typical of ambush predators.

"It was generally assumed that their swimming speeds were low and at best they could do a quick lunge," said Bruce Young, a researcher at the Kirksville College of Osteopathic Medicine in Missouri who is studying how reptiles move.

The re-thinking of mosasaur tail structure suggests a much more active, high-speed swimmer, added Young, who was not involved in the study. "Could these animals be swimming down their prey? It really opens up a new way of interpreting these animals."

'Amazing' Confirmation

Scientists have questioned the prevailing view that mosasaurs had stick-straight tails for the past decade or so, said Young.

But researchers were hampered by the fact that their predictions of what a mosasaur tail looked like were based on studies of fossilized bone, he explained.

Comparing fossil mosasaur tail bones with shark tail structures led some scientists to conclude that these ancient lizards must have had lobed tails, said Polcyn.

Mosasaurs and sharks are about the same size, and researchers consider the sharks to be the closest living model for mosasaurs, said Young. Mosasaurs are more closely related, evolutionarily, to monitor lizards than they are to sharks.

Getting a fossil mosasaur with an imprint of the surrounding soft tissue is a fantastic find, Young said. "It's amazing confirmation" of what researchers have been predicting for a decade.

Ancient Heritage

At about six feet (two meters) long, researchers think the Prognathodon specimen is a juvenile. Adults in this genus can get to about 33 feet (10 meters) long.

In 2008, workers at a quarry near Amman, Jordan (map), split open one of the limestone boulders they collect to make tiles and found the mosasaur specimen inside, said Lindgren.

They called study co-author Hani Kaddumi at the Eternal River Museum of Natural History in Amman, who came out to retrieve the fossil.

Described in a 2009 paper, the specimen remained among the museum's collections until Lindgren visited in 2011.

Unfortunately, since the site rests on land owned by the quarry company, "we have to rely on the workers to find more fossils," said Lindgren.

"There are other specimens that have been collected that do contain soft tissue [traces], but not to the degree in the [Prognathodon] specimen," he added.

The vertebrate paleontologist assumes that most of the specimens workers uncover find their way onto the open market. "It's only a fraction that end up in museums," Lindgren said.

He hopes that Jordanian authorities can be convinced of the uniqueness of these finds so that more specimens can be recognized and saved. Lindgren would like to help build up the collections at the Eternal River Museum.

Raising public awareness about fossils isn't easy in Jordan, which is heavily affected by refugees and the strife in next-door Syria. But Lindgren says that means making people aware of the natural history in their midst is more important than ever. (Related: "Pictures: Syrian Cultural Sites Damaged by Conflict.")

The researcher realizes the difficulty inherent in this, what with Syria so close by. "[But] my intention is to be able to get the Jordanian people aware that this is part of their heritage," Lindgren said.

Follow Jane J. Lee on Twitter.

7 comments
David Bump
David Bump

"Stiffening fibers in the tail"? Hey, maybe they're proto-feathers! Oh wait, this is an aquatic creature, not a dino that somebody wants to believe is the ancestor of a dinosaur.  It's sad to think that we've been imagining mosasaurs as poor swimmers due to assumptions about supposed ancestors instead of focusing on their environment and systematic design constraints, especially since there's no line of monitor-like lizard fossils gradually becoming more aquatic.  (Here's one little guy dated about 20 million years earlier than this one, that was still walking on land: http://dinosaurs.about.com/od/aquaticdinosaurs/p/dallasaurus.htm )


  Here's a similar story about an ichthyosaur fossil surprise:
http://www.express.co.uk/news/science-technology/399831/Mysterious-sea-monster-fossil-leaves-experts-baffled
 
Mysterious 'sea monster' fossil leaves experts baffled

A FOSSIL from Iraq has deepened the mystery surrounding the fate of ichthyosaurs – giant dolphin-like reptiles that swam the oceans millions of years ago.
 
By: Charlotte Meredith
Published: Wed, May 15, 2013

ajeeth mr
ajeeth mr

its am amazing to hear ancian animals life style


Arabisca M
Arabisca M

Regarding the mosasaur from Jordan, your article says:

"It sat among the museum's collections until Lindgren visited in 2011 and noticed the specimen."

This is incorrect information! The specimen did not set among the museum collections until Lindgren visited in 2011!! It was discovered and collected in 2008 by H. Kaddumi, a Jordanian paleontologist of the Eternal River Museum of Natural History. Subsequently, and in 2009, the mosasaur specimen was reported and described (EXCLUDING the tail fluke) by H. Kaddumi in a 224 pgs monograph published by his museum "Fossils of the Harrana Fauna and the Adjacent Areas". This is what the recent manuscript of Lindgren et al., pointed out clearly.

Following would be a better sentence:

Although the specimen was initially reported in 2009 by H. Kaddumi, the tail fluke which was still imbedded in matrix, was discovered by Lindgren in 2011 while visiting the collections of the Eternal River Museum of Natural History.

This is a highly important fossil specimen and I urge you to correct the error in your article which gives the impression the specimen was lost and neglected for many years immediately after its retrieval. 

Arabisca M
Arabisca M

@Fernando GarciaNot exactly, the sentence in the article gives a wrong impression. They should have paid more attention to the paper by Lindgren et al. Following is the exact impression I got until I read their paper:  "After the retrieval of the fossil, it sat collecting dust in the museum until 2011". Obviously it did not just set in the museum, it was reported and that led to the recognition of the fossil and eventually to the discovery of the tail fin when the lead author of the paper visited in 2011.

Share

How to Feed Our Growing Planet

  • Feed the World

    Feed the World

    National Geographic explores how we can feed the growing population without overwhelming the planet in our food series.

See blogs, stories, photos, and news »

The Innovators Project

See more innovators »

Latest News Video

  • Mazes: Key to Brain Development?

    Mazes: Key to Brain Development?

    Mazes are a powerful tool for neuroscientists trying to figure out the brain and help us learn to grapple with the unexpected.

See more videos »

See Us on Google Glass

Shop Our Space Collection

  • Be the First to Own <i>Cosmos: A Spacetime Odyssey</i>

    Be the First to Own Cosmos: A Spacetime Odyssey

    The updated companion book to Carl Sagan's Cosmos, featuring a new forward by Neil deGrasse Tyson is now available. Proceeds support our mission programs, which protect species, habitats, and cultures.

Shop Now »