nationalgeographic.com Tools
Search news.nationalgeographic.com  




Sponsored in part by

DE—TRASHING DENALI


It’s enough to ruin your day. You’re poking along on one of the most ravishingly beautiful trails in the world—the West Buttress approach to the ice-crowned summit of Mt. McKinley—and you trip over a bag of trash. Or a cache of discarded camping gear hidden in the snow. Or a pile of human...well, you know.


Eye in the Sky


This kind of unpleasantness right in the heart of wild Alaska—along with the throaty growl of snowmobiles, which can turn a wilderness interlude into something like the Daytona 500—has become depressingly common in many U.S. national parks as they continue to grow in popularity.

In the case of Denali National Park and Preserve, the number of people trying to climb Mt. McKinley has doubled since the mid 1980s. Officials estimate 1,250 climbers have set out for the top so far this year. “When you have that many people concentrated in an area, you have obvious concerns about waste and congestion,” says park planner Mike Tranel.

The good news is that efforts of park administrators to remind visitors of their ecological responsibilities finally have begun paying off.

“In recent years we’ve been telling people to pack out their trash, but there’s been no enforcement,” says Tranel. “Now we’ve begun handing out trash bags and urging their use, and people are complying. It’s cleaner this year than it’s been in 25 years.”

The human waste issue is a bit trickier. As of now, it’s perfectly legal to simply bury the stuff—or put it in a bag and toss it into one of the many ice crevasses that make this mountain an especially interesting place to climb. But that could change.

“We’re not sure how sustainable that practice is, so we’ve been experimenting with carrying it out,” says Tranel. “Some of the volunteer and ranger climbing parties have used a portable plastic thing that you use for solid waste, similar to what’s used on rafting trips in the Grand Canyon.” Eventually, packing it out could become mandatory.

LITTLE GROUSING ABOUT NEW REGS

Such inconveniences notwithstanding, so far there’s been little grousing about the park’s lengthening list of regulations. These include a 60-day advance registration for climbers, along with a fee of U.S. $150, which is used mostly to support educational activities. There’s been considerably more of a fuss over proposals to limit the use of snowmobiles in the park.

In April, the National Park Service banned recreational use of snowmobiles at almost all national parks, monuments, and recreational areas, including Yellowstone National Park in Wyoming—where fans, the industry, and a group of Western senators put up a bitter fight. Also prohibited last year were the use of personal watercraft such as Jet Skis from most park system areas.

Opponents of the ban called it a planned campaign by the Clinton administration to limit access to public lands, and warned that while snowmobiles were on the Park Service’s unwanted list today, campers and sport utility vehicles might be next. But the government stuck to its guns.

“Snowmobiles are noisy, antiquated machines that are no longer welcome in our national parks,” said Assistant Interior Secretary Donald J. Barry. “The snowmobile industry has had many years to clean up their act, and they haven’t.”

However, the story was different in Denali—the Athabascan Indian name for Mount McKinley. Under terms of a 1980 law that roughly tripled the size of the park, certain activities considered “traditional”—such as hunting and gathering by native and rural Alaskans—remained legal. These activities included the use of snowmobiles, which were important for such purposes as hunting and traveling between remote villages.

SNOWMOBILES LIMITED

Since then, snowmobiles have become a popular sport, a lucrative industry, and a thorn in the side of environmentalists and others who visit parks in order to get away from the sound of engines—especially ones that sound like chainsaws. The National Parks Conservation Association estimates that more than 180,000 snowmobiles are used in the National Park System each winter. Each one can emit the same level of hydrocarbons and nitrous oxide as 1,000 cars, according to the Wilderness Society.

Despite court challenges, officials at Denali last month finished closing to snowmobiles the one-third of the park that is designated as wilderness. They are now considering reductions in other parts of the park.

“It’s not our intention to eliminate them entirely,” says Tranel. “But it should be related to some resource value of the park: scenery, solitude, wilderness, wildlife viewing. If you want to do it for play, like to see who can make the highest mark on a steep slope, maybe you should do it somewhere else.”

Officials expect to have a draft plan dealing with this and other issues—such as possibly limiting airplane landings and overflights—by next winter, with a final version in place by summer.

Eye in the Sky is a weekly series that brings you the story behind the headlines using satellite imagery, remote sensing, aerial photography, and maps. This feature is developed by National Geographic News with the sponsorship of the National Imagery and Mapping Agency (NIMA) and Earth-Info. Check out maps and imagery at http://www.earth-info.org.



 Related Websites


More Information
•  At 6 million acres, Alaska’s Denali National Park and Preserve is three times the size of Yellowstone National Park in Wyoming.
•  This spring the park hosted the 2 millionth user of its shuttle bus system—which was established in 1972 to cut down on road
•  Of the approximately 1,200 people who attempt to climb Mt. McKinley every year, about half reach the summit.
•  A dozen or so have to be rescued annually—at a cost to the taxpayer of between U.S. $300,000 and U.S. $400,000.
•  Since 1933, the death rate among climbers has been approximately two per year.


More Information
YOU TOO CAN CLIMB MOUNT MCKINLEY

Climbing Mt. McKinley—at 20,320 feet the highest point in North America—used to be a major trophy in the world of mountain climbing. But now, depending upon careful planning—including choice of route—even a child can do it.

Two years ago 12-year-old Kim Yong Sik of South Korea summited with a party that included his father, becoming the youngest person to climb the mountain. In 1995 American Merrick Johnston, only a few months older at the time, became the youngest female to do it. The oldest husband-and-wife team, ages 64 and 62, did it in 1992, and the following year a blind person accomplished the feat.

“The West Buttress route is not considered technical at all,” says park planner Mike Tranel. “By mountaineering standards it’s fairly easy. The danger is the weather—which can be terribly unforgiving—and the altitude.”

About 1,200 people per year make the attempt. So far this year the success rate has been 53 percent. Frostbite, or falling off one of the trail’s narrow ridges, can be a major setback.

The odds of making it up and back safely may be increased by hiring a guide, as 26 percent of all climbers do. The cost runs around U.S. $2,500. Counting other expenses such as gear, food, and the U.S. $150 climbing fee, one can expect to spend between U.S. $4,000 and U.S. $5,000 for the attempt.

Rescues by military helicopter are free, though discussions continue about the possibility of requiring rescue insurance to defray the annual U.S. $300,000 to U.S. $400,000 cost to taxpayers.

The cemetery at the edge of the small village about 60 miles southeast of McKinley serves as a grim reminder that the mountain does not forgive the careless or poorly prepared.