According to some models, Bournaud explained, galaxies' rotating disks are thought to contain only visible, ordinary matter, while dark matter lies in halos outside the disks.
When galaxies collide, the visible matter inside the disks scatters much faster than the material in the dark matter halos.
Recycled dwarf galaxies form from the scattered blobs created in the collision, so they should therefore be free of dark matter, Bournaud said.
"Only matter from the disks can get into collisional debris and recycled dwarfs," he said.
His new finding thus seems to challenge the standard theory.
Bournaud said the presence of non-baryonic dark matter in the recycled dwarf galaxies would drastically change common understandings of the mysterious stuff.
For starters, it would mean the dark matter resides inside galactic disks, not in the halos. As well, theories of how dark matter holds together the universe would fall apart.
"It is very difficult to change the assumptions on non-baryonic dark matter," Bournaud said.
If Bournaud's theory is correct, the finding would help solve another astronomy mystery: the case of the missing baryonic matter.
When the universe was born some 15 billion years ago, astronomers believe there were about twice as many baryons as are found today.
These undetected bits of ordinary matter are called the "missing baryons."
"One used to think the missing baryons were hot gas, forming diffuse halos around galaxies but not in their disk[s]," Bournaud said.
"We show that at least a large part of these missing baryons is in the disks of galaxies."
Jeremiah Ostriker, an astrophysicist at Princeton University, said Bournaud's study is very interesting but speculative.
The margin of error in the measured mass of the dwarf galaxies is large enough for a skeptic to say they contain no dark matter, he said. Theories on dark matter are still inconclusive, he added, so the dwarf galaxies could contain non-baryonic dark matter.
"These are interesting observations, and they're interesting speculations, but it's not at the level of very conclusive evidence," Ostriker said.
Free Email News Updates
Sign up for our Inside National Geographic newsletter. Every two weeks we'll send you our top stories and pictures (see sample).
SOURCES AND RELATED WEB SITES