National Geographic Daily News
11 comments
Chris Baldwin
Chris Baldwin

The only list Christ the Redeemer makes in my book is "Things I want to BASE jump off of."

Jamie Mcdonald
Jamie Mcdonald

"This contest will not detract from the value of the Pyramids, which is the only real wonder of the world," Egypt's antiquities chief Zahi Hawass

You gotta love this guy!

Jamie Mcdonald
Jamie Mcdonald like.author.displayName 1 Like

As the article says, "The winners were voted for by Internet and phone, American Idol style." Arguing that Christ the Redeemer shouldn't have made it is like saying Kelly Clarckson should have been beaten in American Idol by Bob Dylan. This is not a list decided on historical importance/human achievement/aesthetic beauty, it was purely decided on marketing/cell phone access. I really wish UNESCO would make a short list, 962 world heritage sites are hard to manage as an average tourist, and I hate being influenced by profit driven lists such as this one. I'm happy National Geographic at least noted the controversy, though I'd rather them just give us their top 7 list than publicize Bernard Weber's.

I'd love to hear what everyone would put on their personal top 7. Mine changes all the time, but currently I'd vote for:

1. Pyramids 2. Great Wall 3. Machu Picchu 4. Taj Mahal 5. Angkor Wat 6. Acropolis 7. Petra 8. (if pyramids don't count) Colosseum

So I left off Chichen Itza (which I would rank lower than Tikal or Teotihuacan) and Christ the Redeemer (which I'd rank lower than the Vatican) though I agree the view from up there is fantastic, but that would be a natural wonder and would need to compete with the Grand Canyon, Mt. Everest, or even another tropical beach landscape like Bora Bora.

As for bringing religion into your decision, every single one of these structures was influenced by religion, to use religion as a pro or a con based on your own beliefs would be admittedly biased.

@Roy, I see your Stonehenge and I raise you a Forbidden City, Bagan, Karnak, Teotihuacan, Potala Palace, Vatican, Mecca, and an Easter Island... haha so tough leaving these off, so many wonders to choose from.

X. Kelley
X. Kelley like.author.displayName 1 Like

Hey, I'm sorry the Christ statue was built way after constatine. Sorry about that.

X. Kelley
X. Kelley

I believe it is a wonder because it is a statue of christ ordered to be built by I think Constatine but I am a christian and I believe that it is a wonder. The other ones are great too but this one is a GREAT wonder.

Rory Gilmore
Rory Gilmore like.author.displayName 1 Like

can't believe Stonehenge didn't qualify

John M.
John M. like.author.displayName 1 Like

Is this really a deserving "wonder"? The other six have scale and complexity to wonder at, this is just a big statue on a rock.

Rory Gilmore
Rory Gilmore

@John M. Particularly since it perpetuates a myth that in turn completely ignores scientific evidence.

Jessica Caddell
Jessica Caddell like.author.displayName 1 Like

@Rory Gilmore @John M. Sir I honestly will pray for you. I don't mean that as an insult either. I don't know how anyone can live in this world today without God! The best thing is we don't have to. I leavwe you with some scripture. Please don't be quick to dismiss it instead give just a little thought. John 1:1 "In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God. He was with God in the beginning. Through him all things were made; without him nothing was made that has been made." NIV "Then he said to Thomas, 'Put your finger here and see my hands. Put your hand into the wound in my side. Don't be faithless any longer. Believe!' 'My Lord and my God!' Thomas exclaimed. Then Jesus told him, 'You believe because you have seen me. Blessed are those who haven't seen me and believe anyway.'" NLT and the most impottant one! John 3:16 "For God so loved the world, that he gave his only begotten Son, that whosoever believeth in him should not perish, but have everlasting life." KJV 

Chockadoc DotCom
Chockadoc DotCom

@John M. My thoughts exactly. Though I've never seen it in real life. Maybe we're missing something?

From the Archives

Trending News

  • Week in Space - Picture of the Pavlof volcano, as seen from space, emitting a plume of ash

    Week's Best Space Pictures

    The Ring Nebula shines, a volcano erupts, and Germans see the bat signal in this week's best new space pictures.

  • In this Feb. 6, 2011 photo made available Feb. 8, and provided by the Fire & Emergency Services Authority of Western Australia, Gosnell firefighters battles a wildfire at the rear of a house in the Perth, Australia, suburb of Roleystone. Police said at least 68 homes were lost in the blaze, believed to have been started by sparks from an angle grinder. (AP Photo/FESA, Evan Collis) EDITORIAL USE ONLY

    Australia as Climate Predictor

    As extreme weather seems to accelerate globally, scientists believe events Down Under can help explain what to look for-and guard against.

  • Cicadas on skewers in Beijing, China.

    How to Eat Cicadas

    Cicadas bugging you? See our recipe ideas for the low-fat critters, including the new candied cicada cocktail.

News Blogs

Newsletters

Connect With Nat Geo

Shop National Geographic

    SHOP NOW »

    Sustainable Earth

    More »