The newly studied fossils were dated to the late Pliocene, between 2.15 and 2.55 million years ago.
Two prehistoric cheetah-like species of North America are believed by some scientists to be distant cousins of giant cheetahs of ancient Europe.
This possible relationship has led some researchers to speculate that the earliest cheetahs may have originated in North America and traveled across the Bering Strait from Alaska to Siberia.
Mazák said the new finds challenge this theory, suggesting instead a Eurasian-African origin of the cheetah lineage.
For instance, the primitive dental features would have been more developed in the Chinese fossil if cheetahs had come from North America.
This leaves the question of whether cheetahs traveled across the Bering Strait the other way—from Siberia to Alaska—or if the American cheetah-like cat evolved separately, as some scientists argue.
By Any Other Name?
Deng Tao, a professor at the Chinese Academy of Sciences in Beijing, was "astonished" reading the new study.
The newly identified skull is not from a new species, he said in an email.
Deng said his team had already described this species as Sivapanthera linxiaensis. Deng said Sivapanthera is the fossil genus of the ancient cheetah—today's cheetahs belong to the Acinonyx genus.
Mazák responded that his team and Deng's team had studied different species. He argued that Deng's fossils more closely resembled the genus Panthera—which includes the tiger, leopard, jaguar and lion—than Acinonyx.
Deng's fossils were also too big to belong to a cheetah species, Mazák said, adding that Sivapanthera is not a universally accepted species.
Deng also said that the skull in the new study was not an intact original, but rather a compilation from bones of various individuals and possibly even various species.
The difference between an intact skull and a compilation is apparent from comparisons of the photos of the skull in the current study and the skulls his team studied, Deng said.
Mazák denied this charge, saying his team had carefully examined their cranium and determined that all of its parts—including teeth—belonged to the same individual.
SOURCES AND RELATED WEB SITES