Storms that were recorded 30 years ago as weak may actually have been much stronger, according to Landsea.
The ocean basin with the best historical record, the North Atlantic, shows the smallest increase in stronger storms. And that increase, Landsea said, can be attributed to natural variability.
The Atlantic was stormy in the 1940s, '50s, and '60s; quieted down through the mid-1990s; and is now active again. The current study only looks at hurricane activity since 1970a relatively quiet period.
Landsea also noted that an uptick in hurricane intensity due to warmer sea-surface temperatures does not match the predictions of scientific models.
According to those models, by the end of the 21st century sea-surface temperatures are expected to rise 3 to 4°F (1.7 to 2.2°C), corresponding with a 5 percent increase in hurricane intensity.
Today's 1°F (0.5°C) change in ocean temperatures should correspond to about a one percent increase in hurricane strength, which is too small for modern instruments to detect, according to Landsea.
"So either the theory is wrong, which is possible, or the data is poor or inaccurate, or some combination of the two," he said.
Curry said that although concerns about the data are valid, "in order for our conclusions to be wrong, 50 percent of the Category One and Two storms in the 1970s would have been misclassified and [actually] been Category Four. Nobody thinks the data is that bad."
According to Curry, the link between sea-surface temperature and increasing hurricane intensity was apparent in data from earlier studies.
But "we didn't do the nitty-gritty statistical and data analysis to really nail down the link," she said.
Some hurricane forecasters, including Landsea, questioned whether other factors, such as wind shear, might be driving the trend.
Decreased wind shearupper-level winds that can disrupt hurricane formationwould lead to more and stronger hurricanes.
Using statistical analysis, the new study shows that even in ocean basins where reduced wind shear plays a role, warming sea-surface temperature is the dominant driver.
"This new study really nails down that link," Curry said.
But the lack of wind shear influence still troubles Landsea.
"That doesn't fit my physical concept of how these things work," he said. "If you really get that many more Category Four and Five [storms], wind shear would have to go down."
Roger Pielke, Jr., is the director of the Center for Science and Technology Policy Research at the University of Colorado at Boulder.
He says the new study adds weight to findings of a link between warmer oceans and hurricane intensity.
He cautioned, however, that burning oil and coal to drive our cars and heat our homeswhich releases greenhouse gases into the atmosphereis not to blame for an increase in the damage done by hurricanes.
"It's important to recognize that [storm] damage is going to increase going forward, no matter what happens to sea-surface temperatures or hurricanes, as more people move to vulnerable locations on the coastline," he said.
"If hurricanes do become more intense than they have in the past, then that would be an additional factor," he added.
Free Email News Updates
Sign up for our Inside National Geographic newsletter. Every two weeks we'll send you our top stories and pictures (see sample).
SOURCES AND RELATED WEB SITES