-
Crucial Waters
Photograph courtesy Cristina Mittermeier, ILCP
Canada's pristine western coastline could be endangered by a plan to build a new oil pipeline from Alberta to the coast in order to export oil overseas, say environmental activists and native people who rely on these waters.
Oil company Enbridge plans to link the oil sands of Athabasca, in central Alberta, to the port town of Kitimat in British Columbia, with a new pipeline that would carry 525,000 barrels of oil to the coast per day.
There's just one problem: the pipeline would pass through watersheds important to Canada's commercial fishing industry and brush past Coastal First Nations lands and the Great Bear Rainforest, a protected coastal area filled with red cedars, spruce, and the elusive all-white "spirit bear."While the Northern Gateway pipeline itself wouldn't pass through the 4.4-million-acre (1.8-million-hectare) Great Bear Rainforest, activists say it's a little too close for comfort. The International League of Conservation Photographers recently performed a Rapid Assessment Visual Expedition (RAVE) in the area, sending a dozen photographers to the rain forest to document the ecosystem they believe is at risk. A pipeline means more tankers, and because the Kitimat terminal is separated from the open ocean by more than one hundred miles of channels and fjords, the photographers argue that a tanker spill would imperil the local environment. "These are highly treacherous waters, with tremendous currents," said Cristina Mittermeier, ILCP president.
(Related: Oil reserves put Canada's Great Bear Rainforest under the lens)
The danger is not just to plants and wildlife: The lifestyle of the First Nations people living in and around the rain forest, such as these Gitga'at fishermen gathering crab in a photo from the Great Bear RAVE, would be at risk. "One major oil spill on the coast of British Columbia would wipe us out," Coastal First Nations director Gerald Amos said in a statement.
–Rachel Kaufman
Published October 7, 2010
-
Swimming Upstream
Photograph courtesy Thomas P. Peschak, Save Our Seas/ILCP
Pink salmon migrate upriver to spawn in an unidentified stream in the Great Bear Rainforest.
The rivers in the Great Bear Rainforest (and, indeed in much of British Columbia) are fertile spots for Coho, Chinook, Sockeye, Pink, Chum, and Steelhead salmon. First Nations subsistence fishers, wildlife such as bears and wolves, and to some extent commercial fisheries depend on the abundance in these rivers.
Published October 7, 2010
-
Rocky Seal Respite
Photograph courtesy Daniel Beltra, ILCP
Seals sun themselves on the rocky coast of British Columbia. The Douglas Channel, the path from the Pacific to Kitimat, would take an oil tanker, escorted by tugboats, up to 18 hours, said Stafford Reid, an environmental consultant who previously worked for the British Columbia Ministry of Environment. Given the trip time and the quantity of oil coming through the new pipeline, "there'll be a tanker coming through that channel pretty much every day," Reid said. "That's a pretty intense use of a coastal channel."
Enbridge, which hopes to export its oil to energy-hungry countries in Asia, says the route is safe. It's "more safe in terms of depth and width than other ports tankers use around the world, and a lot wider and deeper than the port of Vancouver," Enbridge spokesman Alan Roth said.
Published October 7, 2010
-
A Different Oil
Photograph courtesy Ian McAllister, ILCP
Sea stars and kelp make a pretty picture off the coast of British Columbia that could see new oil tanker traffic if the pipeline plan moves forward.
Reid, the consultant, said that Enbridge was performing "various layers of due diligence . . . most oil tanker companies are safe. Reasonably safe." He added, however, that he did not believe federal standards for emergency response were strict enough to ensure a fast cleanup in the event of a spill, and that the heavy oil that the tankers would be carrying—mined and extracted from the bituminous sands of Alberta—would confound standard cleanup techniques. "It has different properties in the environment, which will challenge the use of our current technologies to clean it up."
(Related, from National Geographic Magazine: "The Canadian Oil Boom")
Published October 7, 2010
-
Tall Cedars
Photograph courtesy Cristina Mittermeier, ILCP
Chief Qwatsinas (Edward Moody) of the Nuxalk Nation and a friend of the photographer gaze at a giant cedar tree near Bella Coola, British Columbia, in this photo taken in spring 2010. The large cedars in the Great Bear Rainforest were once used in almost every aspect of the Coastal First Nations' people's lives: bark for clothing and utensils, branches for rope and fish traps, logs to make canoes.
Published October 7, 2010
-
Lessons of the Gulf?
Photograph courtesy Thomas P. Peschak, Save Our Seas/ILCP
Looking like a discarded piece of plastic, a hooded nudibranch, or predatory sea slug, swims to new feeding grounds with the Great Bear Rainforest trees in the background.
The pipeline project, ILCP President Mittermieier contends, is "such an inappropriate push for oil development in areas where there should be none. The lessons learned from the Gulf oil spill need to be translated into some protective action."
(Related: "Why The Gulf Oil Spill Isn't Going Away")
Pipeline owner Enbridge is responsible for an oil leak in Michigan in July. But company spokesman Roth said that the application for the Northern Gateway project was filed with federal regulators at the end of May, and that the company didn't anticipate new questions about safety even given Enbridge's recent track record. "All those issues around pipeline safety and construction, we think we've addressed them in the regulatory filing . . . it's important to remember that the Michigan pipeline was built in the 1960s and the Northern Gateway pipeline would not begin construction until 2013."
Published October 7, 2010
-
Spirited Snare
Photograph courtesy Ian McAllister, ILCP
A "spirit bear" snatches a fish from a Great Bear Rainforest stream.
Spirit bears, also known as Kermode bears, are a subspecies of the American black bear. The bears are not albinos but carry a recessive gene that gives one bear in ten a cream-colored coat. Spirit bears play a part in the mythologies of First Nations people and are one of three bear species—the others being black and grizzly—that give the Great Bear Rainforest its name.
Published October 7, 2010
-
Verdant Flow
Photograph courtesy A.S. Wright, ILCP
A Great Bear Rainforest river flows green, thanks to the nitrogen left behind by last season's decaying salmon.
Not only do salmon carcasses fertilize streams and rivers, but because bears and wolves drag half-eaten fish into the woods, the fish nourish the surrounding forest.
Princess Royal Island, where this photo was taken in June, is in the heart of the rainforest, yet is "close to the action," photographer Andy Wright said. "If you do a 180-degree turn you would see the tankers traveling past," he said.
(Related: "Gulf Oil Spill Pictures: Birds, Fish, Crabs Coated")
Published October 7, 2010
-
Native Resistance
Photograph courtesy Thomas P. Peschak, Save Our Seas/ILCP
A Gitga'at fisherman catches two Pacific halibut with a hand-pulled long line in the Great Bear Rainforest.
The nine Coastal First Nations are unanimously opposed to the pipeline, and a majority of First Nations tribes along the pipeline route have joined in opposition.
There are fewer than 200 Gitga'at remaining, Mittermeier said, and they and the other Coastal First Nations tribes are "so dependent on this food.
(Related, from National Geographic Magazine: PHOTOS: Scraping Bottom)
Published October 7, 2010
Latest Energy News
-
Megadam Project Galvanizes Native Opposition in Malaysia
Malaysia’s ambitious hydropower plan would remake the rain forest state of Sarawak into an industrial haven. The project has ignited protest by indigenous tribes.
-
U.S. Gas Price Spike: Blame the Long Road From Well to Pump
U.S. motorists face a rapid fuel price run-up, despite the nation’s surging oil production. Meanwhile, in the middle of the supply chain, refineries prosper.
-
Obama Pledges U.S. Action on Climate, With or Without Congress
President Barack Obama urges Congress to pursue a “bipartisan, market-based solution” on climate change, but says he will act if lawmakers don’t.
Advertisement
The Great Energy Challenge
-
Energy News and Perspective
Discover thought-provoking stories and conversation on the Energy Challenge Blog.
-
The 360° Energy Diet
Follow this plan to reduce your energy use, from using less fuel to changing what you eat.
-
Personal Energy Meter
See how you measure up, and find out how making simple changes at home can help.
ScienceBlogs Picks
Got Something to Share?
Special Ad Section
Great Energy Challenge Blog
- U.S. Monthly Crude Oil Production Hits 20-Year High
- Shell Suspends Arctic Drilling Plan for 2013
- Shale Gas and Tight Oil: Boom? Bust? Or Just a Petering Out?
- Tesla’s Musk Promises to Halve Loan Payback Time to DOE, Jokes About ‘Times’ Feud
- Focusing on Facts: Can We Get All of Our Energy From Renewables?
Sustainable Earth
-
Help Save the Colorado River
NG's new Change the Course campaign launches.
-
New Models for Fishing
Future of Fish is helping fishermen improve their bottom line while better managing stocks for the future.
-
Can Pesticides Grow Organic Crops?
The Change Reaction blog investigates in California.
