That changed when two hunters hauled a metal detector to the site in July 2007 and found four metallic fragments on the depression's rim.
They called Herd, who also curates the university's meteorite collection.
"Based on the description, I was extremely skeptical," he said.
The hunters sent Herd one of the fragments, which testing confirmed was an iron meteorite. Herd and colleagues went to the site and recovered 17 more meteorites in a day.
"That told us right away that we are dealing with something quite interesting and quite unique," he said.
But the thicket of trees, especially in the midst of the summer growing season, made analysis of the crater next to impossible.
Duane Froese, one of Herd's colleagues at the University of Alberta, suggested that a type of existing aerial survey could help.
The technique is called LiDAR, a remote sensing technology that can be used to "strip" away vegetation and create images of the bare Earth beneath.
"The crater shows up beautifully as a nice, bowl-shaped structure" that measures 120 feet (36 meters) wide and 20 feet (6 meters) deep, Herd said.
Calculations based on the crater's size suggest the impact rock was about three feet (one meter) wide.
The researchers have been working with local politicians since August 2007 to secure government protection for the site.
The crater and its associated meteorites are described in the December issue of the journal Geology.
Only a handful of similar-size craters are known in the world, though calculations suggest meteorites like the one that caused the newfound crater should hit about once every five to ten years.
With the use of LiDAR, Herd said, researchers "should be able to find more of these craters" hiding beneath vegetation.
Phil Bland is a planetary scientist and meteorite expert at Imperial College London in England.
In an email, he agreed the LiDAR technique "would be a great way of finding more of the little guys."
Bland noted that due to the lack of weathering and sparse vegetation in Australia, for instance, researchers have already come close to finding the number of expected small craters there.
"This technique would give us a way of finding those little craters everywhere else. Very cool," he said.
SOURCES AND RELATED WEB SITES